FAQs about Stony Coral, Cnidarian
Related FAQs: Stony Coral ID 1, Stony Coral ID 2, Stony Coral ID
Coral ID 4, Stony Coral ID 5,
Stony Coral ID 6, Stony Coral ID 7, Stony Coral ID 8, Stony Coral ID 9, Stony Coral ID 10, Coral ID 11, Stony Coral ID 12, Stony Coral ID 13, Stony Coral ID 15, & Cnidarian
Identification, Stony FAQs 1, Stony
FAQs 2, Foods/Feeding/Nutrition, Disease/Health, Propagation, Coral Compatibility, Stony Coral Behavior,
Related Articles: Stony
What coral is this? 12/4/13
I am just wandering if you can identify these 2 corals for me?
<Nope... too poorly resolved images. B>
SPS identification 11/9/13
Hello Mr. F.
How are you?
<Fine; thank you>
Can you please help me identify the coral in the image? I think is a
Montipora but I am not sure. It is a beauty, 30 cm high and in order to take
best care of it, I need to know what is it.
<... The pic doesn't have enough detail, but this looks like some type of
robust Hydnophora at first glance>
I know it doesn't like too much flow, because part of it was in front of an
Vortech MP 40 and that part didn't opened the polyps anymore. So I moved the
pump a little bit and now seems ok.
Re: SPS identification 11/9/13
Thank you for your patience.
<And you for yours.>
LR Hitchhikers in QT - OK to transfer to FOWLR display? and
Based on my emailing with the Engineers, I've decided to transfer all life
from my smaller tank to my display tank. Why not combine households...
<Mmm, well, the Lions may well inhale the shrimp>
There are a few hitchhikers I wonder if I should have worries about with
this move. They are the stinging celled specimens in the pictures (which I
am having difficulty getting a positive ID for, based on WWM and Google
pictures), and also a hairy gorilla crab.
<... the polyps... some sort of stony coral... May be a single
Caryophylliid. See WWM re>
They will move, with the engineer gobies and peppermint shrimp (aka lunch),
to my FOWLR display which has - 2 large volitans lions, a large harlequin
tusk, a medium red Coris wrasse. A Rabbitfish and trigger will be added
<The Labrids will definitely consume the shrimp>
Should I worry that these hitchhikers will threaten my fish or otherwise
<Mmm, no. BobF>
Thanks for your opinion, Dave
I hope you can I.D. this coral...
<Have you searched the WWM stony coral family files? BobF>
Can you identify this little guy/girl ( of course you can
;-) ) 3/20/13
I thought it was now my time to probe your apparently un-exhaustive
knowledge bank. I got the (beautiful) picture of a rather cool little
guy that I found on my live rock.
The rock has been in my aquarium for over a year, but I didn't find him
(or her) until I moved all the live rock to a new 180 gallon tank. I
really like it, but I am a little afraid that it could be
some sort of aphasia,
<I forget... Heeeeee! Aiptasia>
which I will have to kill off. If it is not a pest I don't want to harm
it because I think it is really cool.
<Not a pest; well not much of one>
I have seen some other pictures on your site, and you identified them as
a non-photosynthetic stony coral, but I just wanted to be 100% sure, and
I figured you could use the picture as it seems to be a little clearer
than some of the other
pictures of similar creatures on the site.
<Is there a stony skeleton here? If so, then this is likely a single
polyp Caryo/Euphylliid of some sort, perhaps a Dendrophylliid colony
starter. Bob Fenner>
Re: Can you identify this little guy/girl ( of course you can ;-) )
wow that was a fast reply ;-) I think you are right - it is a
Dendrophylliid - looks very much like
though<t> I can't see the bas<e> of it - its in a crevice, but I did see a
couple more like it around the tank today and even one right next to it -
albeit somewhat smaller ;-)
thanks again for the quick reply
encrusting coral species 2/4/13
Just added some mushrooms to a pico tank and noticed encrusting coral on
the front of one of the mushroom rocks (see pict). Didn't see anything
in the archives that distinctly resembled it. Polyps are low profile, at
least for what I've seen under the day and moonlight LEDs.
Curious as to species and optimal care?
<... looks to be a Faviid, perhaps a Porites of some sort. Look up
husbandry on WWM>
I have a 4gal Aqueon Evolve. Tank is cycled, ammonium,
nitrate, nitrite all undetectable. pH ~8.2; have activated charcoal
filter that comes with setup, change these out monthly. Is otherwise
housing Discosoma and Ricordea mushrooms and a couple of Nerite snails.
<... Bob Fenner>
Mystery coral 1/4/13
I have a Coral and have no idea what it is. I have had several
people look at it, and even posted it on livingreefs.com. They
suggested I try here.
I purchased it a week ago, the seller said it was Leptastrea.
When I looked that up, it looked nothing like it. Another person
but the pattern for the polyps is all wrong.
I rather like the coral, and just want to make sure I am giving it the
Here is a picture with my Hawkfish photo bombing it.
The stony portions are purple, and the polyps are a pale bluish
white-they run a ring around stony protrusions. The
frag itself is about half inch square, on a cut stone plug.
Thanks in advance,
<Would like to see a larger, more-resolved image, but do I
detect hydnophores here? If so, my guess is on the family
|which LPS is this?
I got this fist sized coral [photo attached] about a week ago.
It looks like a maze coral but when I read-up from the Aquarium corals book
[by Anthony Calfo I think], there are 3-4 varieties that look almost same.
Would you be able to suggest at least an educated guesstimate for this
<A Mussid of some sort, perhaps a Lobophyllia species:
Also, the picture shows a whole fish being ingested by the coral while the
cleaner shrimp seems to be grabbing a free meal.
The fish is a 2.5” small orange spot goby who was just one day old in the
Is this very common? Would the coral have eaten the whole fish?
Are the sweeper tentacles out so much due to being in high flow area [photo
<Could be other stimulus... read the linked files above where you've been
I tried feeding this coral 2 nights ago using Cyclop Eeze
<http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=cyclop+eeze&spell=1> using a syringe.
The cleaner shrimps come rushing and get all over the coral. Would the coral
get anything in its sweeper tentacles or do I need a feeding hat to keep the
shrimps out while I feed this coral?
<... keep reading. Bob Fenner>
Leaf Plate Coral? – 6/6/12
Dear crew / Bob,
It has been many years since requesting your help, firstly because I
spent time away from the hobby after re-locating from Shanghai to sunny
Ohio, and secondly due to the vast on-line archives help which is too
often over-looked I am sure.
However on this occasion I could not find any reference to the problem;
or even definitively identify the coral or issue in question. I
presently have a 16 month old 75g with 10g sump partitioned with 4" deep
live sand and Chaetomorpha, Aqua Medic T1000 skimmer, (2) rotating bags
weekly of ½ cup carbon, main tank has (2) 150w MH 14,000K bulbs, 216w T5
actinic mix, 90lb live rock. Conditions are PH 8.0 to 8.2, Salinity
1.025, Phosphate <0.1ppm, Nitrate <5ppm, Calcium 395, MeqL 4. I do
a 20% water change weekly and have had better than my Shanghai
experience success with a healthy tank stocked with mainly LPS corals,
(2) healthy clams, Regal and Yellow Tang, (2) Allen's Damsels, (2)
Banggai Cardinals, Flame Angel (No clam issues), Orange Stripe Prawn
Goby. Now to the issue, I saw
in my LFS just South of Toledo the attached pictured 'thing.' The LFS
owner who is actually very knowledgeable and helpful could not confirm
what type of coral this was, and stated that even his supplier said that
he has only seen this very
occasionally but also could not confirm what the coral actually was. I
went home and searched on-line and found only 'similar' comparisons to
what it looks like.
The closest match I thought was possibly a Montipora, but even that did
not seem to form the same shape or surface structure of the coral in
question. So my first question would be to ask if you have seen this
type of 'plate coral'
before and if so; could you direct me to the resource information about
<Mmm, pretty sure this is a Fungiid of the genus Diaseris:
Secondly to the issue, I of course purchased the item because am
fascinated with the different things we come across within the hobby;
and it had been at the LFS for a few weeks with lots of interest but no
takers, mainly as it was not
exactly cheap. However, I thought that I would have a decent chance with
the set-up I have, i.e. parameter control and lighting. After discussion
with the LFS owner we thought that a mid-tank position would be the
suitable approach to
take thinking that this would be a light dependent coral, but not
necessarily intense lighting requirements. So I acclimated for (2) weeks
lower in the tank to start with and then moved it up to a central
location. The problem now, and was apparent in the bottom of the tank
also before movement, seems to be that the green 'lines' on the coral
are coming away from the base skeleton leaving blotchy areas of the
structure. Any assistance with the identification and subsequent
requirements would be greatly appreciated before I lose the coral
<I'd "kick up" your dosing of iodide/ate and not move these>
As always, thanks for your continuous dedication and support.
<And you, Bob Fenner>
Coral ID Help 4/28/12
First, thank you so much for your website!
<You're welcome Stacy>
My husband bought a stocked Red Sea Max tank and brought it home for me.
Wonderful gift that we had been planning on, but I thought I had time to
research what we would be putting in a tank without being thrown into the
life <fire :-)> first. Your site has been VERY helpful for me to keep all
my new babies alive. I was at a LFS the other day and found this very cool
coral. They had no idea what it was and I have not been able to find it
anywhere. It looks similar to a Galaxea coral, but it has feeding crowns
like a feather duster. Could you please help me out?
<Mmm, my first guess would be as yours, a Galaxea species. The white tips
are a clue as most Galaxea species exhibit white tips on their tentacles.
Bob may input here as well.><<Agree. RMF>>
Thank you again for all your help!
<You're welcome. James (Salty Dog)>
coral ID 1/21/12
could you guys or girls help me with an ID of a coral I
I have currently 2 pieces of it in my tank. (was given to me)
Anyway I posted the same questions in several online forum but no
one seem to have any idea.
Hope you guys can help
<Mmm, any idea of where this colony originated? Appears to be
a Faviid, perhaps of the genus Montastrea.
Coral Ids, and an update.
Hi crew, I have two corals that came in as hitchhikers on a piece
of live rock that I can't ID conclusively. They've been
in my tank for about a year now, and they've both grown out
from single polyps, about the size of pencil erasers.
Based on hours spent browsing your site, as well as many others,
and a few books too, I'm pretty sure they're both Faviids
of some sort, but I'd like to narrow it down more than that
if possible. The two corals are the green fleshy one on the left,
and the one with the pink base and blue/green polyps in the
linked picture below.
<Mmm, the green one looks like a Mussid to me; maybe a
Lobophyllia, see here: http://wetwebmedia.com/mussids3.htm
and the blue-green other, perhaps a Faviid. The image is too
poorly resolved to guess more>
Also, here's an update I'd like to share. I emailed back
in July 2009 to ask for an ID on another hitchhiker, and I was
told it was a small-polyp Goniopora. I was discouraged when I got
the ID, since I know how difficult Goniopora can be to keep, but
I did everything I could for it... I installed a refugium with
macroalgae, I fed regularly with liquid filter feeder foods,
finely chopped fresh seafood, and vitamin-enriched, freeze-dried,
finely chopped (powdered, really) seafood, and I'm happy to
report, it's thriving!
Here it is when I asked for the ID two years ago
And here it is today
<Very nice. Looks now to be a Poritid perhaps>
Thanks again for the amazing service you guys and gals provide. I
don't think I could have survived three years in the hobby
without WWM to fall back on. Keep up the good work!
<We're trying. Thanks, Bob Fenner>
Re: Coral Ids, and an
Thanks Bob. Here's a few higher resolution pictures. I used
my DSLR this time, rather than my wife's point and shoot. I
got two shots of the blue/green coral, one with the polyps open
and one with the polyps
closed. I sent the pics as attachments this time, rather than
linking to them.
<Same answers. B>
Coral ID please... Likely a
I sent this message a few days ago but it may have gotten tied up
or lost in the shuffle.
<First time I saw it, but it's been a while...>
So again thank you in advance for all the help you have given me
and any future advice you may give.
<Happy to help.>
You all are the greatest.
<Flattery will get you everywhere! Heehee!>
I have this coral, which I believe is a Montipora sp.
<I would agree.>
But haven't been able to find any pictures similar to
<Hard to tell from photos but reminds me of a Montipora Danae.
More on Montipora here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/acropt3.htm
This beautiful little coral popped up as a very welcome hitch
<Gotta love the freebie!>
The body structure is yellowish Orange. It has small, maybe 2mm,
bright green polyps. Under actinic lighting the edges glow bright
<Many Montipora fluoresce.> Am I along the right lines with
it being a Montipora sp?
<I think so.>
One photo is with actinic and daylight. The other is daylight
Thank you again for your help.