|
| |
|
FAQs about Pump Troubles/Repairs 2 Related Articles: Marine Electrical, Circulation, Aeration,
Water
Flow, How Much is Enough,
Marine
System Components, Refugiums,
Central
Filtration, Flow-through
Live-holding Systems, Refugiums, Business
Set-Up,
Related FAQs: Pump Trouble 1,
Installation/Arrangement,
Electricity FAQ 1, GFCIs
and Marine Aquariums, Marine Circulation 2, Marine
Circulation 3, Aeration, Pumps,
Powerheads,
Plumbing, Make
Up Water Systems, Sumps, Refugiums, Surge
Devices,
A nice batch of tank-raised
clownfish at last time's Interzoo. Pic by MikeK.
|

|
Rena XP-1 Problems 2/11/08
I have had one set up less than 2 months. I discovered the other day that it
wasn't working at all so I pulled it out and went to investigate. The impeller
simply will not turn in the thing. I can hear it trying too, but that's it. Like
I said, the whole unit is about 2 months old, so I am wondering what kind of
problem I'm having this early. The impeller / impeller housing was all clean...
but it just won't spin!
<Ryan, do contact Rena on this problem. Go here http://www.planetrena.com/contact-us.html>
Thanks in advance.
<You're welcome. James (Salty Dog)>
Ryan
Turn off Gen-X pumps for
Feeding? 12/22/07
Hi Bob -
<Hello, Scott V. here.>
We emailed a while back and you and your crew rule the world!
<Just a small part of it!>
That being
said:
I have a 100 gallon reef tank with a main pump (currently two Gen-X PCX-40
pumps) pushing my main water from the sump about 12 feet up and into the display
tank. There are also several pumps circulating water within the display tank. I
rigged up a timer system that turns off my main pump for feeding. I can set it
for 15, 30, 45, 60, or 75 minutes. Historically I had been turning off the main
pump for 15 minutes when feeding fish food, and 30 minutes when feeding
plankton. But recently my Sequence 3.5-amp main pump recently froze, after only
about 3 years of use. (Yes I know that pump was way too much for this system
even moving water 12 feet). So I replaced it with the two Gen-X pumps.
Although I don't really know why, I suspect that the Sequence froze because of
turning it on and off two to three times per day.
<Doesn’t help.>
What do you think? Is it a bad idea to turn off my two Gen-X PCX-40 pumps for
feeding?
<Start up is the hardest thing on an electric motor in service. But, a few times
a day is not terribly significant. It will shorten the life of the pump, but not
significantly.>
Thanks,
Carl Beels
<Welcome, Scott V.>
Re: Turn off Gen-X pumps?
12/23/07
Hi Scott,
<Hi again Carl>
Thanks for your prompt reply...I spoke with someone who knows pumps of all kinds
and he said that most pumps actually do not run all the time, and are designed
to turn off and on automatically depending on various system conditions.
<Most pumps do not run continuously, but start up is still the hardest phase on
these pumps.>
I think the pump froze because of a seal leak or possibly because it may have
sucked too much air over time.
<Likely.>
OK so now I have two questions:
1. Do you typically turn off your main pumps when you feed your reefs?
<Some do, I personally don’t. Fish get fed by dropper, as they eat more is
dropped in, nothing goes to waste. As far as feeding inverts, it will be spread
about your system anyhow.>
2. Do you use a back-check valve? This is apparently the norm in many
non-aquarium pump applications to prevent the pump from ever running dry.
The back-check valve would go next to the pump on the suction side. Seems like
that might have saved my pump.
<This is commonly used in suction lift applications, rarely utilized in aquarium
use. In this case I would not use one. Just too much restriction. Does you pump
run dry on startup? It shouldn’t in your case. Otherwise no problem restarting a
pump a few times a day. Good luck, Scott V.>
Curious Pump Issue – 11/22/07
Hello All,
<<Greetings Jackie>>
I hope you and your families have a wonderful Thanksgiving.
<<Thank you>>
I have a question related to my return pump which is a Mag Drive 9.5.
<<Okay>>
The pump has been in use for approximately 1 year. A couple of days ago I
noticed it is expelling a large amount of tiny bubbles into my main tank. Do you
know what would cause this to happen?
<<Mmm, I’ve used this brand of pump for many years with good reliability (though
I recently made a switch to the Ocean Runner line of pumps for some
applications)…if the pump is “submerged” this is likely due to air intrusion
somewhere along the plumbing line, rather than any particular fault in the pump
itself. A joint/junction somewhere may have worked loose and is “sucking air”
much like a venturi functions (only takes a very small pin-hole). It will take a
bit of investigative work on your part to find the fault. One tactic for finding
the air leak is to smear a bit of silicone grease around each joint
“one-at-a-time” to see if the bubbles stop>>
Also, should I be concerned about the health of my inhabitants?
<<In my experience, unless the bubbles are very small and very profuse they are
likely more of a nuisance to you, than anything else>>
Thanks,
Jackie
<<Happy to assist. EricR>>
Mag Drive Pump Sticking
11/3/07
I have a Supreme Mag Drive water pump (model 5 utility pump) in my sump
servicing an ETSS skimmer. It seems to get stuck and will not turn on every time
it is turned off unless I disconnect it and bang it a few times. I have taken it
apart and it seems clean inside. Any suggestions? New impeller anyway?
<I'd replace the entire impeller assembly.>
Also if I do need to replace it, should I get the same pump in terms of gal/hr
flow?
<You would have to see how much flow the ETSS Skimmer can handle. Check with
them or your manual. James (Salty Dog)>
Chiller Pump
Is Overheating My Tank! – 07/14/07
Hello there,
<<Hiya Stephen>>
I have a brand new Blueline hd-20 external pump that is being used to
pump water through my chiller and re-circulate the return water in the
tank. As seen here
http://i117.photobucket.com/albums/o46/mynd/AquaPod/chiller-2.jpg
http://i117.photobucket.com/albums/o46/mynd/AquaPod/chiller-1.jpg
<<I see it>>
The distance is short, the pump is super quiet and is working like a
charm.
<<Have heard many good things about these pumps>>
However, the casing on the pump is really hot and when I mean hot I mean
you cannot touch it for more than 5 seconds in some places.
<<Typical of a pump that does not employ a cooling fan…and one reason it
is so “quiet”>>
Because of this, when the water was in the tank tonight at 8pm it was 72
degrees.
<<Hmm...I have to wonder why you think you need the chiller>>
By 9pm after adding the water and priming the pump the temperature via
the chiller/heater rose to 77. Here it is 12:36am and the temperature in
the tank in the basement which is 75 degree, with no lights on in the
tank and no salt in the water (just distilled water) with no filtration
in the tank at all has risen to 79 degrees.
<<Quite a jump, but your picture shows this pump hooked to a pretty
small tank. You would likely not realize this kind of increase on a
larger system>>
Now, the chiller has come on and is cooling the water back down to 77.
<<Doing its job then…>>
I think the external pump is heating up the water.
<<Yup…>>
This does not seem normal.
<<Why not…it is quite “normal” for the heat energy generated by the pump
to be transferred to the water>>
If the temperature of the casing does get this hot and it is going to
continue to heat my water up and turn on the chiller now, what is going
to happen when the lights are on for 10 hours?
<<Indeed…but did you even determine the need for the chiller/this pump
beforehand?>>
The Chiller should not even be coming on now,
<<…?>>
it's going to be on 20-hours a day. I just need you to tell me if this
is normal behavior for this type of external pump?
<<It is>>
Suggestions are welcome.
<<Try placing a small desktop fan to blow on the pump…this should cool
the casing by a few degrees and limit some of the heat transfer (though
you will now have to deal with the noise of the fan)>>
Also, there is no problem with the pump. It is not making any noise, not
shaking, nothing out of the ordinary. It is brand new and other then the
heat seems to be working perfectly.
<<Even “with” the heat, I’m sure it is working as intended/designed>>
What to do?
<<Try running the tank without the chiller/just a fan to blow across the
surface of the water…you may discover you could have saved yourself some
trouble/money>>
Kind regards,
Stephen
<<Be chatting. EricR>> |
|
 |
Re: Chiller
Pump Is Overheating My Tank! - 07/14/07
Thanks for the quick reply.
<<Quite welcome>>
Just to verify things. The reason I have the chiller and external pump
is not only to cool the tank but to allow 240GPH extra circulation back
into the tank as you can see here:
http://i117.photobucket.com/albums/o46/mynd/AquaPod/grommetized-1.jpg
<<Ah yes…did get this from your earlier query>>
This Chiller also acts as a heater which auto changes based on the
temperature you set it for. This means no heater in the tank either. As
you can see I am keeping it simple, heh.
<<Indeed, and I do understand the desire to keep ancillary equipment out
of such a small display>>
I went ahead and purchased a little fan from Lowes:
<<Excellent>>
http://www.lowes.com/lowes/lkn?action=productDetail&productId=3084-48819-FB1
0-5Q. Works like a charm and I can now easily put my hand on the pump
forever.
<<Sometimes the most simple of resolutions…>>
The chiller has stopped coming on except for maybe once all day and the
temperature in the tank has remained a semi constant 77-78 degrees with
all the lights running too.
<<Yay!>>
Thanks for the information, advice and for giving me a bit of comfort
about the pump.
<<Was my pleasure to assist>>
If you post this please include the response and links if you can for
anyone that wants to see this in progress and its outcome.
<<No worries...we do post all…>>
http://www.njreefers.org/joomla/index.php?option=com_smf&Itemid=26&topic=322
3.0
Kind regards,
Stephen
<<Cheers mate. Eric Russell>> |
|
 |
Noisy Powerheads, Wavemakers 3-13-07
Dear Crew,
<Hi Guys.>
As always, thanks for your help!
<Of course.>
We have a 72G reef tank (see photo).
<Neat.>
For circulation we are running 3 MaxiJet 1200 power heads linked to a Red Sea
Wavemaster Pro. This set up creates lots of turbulent circulation.
<Yes.>
However, we notice that the power heads make a noise when they turn on as part
of the Wavemaster timing sequence. We hear this and the fish jump.
<Mmm...yes, the constant stopping and starting of the impeller, especially over
time can lead to diminished efficiency. Furthermore when is the last time the
pumps were taken out and cleaned?>
Is this sound normal?
<If they are old or in need of a cleaning yes. I would take them out and
disassemble the intake grate...check it for debris as well as clean the impeller
area. If there is calcareous algae build up, remove it.>
Is this bad for the fish?
<If the noise is sufficient enough to lead to stress, it's not a good thing.>
Is there a better way to achieve circulation?
<Personally I like closed loop systems better as they can be designed to be more
aesthetically appealing and not impart heat into the display area.>
Thanks in advance for your help.
<Anytime.>
Jan & Ellen
<AJ.>
Belching Return Pump, Possible Air Leak 2/11/07
Hi Crew,
<Hi Jason, Mich with you tonight.>
I'm having a problem with my Quiet One 6000 return pump. Once every few
minutes, it will spew a stream of bubbles into the display tank. This is
preceded by a "shhhh" noise from the pump, like the sound of opening a soda.
<Sounds like an air leak.>
The pump is external, connected to the sump by about 14" of PVC plumbing as
follows: (all 1") bulkhead -> threaded connector -> ball valve -> connector
-> union -> pump. All slip connections are PVC bonded, and all of the
threaded connections have silicone except the union->pump connector. The
bulkhead intake is 12" below the water level of the sump, and it is not
drawing air from the surface. On the return end, I have pump -> union ->
connector -> ball valve ->
nipple -> vinyl tubing -> nipple -> elbow -> bulkhead.
<First place I'd check would be the vinyl tubing.>
Any thoughts on what is happening?
<Sounds like you're drawing air somewhere.>
My particular confusion comes from the intermittent nature of the problem...
there's some sort of buildup followed by release of these bubbles from the
pump. Would a simple loose connection or small air leak cause this?
<That would be my thought. Have you tried checking for water leaks while
the pump isn't running? It may require the water to rest in the plumbing
for a while before revealing itself. The pumps may need to be turned off
for more than a few minutes, maybe a hour or so. Obviously make sure all
the exposed plumbing is dry initially.>
Thanks for any advice!
<Hope that helps! -Mich>
Jason
Bubbles in Main Tank, cavitation? 1/13/07
<Ken, Graham T. with you tonight.>
I have a 180 gallon tank plumbed into the basement which dumps into a 300 gallon
sump.
<Big sump. Good.>
The return line is 2" pvc to a hammerhead pump which pumps a head of about 12'
in 1.5" pvc to the tank. I am circulating about 3,500 gallons per hour from the
sump.
<I only see one hammerhead pump with a 2"inlet and 1.5" outlet, and it isn't
rated for that head... but I probably missed the one you have.>
I also have a closed loop moving additional water within the tank with four
returns. My issue is that I am having tiny bubbles returning from the sump to
the main tank. The sump is very calm , tiny bubbles not visible and I have tried
a return box with sponges to trap possible bubbles and multiple inlets to
decrease the intake draw of water, nothing seems to decrease the bubbles. Can my
powerful pump be chopping the water and creating air bubbles.
<That would be my guess. The large differences in pressure associated with
pumping volume at that head with induce cavitation. Cavitation, simply put, is
just water boiling because of the extreme low-pressure on the input side of your
pump. Remember, it is not just heat that makes water boil, but pressure
differential. Adding more lines to feed the tank will do little or nothing since
the low pressure is found at the impeller-housing, after the 2" restriction. The
real change must be made at the out-put stage. Unfortunately, if you do have the
pump I spec'd out (Dart), then you may be undersized to boot. Either way,
utilizing a low-speed pump, using multiple pumps, or enlarging the inlet-size of
your current pump are all ways to reduce the unsightly bubbles you generate.
HTH,
-Graham T.>
Thanks Ken
Will a MagDrive-24 Overheat My System? - 01/03/06
I would like to put a Mag-24 inside the main tank hidden in back running to
an internal manifold with 6 outlets around the internal rim of the tank (120G)
to provide only internal flow much like the one described in WetWeb.
<<This is feasible, though placing the pump "in the tank" does make for more
difficult maintenance...and you will also find it likely that six outlets are
too many for this size pump after head-loss>>
The actual question is two fold.
<<Ok>>
1. Is a Mag-24 too much pump for an average aquarium with assorted corals and
fish?
<<I guess that depends on your definition of "average"...but in this
instance/with this size tank, no, not in my opinion>>
According to most charts with all the tees and 90's I will be adding about 10 ft
of head to the pump leaving approx 1100 gph running for flow. I believe you
address this with about 350 or so at each outlet, I should be ok?...
<<Mmm, no...using these figures you will only be able to provide sufficient flow
for three outlets (these are 1/2"?). But, you may well find three outlets to be
enough>>
2. I have heard they run hot, do you know just how many degrees I may be adding
to the tank or will I be ok in this area. This is of great concern to me.
<<Adding any make/type pump will usually result in a rise in temperature...and
yes, the big MagDrive pumps can get pretty warm. Just how warm? Hmm, I think
on a tank this size with this pump you could see a 2- to 4-degree increase in
temperature. How "hot" does your tank run now? If you are at the upper limits
already (83F-84F) then yes, this pump will probably push you beyond the
"recommended" limits. But don't discount the effects of evaporative
cooling...the addition of a small fan or two to increase evaporative cooling can
normally compensate for this small increase>>
The reason to add it to the tank is to make the tank as problem proof as
possible.
<<I see...and of little consequence re "heat" issues as adding the pump to the
sump would have the same effect>>
No hoses running to and from the tank just for flow. It would be all internal.
<<Can be/has been done, though as stated it does make servicing the pump/loop a
bit more hassle>>
You guys are great by the way.
<<Thank you...tis a pleasure to assist>>
Sometimes I get information overload on here just reading to learn.....wow.
<<Hee-hee...indeed!>>
r/
Kevin
<<Kevin, unless you're already "maxed-out" on heat in your system you can
probably add the pump and deal with the heating issue without having to employ a
chiller. Regards, EricR>>
SW Pb, valves 10/03/06
Hi
<Greetings>
I have 2 mag drive 9.5 pumps. I tried to contact the company that I purchased
the pumps from and they have yet to reply to me. I was curious if I would be
able to place a ball valve on the return line... would this damage the pump in
any way....
<Yes you may. A gate valve would be a much better idea though as they provide
for finer adjustment among other positive attributes. Be aware that there is a
limit to how far you can throttle these pumps down before they will shut off or
overheat.>
thanks
<You are welcome - Emerson>
Adam Dusza
Tufa has been removed
Thanks for the informative response the other day.
<always welcome>
The Tufa rock has been removed, not only from my tank but also from my property. The vendor kindly refunded my purchase price on the returned goods.
<a good way to honor/keep a customer>
This evening I was again reading the FAQs and noticed with alarm that I have one of the well advertised and less well loved Lifegard pumps. It is presently on its second motor. <yes... the "Not-so-stainless steel" shaft that leaks>
It will not receive another. Given that the life expectancy of this circulator is certainly limited I am in the
planning stages of replacing the thing. <a great pump for freshwater though> The manufacturers rate the capacity of their pumps in the face of various head losses. Without going to engineering tables, what do you use as a rule of thumb to add head restriction for 90s and other fittings in addition to the easily measured physical lift from sump to tank?
<add one foot of head for each elbow, valve connection and ten feet of horizontal run in addition to the height>
My tank is 48 x 18 x 20 inches and came equipped with a 1 1/2" standpipe. I built an 18 Gal sump to increase the water volume a bit and to have a place to add essentials. Would you be so kind as to recommend the appropriate MagDrive (as they are available locally) to hustle all of the water around at the required rate?
<I believe that there is a mag 1100/1200 that would be quite comparable to your
Lifeguard if you are otherwise pleased with the flow>
I sincerely enjoy the fruits of your collective labors.
Cheers, from B.C., Fred.
<thanks kindly, northern friend! Anthony Calfo>
Foreign Particles in Tank/Using the Wrong Pump Pads - 09/04/06
Hello crew how are you doing? Hope you are all fine and well.
<<Hello...EricR here, and yes, doing well thank you>>
The last time I asked you a question was last year concerning my pistol
shrimp. An update on that is that I have 2 yellow watchman gobies that have
paired with this one shrimp, and that is the coolest thing in my tank.
<<Indeed!>>
Ok, I'll build into my question. Basically what happened when I first got the
tank was that the pumps were noisy, so the person from my LFS gave me some
cushioning I can put under them in the sump.
<<Some folks use rubber "mouse pads" for this...Neoprene also works well>>
Unfortunately, this material has dissolved into what looks like dust particles
and its pretty nasty.
<<Yikes!...obviously they gave you the wrong material to use>>
The problem is that these particles don't go away and are on the bottom of my
sump, and are covering significant portions of my live rock hiding a lot of
their beauty.
<<That's not good>>
I was wondering if you knew if I can get a sieve or very fine filter to
eliminate this stuff?
<<Hmm, you can try placing a filter-sock over the end of the pipe outlet from
the tank overflow>>
I was thinking of putting it in front of the return hose from the sump, so that
over time it will all be collected. Do you know if this is possible?
<<Not sure I understand what you're saying...if you mean the pump return to the
tank then no, I don't think that is practical...better to try my idea or
something similar to trap the material as it returns to/processes through the
sump>>
To give you a better description of the 'dust', it looks like small brown
strands of dust. I know there are products to eliminate cloudiness by making
smaller particles clump together, do you know if this is possible?
<<I wouldn't recommend using a flocculent here, it may do as much/more harm than
good by clustering/smothering your micro-organisms>>
I hope my question is clear, it's sort of a unique problem so I hope you
understand what I'm asking.
<<Try the filter-sock, or even placing some filter floss in the flow path
through your sump. Also, once the filter material is in place, use a turkey
baster of similar to stir up the "dust" in the display tank to help it get to
the sump for trapping/removal>>
Thanks for your time and help!
<<Regards, EricR>>
Mag Drive Pump Slowing Down 8/1/06
Hello Wet web,
<Hello Mike>
One question for you. I have a Mag drive 9.5 pump that pumps water through my
chiller 4' below my tank and back up 4'. The pump has slowed down dramatically
since I installed it (1 1/2 months ago). Are these pumps not meant to pump with
this configuration?
<I would disassemble the pump and look for blockage in the impeller
chamber. This pump has a maximum head of 14 feet and should work well with a
chiller providing the chiller lines are not restricting flow.>
Thanks for the help,
You're welcome, James (Salty Dog)>
Mike
Optimistic Flow Rates - 07/11/06
First of all great website, I've learned tons and spent hours reading posts,
thank you.
<<You're quite welcome...glad you find the site beneficial>>
I tried to find my question but had no luck.
<<Let's see if I can help>>>>
I have a 300 gal FOWLR with a 50 gal sump. I am running two twin tube hang on
the back overflows, both with twin 1" drains. I read I should be gravity
feeding 1200 GPH for each box totaling 2400 GPH to my sump.
<<Read? Where? No way on Earth you're gonna get 1200 gph to "gravity flow"
through a 1" drain. 1200 gph may be the "rated" flow on the overflow
boxes...but it's not going to happen with a single 1" drain>>
My return pump is the Mag 2400. I want high flow as I have groupers and
triggers in this tank.
<<Mmm, yes...most all fish species appreciate good water flow. Though I'm
skeptical when it comes to processing this much water through a sump. But if
the noise, bubbles, splash is not an issue with you...>>
I used 1" for everything.
<<Not big enough>>
Right off the pump I have a check-valve, spring type from Lowes and a ball-valve
on top of that all in the return line.
<<The check-valve is not a good idea. Aside from metal contamination from the
spring and the huge lose of flow incurred when using these devices, the valve
will inevitably fail at some point...usually when no one is around for a long
period. Much better to adjust your skimmer boxes, return lines, and the water
level in the sump to handle all transient water when the power is off. I'd also
like to suggest you replace the ball-valve with a gate-valve...will give you
much more "finesse" when flow adjustment is necessary>>
Then it goes up the back of the tank and tee's to the ends when I have a 90 up
then a 90 over then a 90 down and a 45 into the tank.
<<Mmm...head pressure indeed. Between the check-valve and the elbows I doubt
your getting little more than half the rated flow of the pump>>
I hope you can picture this.
<<I can>>
The problem is even with all that head pressure from 10 90-degree fittings, the
ball-valve and the 45-degree fittings, I can't run the pump at even 50% or the
aquarium overflows.
<<Not surprising. At the "most", I think you should expect 500-600 gph from the
1" drains...about half that if you want a bit of a "safety margin" or to keep
things quiet>>
I have to turn the ball-valve closed by almost half way for the tank to not
overflow.
<<Indeed>>
Will changing the return plumbing to 2" help fix my problem?
<<Ahh yes! Will improve things by a huge margin>>
Very confused, and lots of different formulas and theories.
<<Agreed...and most seem a bit "optimistic" to me where flow rates are
concerned>>
Please Help.
Thank you,
David
<<I hope I have. Regards, EricR>>
Pump Restrictions 7/9/06
Hi, how are you?
<Let me try my best Tom Leykis impersonation "Hunter.. Do you care?" - I'm fine
thanks for asking.>
I have a question about restricting your pump's output, i heard that restricting
the input can burn the motor while also hearing that restricting
the output will do no damage at all.
<No damage but will create head-loss rather quickly.>
Then the other day my LFS employee said you can not restrict a pump's outtake
too much or it will ruin the motor.
<Depends on how much back-pressure there is and if the pump is built to handle
it.>
I have been running a 20 gallon FOWLR + a cleaner shrimp with only
nitrate being my only problem, but that is kept under control by weekly water
changes of 5 gallons. However i am moving up to a 90 gallon and am running two
life guard filters (mechanical and chemical) just incase i ever need them with a
wet dry and 15 gallon refugium mainly for nutrient export and nitrate reduction.
<The canisters (mechanical/chemical media) is s detritus trap and probably the
source of your nutrient problems...you need to replace these with a large
protein skimmer.>
My main pump is a mag drive 2400. i know this is too
much but can i use it if i use a ball valve on the output to restrict the water
flow.
<Should be okay, put I would be careful as to how much you restrict it.>
Thanks Very much for any info.
<Anytime.>
A young up coming aquarist
<I'm young....or so I'm told.>
Hunter
<Adam J.>
Blueline Pump Noise 6/16/06
Hi Crew:
<Gregory>
It’s been a while since I needed to bother you guys, but…?!
I have a new Blueline pump and it is making a lot of noise. It is hard to tell
whether it is from the pump or the PVC leading to the pump. It might be
cavitation, but how to tell??
<Drain the water from this plumbing, turn the pump on and listen...>
I have a 2” drain that is eventually cut down to a 1 ½” ball valve and then the
1” input for the pump.
<... there should not be such a restriction/ball-valve in front of the pump...
this, like most centrifugal pumps made for aquarium applications is for
"pushing" not pulling... in other words, you may well have a cavitation issue>
One interesting thing (at least to me) is that when I pour my water change or
top off water near the input to the pump, the bubbles make the pump almost
silent.
<Dangerous to mix water and air together here...>
I don’t know if that means anything but thought I would mention it.
I thought these pumps were pretty quiet, so thought I would ask. Have you guys
heard anything…have any suggestions for me?? Thanks, Greg
<Mmm, you've tried opening the ball valve completely? I'd remove any intake
screens from this side of the pumps, and see if this quiets this pump down...
you may have air trapped around the impeller/volute that could account for this
noise as well... this can be a bit hard to remove, but may be able to be flushed
by pressurizing the line (like with a garden hose) while the pump is temporarily
turned off. Bob Fenner>
Regulating Pump Flow... Inadequate Factory Overflows - 06/12/06
Hi Crew,
<<John>>
I bought an Eheim 1262 to use as the return from my sump to my 90g (with AGA
Megaflow).
<<I love Eheim pumps...wish we could get some of the bigger ones over here>>
It's a great pump, but it seems too powerful for the Megaflow system.
<<Not so "Mega-", eh?>>
Actually, I should say it seems too powerful to run the Megaflow quietly - water
rushes though the system and it sounds like a dishwasher.
<<Typical of these undersized (Mega or not) factory overflow systems>>
I've read through the FAQs and this seems like a common problem.
<<VERY common>>
One suggestion that helped was to increase the diameter of the hole at the top
of the Megaflow drain tube. However, my system is still extremely noisy, unless
I pinch and restrict the flow coming out of the Eheim.
<<Replacing the Megaflow drain tube with a Durso-style standpipe might allow
both an increase in flow AND a reduction in noise...but still no replacement for
the simple want/need of a larger throughput>>
So my question is (finally) is it safe to add a ball-valve on the return side of
the Eheim, or will this produce too much back pressure and jeopardize plumbing
connections?
<<This is quite safe and satisfactory, though I would install a gate-valve as
opposed to the ball-valve for better "finesse" of the flow. Magnetic drive
pumps such as the Eheim respond to/endure this type of control/adjustment very
well. But do make sure you install the valve on the "output" side of the pump>>
Would it be better to step down to the Eheim 1260 and let it run unrestricted?
<<Not in my opinion. The plumbing lines will eventually start to restrict from
bio/mineral accumulation...but with a twist of the valve you can step up flow to
compensate>>
Thanks,
John H.
<<Quite welcome, EricR>>
Isolate vibration of closed loop pump... Newspeak re pumps, plumbing
6/6/06
I have done a lot of research into closed loop systems, I plan on installing
one on my next system.
In the many photos I see of closed loop external pumps they are almost always
plumbed right to ridged PVC pipe. I think it would be quieter and transmit less
vibration to connect the pump with some type of soft connection to isolate
vibration, I have seen just one picture of this type of setup. Your thoughts
are much appreciated.
Stephen Blalock
<... Let's see if I interpret what you seem to be looking for... I do agree with
the approach of utilizing a bit of flexible tubing at the junction mentioned...
for the purpose of reducing vibration for a few ends (most notably noise and
shimming of connectors over time, salt creep and leaking...), as well as making
a connection that can easily be broken... This being stated, the same can be
achieved by securing the pump to a stable platform, using true union couplers...
and this latter is more favorable in terms of not reducing intake (important)
and discharge flow through induced drag with the flexible plumbing and added
fittings to attach same. Bob Fenner>
Bad Pump? 6/4/06
I've got a Maxi-jet power head, and can't seem to get the water flow
started. Is there a trick to this?
<'Tis a plug and play product...if it's new return it, sounds defective.>
Pete.
<Adam J.>
Teeing off to two pump intakes - 04/27/06
Hi crew,
It may be stupid question, but I'll ask it anyway! Is it possible to tee off
two external pumps from one bulkhead fitting? If so, is it recommended?
<Mmm, in general a poor idea. Most small aquarium pumps are centrifugal,
designed to push, not pull... restricting their intake results in a loss of
efficiency, generation of more waste heat, shortened "lives". Bob Fenner>
Thanks
Scott Griswold
Tank Overheating With Many External Pumps - 04/25/06
Good morning all,
<<Hello!>>
I've spent at least a couple hours every day looking over the problems that
others have had, and this has helped me beyond words in setting up my new 150
gallon tank.
<<Mmm, yes...not repeating other's mistakes...>>
So, first I just want to say thank you for taking the time to help all of us!
<<A collaborative effort...you're quite welcome>>
I've been battling a problem with my external pumps overheating my tank. My
water temperature reaches 85+ degrees in the winter time when the ambient room
temperature is 64.
<<Wow!>>
I have an office fan blowing cool air on low from behind the canopy to keep the
temp at around 79 degrees.
<<Sounds fine...I utilize fans and a small chiller to maintain my tank at around
80F in the winter, and around 83F in the summer>>
Yesterday, we finally broke the 70 degree mark outside, and our house heated up
to around 78 degrees. I had to use both office fans on high to keep the tank
below 84 degrees, and that's without my halides!
<<Does seem excessive>>
I know that 84 degrees is tolerable by many animals, but this seems to be an
excessive amount of heat exchange when it's coming from just the pumps, and 20
degrees of heating without lights or a heater makes for a huge hurdle going into
summer.
<<Indeed!>>
Here's some info about my tank: Dimensions: 48x24x30 (LWH)
Canopy and stand are made from MDF and 2x4 constructions. The canopy has an open
back for more air flow, and 4 Ice Cap variable fans in the canopy top exhausting
any heat in the canopy. Ebo Jager 250-Watt heater - removed to determine that
this was not the cause. Pumps:
- Blueline HD70 - 1750 Gal/Hr - 290 watts (Panworld 200PS-MD70R) - Closed Loop
at the rear of tank to 1" spray bar with 1/2" tees.
- Blueline HD30 - 590 Gal/Hr - 90 watts (Panworld 50PX-MD30R) - AquaC EV180.
- Iwaki WMD 40RLXT - 1080 Gal/Hr - 1.9 Amps (218 watts?) - Tank return tee'd off
to two SQWDs so each corner of the tank has random flow towards the reef.
- Dolphin AmpMaster 4000/3000 - 3000 gal/hr through 1.5 inch pipe -1.21 Amps
(140 watts?) - Closed loop at the bottom of the tank, 1.5" tee'd into (2) 1"
pipes the go to opposite ends of a spray bar with 1/2" tees.
True flow is probably about 2000 gal/hr because of the way it's plumbed.
Lighting:
- (3) 95 Watt VHO (custom hood lacks room for 46.5 inch bulbs) (2)
50/50, (1) Actinic
- (2) 250 Watt HQI Ice Cap reef pendants with (2) 10K bulbs (halides not being
used yet)
Chiller:
- Pacific Coast 1/4 HP Chiller (not used yet, because I don't want to mask the
problem), it's rated to cool 150 gallons about 20 degrees.
This won't be big enough if I'm using it for my pumps & halides during summer.
<<I'd still give it a try before going "bigger">>
Sump:
- Sump - 25 Gallons (a little small for the evaporation rates I'm getting which
is approximately 3 - 4 gals/day.
<<May seem like a lot for this size system, but is not excessive...contributed
to by the fans...low relative humidity in your house/area>>
So, a lot of info for an implied question.
<<Mmm, yes...and no real "clues" that anything is abnormal regarding your
equipment/setup>>
Is this a normal amount of heat given my pump selection?
<<Is a lot of pumps...some heating would be expected, but generally not to the
extreme you describe>>
Are any of these pumps known for heat issues?
<<As compared to some others...no>>
I've tried plumbing my AmpMaster 4000/3000 with 2" PVC and not use the Blueline
70HD, but with 2 spray bars in different locations it was nearly impossible to
achieve the flow rates I was hoping for, because of all the Tees & 90 degree
elbows.
<<Understood>>
I've cleaned all of the intake screens, and I've positioned the pumps so their
exhaust is not impeded. None of the pumps seem hot to the touch, more like a
warm cup of coffee.
<<Hmm, curious...what about the impeller housings?>>
Any ideas would be of great help,
<<I think first you have to isolate the source causing the problem. Shut down
all but the return pump and see if the water temperature falls. If it does,
fire up the other pumps one at a time and evaluate each pump for its heat
exchange/transfer capacity. If you find the offending pump, perhaps it is an
aberration and fixing the problem will be as simple as changing it out with
another (gee, it's easy for me to spend your money <G>), or maybe scrutinize the
plumbing for something that may be contributing to excessive heat...like
excessive head/back pressure. You're only/best option at the end of the day may
be to fire up that chiller>>
Thank you!
-David
<<I'd be interested to know what you discover. Regards, EricR>>
Tank Overheating With Many External Pumps II - 04/26/06
Thanks Eric for your quick reply,
<<Quite welcome David>>
I have checked all of the impeller housings, and they all seem to be clear.
<<Okay>>
I started shutting down the pumps individually and waited several hours to see
if I could isolate the problem. I found that the
Blueline HD70 was probably the biggest contributor with a temp drop of around 5
degrees.
<<a lot>>
I went back to reading WWMedia about plumbing pressure rated pumps, and I came
across an article from Mr. Fenner explaining that these pumps want to push
rather than pull which makes
sense, but it got me thinking about the plumbing. I have more bends and elbows
on the intake side than the output side, and now I'm flashing back to a problem
I was originally having which was cavitation on the intake vinyl tubing I
originally installed.
It was completely cutting off the intake flow after a few minutes of operation.
<<Ahh...maybe on to something here...have to think starving the pumps would
certainly cause a rise in temperature>>
Now I'm planning on replumbing the intake to 1 1/2" from the bulkhead like this:
1 1/2" Bulkhead fitting---Ball Valve---barbed nipple---spa-flex---barbed
nipple---Union--1 1/2" to 1" threaded reducer---Blueline.
This will give me more to draw from, and get rid of the elbows.
<<Much better my friend...with one observation. Unless you have the valve here
to allow removing the pump (for service/replacement), I recommend you place your
valves on the "output" side. If the valve is there for servicing the pump, then
I would place it as "close to the pump" as possible>>
Anyway, thanks for putting me on the right track with isolating the
problem, and thanks to everyone there for your collaborative efforts!
<<Have no doubt you would have figured it out...but you're very welcome>>
Just a quick side note: Don't mount this pump on the backside of your stand,
because there's a lot of low-end vibration that resonates though the cabinet and
even the floor like an electric raiser on a bass drum.
<<Very true>>
Also, to further minimize the vibration from these pumps, go to a
computer store and buy a gel-filled mouse pad that would normally go under your
wrist to keep it straight when using a mouse. I put one of these under the
pump, and voila!!! Nothing but a quiet fan.
<<Indeed, I even use vibration dampening pads under my submerged pumps...this,
combined with a “short” run of spa-flex or flexible vinyl tubing at the pump
inlets/outlets can make a world of difference. EricR>>
-David
Equipment/Pumps/Cavitation 4/10/06
Hi, <Hello Mark>
You're are best hope at solving this problem. I have had a reef tank for
about 7 years now. I would now consider myself pretty experienced at all
things water/pumps/etc. I am now stumped. I have a 120gal w/55gal sump
(sump is located below main tank in basement). It's a great setup since I
can do water changes, maintenance, etc. easily. In my continuing effort to
improve things I removed the pump to my skimmer and I tapped into the main
return line (which goes to main tank) to run my skimmer. This pump can run
both w/enough power to spare. My problem is the tee I inserted inline now
causes air bubbles in show tank. I thought of inserting a "Y" instead,
however, I am not sure this will prevent air bubbles as well. Any and all
suggestions are appreciated. Thank you in advance for your help. <Mark, I
believe you are drawing air somewhere in the newly inserted "T". James
(Salty Dog)>
Best,
Mark
Equipment/Pumps 4/6/06
Hi I've read through your articles and I know I've seen one on this but
I can't seem to find it again. I have a Mad <Mag?> drive 1200 pump
connected to a downdraft skimmer. The pump will run quiet for a while then
start making a suction with gurgling noises the same way a bathtub does when
you drain it. Do you have any suggestions on how to fix this? <Sounds to
me like the pump is sucking air, water not high enough above intake.>
Thanks, <You’re welcome. James (Salty Dog)>
Danielle
Equipment/Pumps/Iwaki Complaint - 2/28/2006
Hi guys (gals)! Peter here. <James on this side.> I just wanted to let you
and other potential Iwaki pump purchasers know about my recent saga. <Shoot.>
I purchased an MD-70 (Japanese motored) via Marine Depot. When I installed the
pump, it was extremely loud - not vibration, but the fan on the back
makes a very loud "whooshing" noise. <Typical.> The second my wife walked in
from work, she said "what is that noise." The tank is in the other room, across
the house. I removed it after maybe 2 hours of operation. I contacted Marine
Depot who told me that once the pump has touched water, they can not
accept it for return as Iwaki would not accept it back. He recommended that I
contact Iwaki direct and find out if they would do a refund or exchange it
for a smaller pump which would be quieter (in his words).
So I contacted Iwaki and explained the situation. They said they would be more
than happy to swap out the pump for a smaller model - I requested
nothing for the difference in cost of the smaller pump. At this point I was
very happy as I mailed off the pump. Then 2 weeks later, I call to check on
the status. This is where it goes south. The gentleman says, "oh, it arrived
last week, but I don't know if they've looked at it yet. Let me
check and call you back." A few minutes later, I get a call and he tells me,
well, the cord is shorter than it was when originally sold, and thus,
they can not accept the pump back. <Some companies do have strict policies as
sad as it may be.>
Now those of you who have researched the Japanese motored Iwaki pumps know that
they do not come with a plug on the cord. So when I received the pump,
I went to Lowe's and bought a plug (with cord) to attach. I cut the cord on the
pump maybe 8-12 inches in order to avoid having 3 feet of excess - as I
think anyone would do? There was still a good 2 feet of slack on the pump
cord. Now they say that because the cord is shorter, that they can not
resell it and thus can not accept it back. Why don't they put a cord on the
darned thing to begin with if they don't want people altering it? IT'S A $5
CORD, HOW HARD IS IT TO ATTACH A NEW CORD? It's a $300 pump, you would think
that something this simple would be nothing compared to customer
satisfaction. I guess that doesn't matter any more.
After all of the good things I heard here about Iwaki and their pumps, I must
say I completely disagree. They may last a long time, but they are by
no means quiet (by any definition of the word) and their customer support is
terrible. Sorry for my rant, but I think others should be aware of what they
are getting into.
As for WWM - The site is great and here, customer service is top priority
(and we don't even pay anything for it). PRICELESS <Peter, thank you for the
kind words, about us anyway. I'm sure Mr. Fenner will post this on the Wet
Web. Will serve as a warning to Iwaki pump buyers not to alter the unit in any
way so as to protect the warranty and/or exchange privileges. <James (Salty
Dog)>
Best regards,
Peter
Flow Rate/Back-Pressure Issues - 02/06/06
I have never really gotten the performance I expected from my two Sequence
3600 pumps. Based on distance, I calculate no more than 8 or 9 head of
resistance which should get me at least 1200 GPH per pump. I'm lucky to get 25
percent of that.
<<Hmm, maximum head height (the point at which flow is reduced to zero) is 12
feet for this pump...and you're awfully close.>>
The manufacturer suggests the biggest problem is the 1.5" output from the pumps
is immediately "Teed" to two 3/4" return lines.
<<Ah yes! This pump is designed for high "volume" but does not seemingly deal
well with back-pressure. Teeing and reducing the line like you have done will
reduce flow greatly.>>
Would the fact that the return lines travel about 5 feet across to the bottom of
the prefilter box (and then proceed up another 3 feet), cause such a tremendous
decrease in flow rate?
<<The added friction/pressure from the reduced diameter will inhibit flow,
yes.>>
Does going from 1.5" line to two 3/4" lines do that?
<<Absolutely...if the pump can't overcome the back-pressure to keep up the
flow.>>
Would there be any benefit in putting the "T" after the five feet of diagonal
travel over to the bottom of the prefilter box so that it will stay at a 1.5"
line until it enters the bottom of the tank?
<<This would help, yes. "How much" will only be determined by giving it a
try.>>
Unfortunately, there is no possibility I can run 1.5" line into the tank as the
holes are not big enough and there is no room to expand them.
<<Mmm...I imagine this was one of the so called "reef ready"
tanks/installations. EricR>>
Re: Flow Rate/Back-Pressure Issues - 02/06/06
Thanks, you have confirmed my fears.
<<Welcome>>
I will consider a pressurized pump that might be able to fight the back
resistance, but the problem is the ones I have looked at are two big (bulky) for
my current set up.
<<Mmm, have you tried looking at the GRI pumps (Gorman Rupp Industries)? The
model 520 is quite compact and would likely fill the bill.>>
Live and learn. (By the way this was a "reef-ready" set-up from a well known
aquarium manufacturer. Their tank itself is fine but there engineering of the
plumbing has proven to be questionable).
<<Ah yes, and this is not limited to a few. Most all manufactured "reef ready"
setups have throughputs that are not suited/sized to the purpose
implied. Regards, EricR>>
Jeffrey
Trouble getting pump to restart 12/30/2005
Hi crew, <Hello Dave>
Odd thing happened today... every day I unplug my pump before feeding, to
prevent pellets from being sucked into the filter and festering... I've had
this system about a year now... and today when I plugged it back in it
wouldn't start. So, I went and got my spare from the basement, but just on
a lark I tried plugging the original back in again-- and lo, it started just
fine.
This is a small submersible pump, I have no idea what kind, it is the one
that came with my JBJ 12g Nano-Cube. FW tank.
What would cause this to happen? Is it a sign that the pump is going "bad"?
And in what way? Or is this simply a "feature" of cheapo submersibles?
My worst fear is that there is some kind of short, but if that were so then
why would it have restarted? If there is a short it's not dumping enough
current into the water to be noticeable when I... ah... stick my hand in the
water... hm...<This is why I like to see people use GFCI's on their
aquariums. As far as the pump...not unusual. They are not made to last forever
especially for how cheap they are. Try taking it apart and clean the impeller,
rinse the hole out good where the impeller assembly goes. James (Salty Dog)>
Happy new year to you all!<And to you>
Thanks,
-Dave
| |
|