Re: Scyphozoa Question, sys. - 6/21/08
Hi Bob,
<Jim>
>> some very nice, much cheaper models a couple weeks back <<
Seems
to me too many hobbyists looked at my original Jelliquarium cabinet
system when I first began marketing them, choked on the price and have
never looked at them again. I say this because everyone has in their
mind that the Jelliquarium is $10,000. hec, there is even a forum thread
that shows up in the search engines titled "$10,000, Got Jelliquarium".
Sure, my first version was $8,000+ but please understand it's was
designed with public aquarists in mind as I aspired to impress people at
that level. It has all the proper bells and whistles on it, and it's a
furniture type cabinet that contains it all. I have even designed a
larger version that is even more expensive... I also have designed a
smaller and inexpensive version, the Mini-Jelliquarium, which sells for
$2425. certainly affordable!
<Mmm... you and I have had this
conversation I recall>
I do believe based on your comment about the
Jelliquarium being 4 times as expensive as this vendor you mentioned
clearly tells me you are comparing apples to oranges. I suspect what you
saw was a $2,500 unit and you have compared it to my $8,000 cabinet
system.
<They had some for about $800 retail>
I would like to
invite you to re-visit the Jelliquarium web site (www.jelliquarium.com )
so you may review the wide range of systems and prices.
<Have seen
these... they are very nice>
BTW, I searched the InterZoo web site
and the only jellyfish related item that came up was some plastic
jellyfish toys.
<Again, I did collect the literature for you from
the outfit I saw... these may have been shown by a vendor/manufacturer
w/in another vendors space. BobF>
Jim Stime, Jr.
805-241-7140
Aquarium Design www.aquarium-design.com
MyFishTank.com
www.myfishtank.com
Midwater Systems www.jelliquarium.com
LA
Fishguys www.lafishguys.com
Re: Scyphozoa Question, sys. 6/22/08
Bob,
<Yohimbo>
>> They had some for about $800 retail <<
Well, I guess
its time to close up shop. I cant even build units for that price.
<Mmm, well... there's always freight, time waiting and more that folks
would/will have to consider... EVEN considering if some co. could
convince someone to import, get all the electrics (and avoid UL) to
conform to U.S. standards... AND there is always the quality issue. You
have a very nice product... and there are "quality" (i.e. not price,
compromise) buyers/segment to this part of the trade. I would not be
dissuaded from continuing... BUT I do want to comment that there are
MANY knock-offs in ours and seemingly all other aspects/businesses...
Some folks I know won't even attend the CIPS tradeshow (in China)...
considering that "they should at least come out of their country to copy
our products"... Cheers, BobF>
Jim Stime, Jr.
805-241-7140
Aquarium Design www.aquarium-design.com
MyFishTank.com
www.myfishtank.com
Midwater Systems www.jelliquarium.com
LA
Fishguys www.lafishguys.com
Re: Scyphozoa Question 6/22/08
Bob,
<<Big J>>
<
hey had some for about $800 retail>
It just occurred to me that this
discussion about price is being posted on your web site???
<<Yes...
all is, unless otherwise/requested>>
Looks like this imported crap is
going to put me out of business.
<<Again, I would not be so sure
here... see my prev. email...>
It just no longer makes cents to
promote myself to the aquarium hobby crowd. Seems what sells is
low-price ( like that Nano crap ) and not quality.
<Too much so
IMO/E>
I will begin to start withdrawing my advertisements, articles
and promotions to this group.
Jim Stime, Jr.
805-241-7140
Aquarium Design www.aquarium-design.com
MyFishTank.com
www.myfishtank.com
Midwater Systems www.jelliquarium.com
LA
Fishguys www.lafishguys.com
<Be seeing you, B>
Plankton
Kreisel substitute/keeping jellies? 6/18/08
Crew,
<Doug>
After reading the exchange re: jellyfish on today's FAQs
(Scyphozoa Question 6/16/08), I got a bit interested in the idea of
keeping jellies.
The biggest concern seems to be that of laminar
flow to suspend the critters in the water column and avoid having them
settle, and the design
of the Jelliquariums (a "plankton Kreisel"
design) is designed to accommodate this - but at a price point out of my
range for a tank.
<Mine too... and an extremely important point I
brought up with Jim Stime when he had first asked me re... he does have
some units with a much lower price point...>
Since frugality is the
mother of invention in the marine hobby, I instantly set to work to find
a way to achieve suitable laminar flow in a "regular"
aquarium. I
assembled a network of old lengths and tees of PVC I had lying around,
drilled some holes, and attached a Maxi-Jet with the venturi fully open
to the input and set it on the bottom of a 40 gallon glass tank, and
came up with some interesting results - I was actually able to suspend a
few test pieces of weighted plastic in the middle of the water column
after some tweaking.
<Neat!>
Now, I'm soliciting for some other
opinions here - do you think this method is feasible?
<Mmmm, I do...
might I ask how you intend to shield/cover the intake of the pumping
mechanism?>
A significant amount of bubbles were produced by this
setup, and I wasn't sure what the implications of that would be with
jellies (bubbles stuck in the bell?).
<Too likely so>
This isn't
an urgent question, so please don't stress over it - I'm sure there are
plenty of people wondering if they can put a blue hippo tang in a 55
gallon hex that warrant immediate attention :)
Thanks,
DS
<I
do think you have some good ideas going here... and a few petfish hobby
articles a-cooking. Cheers, Bob Fenner>
Catostylus mosaicus,... Jelly sel. 4/6/08 What
can you tell me about these in the captive environment? As much
as you can so I know if it is a good fit or not. (water quality,
temp parameters, feed, lighting, etc) <They are extremely
difficult to keep and can't be kept in a normal aquarium. Please see
here: http://jellieszone.com/captivejellies.htm> Thank you.
<De nada, Sara M.>
Re: Catostylus mosaicus -04/06/08 Thanks, I had already
visited that site. The issue is Temperature parameters for theses
particular jellies. There just is not available information on
temperature. I thought you might have something that I have not
already found. <My educated guess, based on the surface temps of
northeastern Australian coastal waters, is something like 75F to
80F. But if I were you, I would contact one of the public aquariums
which keeps them (successfully) and ask them at what temperature
they keep the systems they have for these animals.> Thanks for
your help! Linda <Best, Sara M.> |
Upside-Down Jellyfish: Cassiopeia spp. Systems - 2/19/08
Hello,
<Hi there!>
I am interested in purchasing an Upside Down jellyfish
<Cassiopeia spp.> for my tank, but cannot find much information on them.
<You’re very wise to do your research *before* acquiring one of these
neat little creatures!>
I have a 125 gallon SPS reef setup and was
wondering if that would be too much water movement for them.
<Yes
indeed. These jellies require low flow systems.>
I know they spend
most of the time on the substrate, but am worried the high water
movement would carry them to the overflows.
<Absolutely, even in low
flow situations, any overflows/intakes would have to be covered with
fine mesh or foam.>
Any thoughts would be appreciated.
<Cassiopeia
spp. are zooxanthellate organisms that require large, intensely lit,
mature systems, with low flow, a deep sand bed, and available
nanoplankton. Also of note is that these Scyphozoans shed stinging
nematocysts into the water, which can potentially sting you and/or any
other livestock therein. All things considered, these jellies do best in
large (over 100g) species, or biotope systems. For more information,
please see these links:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/jellysysfaqs.htm
http://jellieszone.com/captivejellies.htm >
Thank you,
<You’re
very welcome! Take care, -Lynn>
Jellyfish tank - 05/29/06
Hi, I'm planning to build a
jellyfish tank, I currently have a 150 gallon reef tank so the plan is
to build something like a refuge with no corners and slow circular
currents that uses the same water as the reef tank. In the tank I've
built and installed a Sulphur/Calcium denitrator, some time ago I
decided to reduce significantly the usage of the skimmer to improve
copepod growth (now I've lots of them, and one happy and fat mandarin
dragonet) and to keep nutrients in the water, so I think in this case it
wouldn't be so hard for the jellies to find food here.
<Depends on
species...>
I wanted to know your thoughts about this plan and also
ask you a few questions: How a jellyfish is affected by light?
<Most
not much at all>
What kind of light does they need? Any idea of the
Flow rate in the Jellyfish tank?
Thank you very much.
Andrés
Corral
México
<Please contact the site Jelliquarium.com (ask for
Jim Stime), and read here:
http://wetwebmedia.com/jellysysfaqs.htm
Bob Fenner>
Jellies, sys. 5/29/06
Hello there, I just wanted to ask if
there were any special elements or any special equipment for my
jellyfish tank.. I specialized a 20 gal to suit them and they have been
flourishing
Many Thanks,
Joe Iacovazzi
<Mmm, do write my friend Jim Stime at Jelliquarium (.com) re, and see
here:
http://wetwebmedia.com/jellyfish.htm
for the linked files above.
Bob Fenner>
Jellyfish System 9/20/05 hi Bob, <Jimbo> well, it is
the night before i drive out to Las Vegas for the Super Zoo pet
trade show to exhibit the JelliQuarium. i hope i have everything
packed :) <Me too!> i have not had much of a chance to get
all the Jellyfish things together that we spoke of as i have been
buzy getting everything for the trade show squared away but i do
want to get some stuff to you. i am working on the advertisement
for both FAMA and Aquarium Fish Magazine. you were correct about
FAMA's circulation being down, its around 10,000/ mth, AFM is up
around 50,000/ mth. i asked for Susan Steele but she was not around.
i am working with Craig Horowitz. <Good... I called re Sue...
s/w Alicia Jordan... who is heading up FAMA... said Sue had "not
elected" to move down... was consulting somewhat... I'd call
Bowtie/Fancy corp. and s/w Alicia re who in turn to speak with>
the scientific article written by Kevin Raskof i mentioned is
attached as a PDF. it is a great article. <Will take a look/see>
also attached are pictures i took of the various stages of growing
Moon Jellyfish, Aurelia aurita.... <Very nice> 2027 polyps
2031 polyps 2039 sm jelly 2040 two sm jellies
2058 current holding / growing system 2077 ephyra ( babies )
2078 ephyra ( babies ) 2097 mastigias papua sp. 2098
mastigias papua sp. have a great time in Kona next month, i will
be thinking of you in paradise :) <And joining me soon I
hope/trust. BobF> Jim Stime, jr. Resplendent Group
Aquarium Design <http://www.aquarium-design.com/>
www.aquarium-design.com MyFishTank.com <http://www.myfishtank.com/>
www.myfishtank.com Midwater Systems <http://www.jellyfishtanks.com/>
www.jellyfishtanks.com Centropyge.Net <http://www.centropyge.net/>
www.centropyge.net MACNA X <http://www.masla.com/macnax.html>
www.masla.com/macnax.html |
 
 |
 
 |
Upside-Down Jellies 2/23/06
Hey, you guys are
awesome! There is so much info on your site, I could look at this stuff
all day long--and almost have! I have a question about upside-down
jellies. I take care of a 125 gallon tank with 8 jellies in it. The
company that owns this tank has a budget on how much they can spend on
the tank so
they don't have the best set-up for it--they went the
cheap route. I am looking into getting new equipment for this tank,
tell me, if you had a 125
gallon tank with 8 jellies, what would you
get for the tank?
<...? Please see the new: Jelliquarium.com site
here>
I've been researching non-stop in books and on the internet to
get as many opinions as I can and you guys seem to know your stuff!
<Do you have the works of Dave Wrobel? Search re his name...>
So, to
be specific: What kind of substrate would you have, would you have any
plants? Would you have a protein skimmer, how about a UV
sterilizer? How about the lights, what would be the best lights for
them? What and how much would you feed them and how often would you feed
them? And lastly, I have been having a red/brown alga problem--
it
is like a sheet of alga over the top of the substrate. I stir it up
daily and that seems to help for awhile--until the next day and I have
to do it
again. I've been researching ways to treat the stuff, but
I am so skeptical because I don't want to harm them and I know how
sensitive and delicate they
are. Thank you so much for your help, it
is greatly appreciated!
Candace
<Keep searching, reading... Bob
Fenner>
Keeping upside-down jellies
4/10/06
Hey, you guys are awesome! There is so much info on your
site, I could look at this stuff all day long--and almost have! I have
a question about upside-down
jellies. I take care of a 125 gallon
tank with 8 jellies in it. The company that owns this tank has a budget
on how much they can spend on the tank so
they don't have the best
set-up for it--they went the cheap route.
<If it works...>
I
am looking into getting new equipment for this tank, tell me, if you had
a 125 gallon tank with 8 jellies, what would you get for the tank?
<...? Lighting, filtration?>
I've been researching non-stop in books
and on the internet to get as many opinions as I can and you guys seem
to know your stuff! So, to be specific: What kind of
substrate would
you have, would you have any plants?
<Soft, fine coral sand... and
yes... vascular plants from the same area as this species... might be
able to be collected...>
Would you have a protein skimmer, how about
a UV sterilizer?
<Yes to the skimmer, not likely a UV>
How about
the lights, what would be the best lights for them?
<T-5
fluorescents likely...>
What and how much would you feed them and
how often would you feed them?
<Depends on the species... are these
Cassiopeia?
http://jellieszone.com/captivejellies.htm>
And lastly, I have
been having a red/brown algae problem-- it is like a sheet of algae over
the top of the substrate. I stir it up daily
and that seems to help
for awhile--until the next day and I have to do it again. I've been
researching ways to treat the stuff, but I am so skeptical
because I
don't want to harm them and I know how sensitive and delicate they are.
Thank you so much for your help, it is greatly appreciated!
Candace
<... See WWM re controlling BGA. Bob Fenner>
Hi Bob!
Welcome back, glad to hear you had a good trip.
<Thank you my friend>
Now, that I've been polite I'll get to the questions and try to keep
them under War and Peace in length... ; )
1: After going to the
Oregon Coast Aquarium, I've been bitten by the jellyfish bug. (I can see
the <uh-oh> already. spec. the upside down
jelly Cassiopeia andromeda
(sp?).
<Cassiopeia>
I've been reading up on their care and
morphology (I believe that's the correct word)
<The study of
structure and form?>
, bright lighting as they are primarily
photosynthetic, fine sand substrate as they are bottom dwellers, light
current to aid in motion, ALL intakes covered with foam
to prevent
shredding, etc. I can get a custom tank from Tenecor (or do you know a
cheaper Kriesel (sp?) supplier?
<For stock sizes, shapes? Yes. Look
to the Links on the WWM site here>
For advice, I can contact OCA,
they're nice people and very friendly. But, I can't find supplier, do
you know of any?
<For nearer to you... Tru-Vu/Aquaplex in San
Francisco maybe. Ask your local shops if they can/will have a tank
hauled in for you>
I've thought about contacting OCA, but then again
I'm not sure how most public aquariums would respond to that kind of
thing. I do know they're planning on changing the exhibit over from
jelly's to seahorses and ceph's.
<Yes... successful public aquariums
are constantly planning, changing exhibits to attract visitors,
sponsors...>
Or, do you think it's worthwhile to talk to the LR
suppliers who operate out of the Keys, the creatures home range?
<For? Did see a whole bunch of these jellies along the shores along the
way to Key West last week>
Having acquired a scar from a jellyfish, I
can see how they'd be leery of collection, then again, from what I
understand, they're not
that dangerous, of course, I could be wrong
about that.
2: E-tailing: I've read the WWM FAQ's on business, one of
my long term goals is to get into e-tailing, and supplying local stores
with the
excess from my tanks (and eventually do that as my primary
occupation).
Any advice? People you know I could talk to about this
kind of operation?
<Lots of advice... we should define a plan of
discourse here, deal in specifics... Do you have outlines of business,
marketing plans? Very useful exercise at this junction. Another great
suggestion: work for one or more such businesses in the field, this
type/approach to reselling... very educational, telling.>
3: Not a
question, maybe something I can help you with. Let me know what
you're using as a browser, I might be able to show you how to do a
"Sorry, no one home" message.
<MSIE 5.0>
I'd be happy to return
the help you've provided me, even if only in a little way.
<Appreciate this, thank you for your help, friendship here... and
WWF/the chatforum.>
4: Any word on when CRA could be published?
<Very indefinite... sigh... Do wish I could do the Vulcan Mind and
Heartmeld with James Lawrence here... Microcosm allied with TFH... don't
know when the "editorial calendar" might catch up... or if... and do
need his/their help with editing, layout, production... costs,
distribution/sales... Thank you for asking>
Should we start a letter
writing campaign? Talk them into letting us take pre-orders? What can we
do to help to get this published?
<Will continue to dream, scheme re
this possibility. Have seen Jules pre-sell such works to offset
expenses... The editing, layout aspects are not insurmountable... Hmmm>
Thanks again!
PF
<Be chatting my friend. Bob Fenner>
Re:
Hi Bob!
> Welcome back, glad to hear you had a good trip.
>
<Thank you my friend>
> Now, that I've been polite I'll get to the
questions and try to keep
> them under War and Peace in length... ; )
> 1: After going to the Oregon Coast Aquarium, I've been bitten by the
> jellyfish bug. (I can see the <uh-oh> already. spec. the upside down
> jelly Cassiopeia andromeda (sp?).
> <Cassiopeia>
Actually, I was
wondering about acquiring the animal itself.
<<Are sold regularly,
imported from the Pacific and Atlantic>>
2: E-tailing: I've read the
WWM FAQ's on business, one of my long term
> goals is to get into
e-tailing, and supplying local stores with the
> excess from my tanks
(and eventually do that as my primary occupation).
> Any advice?
People you know I could talk to about this kind of
> operation?
>
<Lots of advice... we should define a plan of discourse here, deal in
> specifics... Do you have outlines of business, marketing plans? Very
useful
> exercise at this junction. Another great suggestion: work
for one or more
> such businesses in the field, this type/approach to
reselling... very
> educational, telling.>
Right now, I've got
nothing but vague ideas. I'll look around and see if any of
the local
marine equipped stores is hiring, or would even take part time
volunteers.
<<Make it known if I can help>>
The nearest dedicated
aquarium shop is in Eugene, about 60 miles
one way. Roseburg tends to
dry up and blow away come evening, IIRC, they one
store closes at 5,
the other at 6. Both have really small SW sections, under
6 tanks.
3: Not a question, maybe something I can help you with. Let me know what
> you're using as a browser, I might be able to show you how to do a
> "Sorry, no one home" message.
> <MSIE 5.0>
Let me ask Susie,
she's much more knowledgeable with MSIE than I am, I'm a
Netscraper.
<<Hotay>>*
> <Appreciate this, thank you for your help, friendship
here... and WWF/the
> chatforum.>
Happy to help, I just hope that
I'm giving good advice there.
<<You are... you're stating what you
know, believe to be correct, useful>>
> 4: Any word on when CRA could
be published?
> <Will continue to dream, scheme re this possibility.
Have seen Jules
> pre-sell such works to offset expenses... The
editing, layout aspects are
> not insurmountable... Hmmm>
Well, I
can think of at least 7 people right off the top of my head who'd put
down there money, maybe des could help proofread, she caught one of my
typo's a
real howler too...
<<Be chatting my friend. Bob Fenner>>
Bought a jellyfish, now what do I do? 3/303
Hey Crew,
<whassup>
Over 1 month ago I bought a 20 gallon hex to set up as a
jelly fish tank.
<hmmm... a single jelly fish I assume/hope? Yes?
Even the smallest Cassiopeia gets 6". This tank is only 12 " wide>
I
put a 304 Fluval on it and extended the outlet with flexible hose which
I drilled several holes in it and buried it under the substrate (to help
give
the jellies some lift).
<also put a coarse foam block on the
intake to protect it from getting slurped in>
Well, now I have one
upside down and one moon jelly and they both seem somewhat sluggish in
movement.
<Yikes... mixing species of stinging animals of any kind is
usually a bad
deal. Certainly so for jellies and ever more so in a
small tank>
I have been feeding DT's phytoplankton and the water
quality is just fine.
<that's interesting... because these jellies
are autotrophic. What organismal
feeding they do is on zooplankton.
Who was the rocket scientist that said they would eat phyto as a
staple?>
Should I be adding the same additives I put in my 54 corner
reef?
<I don't know... what additives are you adding to your 54?>
I just cannot seem to find any info regarding jellies and the store I
purchased them from is very reputable but seems to have limited
knowledge.
<you cannot be serious. You bought them (!) and brought
them home without knowing what they eat or the slightest clue about
their necessary husbandry?
And without doing any sort of remedial
keyword search on our archives to even the Internet abroad (there is
tons of info out there on the upside down
jellyfish specifically)...
you are instead going to let the life or death of these animals depend
on a random answer from this forum?!? Wow... serious
reality check
here. Do you know that these creatures are actually living (well... for
now) and not inanimate objects or furniture? Seriously>
PLEASE,
PLEASE, PLEASE, any advise on feeding, housing, water quality, tank
mates (if any) would be very helpful.
After all, you guys are my only
hope! Michael J. Bukosky
<"only hope", huh? Don't underestimate
yourself Michael... I see that your e-mail signature says you work in a
Lab. I'm thinking if you were savvy
enough to get hired, you are
savvy enough to do some basic research (starting with a simple keyword
search on any big search engine) then come
back to us, if you aren't
too jacked by then, to answer honest questions after you've made at
least a half-hearted effort. Please do the hobby a
favor too and have
some concept of an animal's needs before you buy it to prevent the waste
of a living resource that I assume you admired enough to
want to buy
in the first place. Case in point: I went to the first search engine
that popped into my mind (yahoo.com) and typed in "upside-down
jellyfish". That yielded 3,700 hits on the first try. Looking at that
first page, I see the scientific name of this animal is "Cassiopeia
andromeda".
Guess what happens if you type that into a keyword field
<G>? OK... now that I'm done chastising you here for your request to
have us "enable" you, I
will tell you that I have raised these
jellyfish from larvae to full adulthood in in culturing pools under
natural sunlight. You will need to
give these jellies full reef
lighting or get rid of them to someone who can or wants to invest the $
in that kind of lighting system. They feed on
nanoplankton which you
cannot pour from a bottle (Dt's phyto or zoo- subs are not suitable
prey). They need very deep fine sand (lagoonal) and they need a
mature refugium inline that has preferably been set up for 6-12 months
before you purchase the jellyfish. I'm almost certain your jellies will
be
dead within 6 months if they even see 3 months. They are currently
starving (no full reef lighting and no nanoplankton). You need to move
fast to save
them bubba. Good luck. Anthony>
- Jellyfish
Tank -
Hey Crew,
<Good morning, JasonC here...>
Over 1
month ago I bought a 20 gallon hex to set up as a jelly fish tank. I
put a 304 Fluval on it and extended the outlet with flexible hose which
I drilled many holes it and buried it under the substrate (to help give
the jellies some lift). <Yes, then you understand that these animals
really don't have a sense of direction and rely on currents to take them
from place to place.> Well, now I have one upside down and one moon
jelly and they both seem somewhat sluggish in movement. <20 gallons is a
little on the small side when it comes to sustaining good water quality.
Chemistry can go out of whack very quickly.> I have been feeding DT's
phytoplankton and the water quality is just fine. <I can't honestly
agree with this - the water quality might seem fine with you, but the
behaviour of your jellyfish tells a different story. There are many
factors which can't be measured in a test kit.> Should I be adding the
same additives I put in my 54 corner reef? <I think you should consider
a larger tank.>
I just cannot seem to find any info regarding jellies
and the store I purchased them from is very reputable but seems to have
limited knowledge. <Well, Jellyfish are not your typical aquarium fare.>
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE, any advise on feeding, housing, water quality,
tank mates (if any) would be very helpful.
After all, you guys are my
only hope! <I would just proffer that jellyfish are a challenge to keep
no matter who you are. The local aquarium here has a tank with
jellyfish, but what can't be seen through the front glass is a large,
rotating wheel in the tank [made from transparent materials] which keeps
the jellyfish from swimming into a corner and staying there. Instead
they bump into the wheel and are redirected back to the middle. So...
long story short is that jellyfish have specialized care requirements
that will probably not be met in a 20 gallon hex.>
Michael J. Bukosky
<Cheers, J -- >
- Jellyfish Tank -
Hey Crew,
<Good
morning, JasonC here...>
Over 1 month ago I bought a 20 gallon hex to
set up as a jelly fish tank. I put a 304 Fluval on it and extended the
outlet with flexible hose which I drilled many holes it and buried it
under the substrate (to help give the jellies some lift). <Yes, then you
understand that these animals really don't have a sense of direction and
rely on currents to take them from place to place.> Well, now I have one
upside down and one moon jelly and they both seem somewhat sluggish in
movement. <20 gallons is a little on the small side when it comes to
sustaining good water quality. Chemistry can go out of whack very
quickly.> I have been feeding DT's phytoplankton and the water quality
is just fine. <I can't honestly agree with this - the water quality
might seem fine with you, but the behaviour of your jellyfish tells a
different story. There are many factors which can't be measured in a
test kit.> Should I be adding the same additives I put in my 54 corner
reef? <I think you should consider a larger tank.>
I just cannot seem
to find any info regarding jellies and the store I purchased them from
is very reputable but seems to have limited knowledge. <Well, Jellyfish
are not your typical aquarium fare.>
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE, any
advise on feeding, housing, water quality, tank mates (if any) would be
very helpful.
After all, you guys are my only hope! <I would just
proffer that jellyfish are a challenge to keep no matter who you are.
The local aquarium here has a tank with jellyfish, but what can't be
seen through the front glass is a large, rotating wheel in the tank
[made from transparent materials] which keeps the jellyfish from
swimming into a corner and staying there. Instead they bump into the
wheel and are redirected back to the middle. So... long story short is
that jellyfish have specialized care requirements that will probably not
be met in a 20 gallon hex.>
Michael J. Bukosky
<Cheers, J -- >
Re: Jas/Anth jellyfish replies 3/5/03
OUCH!!!!!
Thanks for the
honesty
<do appreciate you hanging in there too... seriously>
and
I should have gave more of a description on what this set up is. I do
have compact metal halides (2) on this tank along with
a sponge on
the intake and about 2 and 1/2 inches of live sand.
<all good and
appropriate for the lagoonal species>
I have researched these
creatures on the internet as well as taken the advise from (Hoffer's)
the fish store here in Milwaukee. Rest assure I did not buy these on a
whim and I took the advise and was given the ok by one of the most
reputable store in my area.
<understood... and you realize that
that without knowing any more that a literal statement "What do I feed
these animals... you are their only hope!!!" said after the purchase, it
raised the hackles on aquarists that have seen the scenario too many
times>
After buying them I started to question the info I was given
as well as the lack of info on keeping the jellies in captivity, so
that's why I came to you guys.
<I can reassure you that some jelly
species are very well suited for captivity (although you still should
not mix species). Several are actively and commonly bred in captivity in
species tanks with live feedings (cultured brine, rotifers, etc)>
By
no way did I use your
services as a crutch without doing research on
my own.
<understood now, simply did not sound like it from the words
and tone of your first message>
No matter what form of life I am
keeping (whether it is my 3 K9's or my 4 marine tanks) would I
jeopardize that creature by giving it an unsuitable habitat. I put my
trust in a marine fish store that has never steered me wrong. They
assisted in this set up of tank and tank mates. NEVER would I have done
this without feeling that this was the proper set up.
<much
appreciated by all>
My e-mail was intended to be an e-mail as if I
was starting from square one so I would get the most info I could even
if I already knew the answer and after doing a search on your web site I
found nothing in regards to feeding or tank set up on them!
<indeed
just a miscomm from the limitations/brevity of e-mail.>
After looking
on the web, most sites tell about where they live but address no topic
of captivity.
<alas, it is because there are few species that really
can be kept by aquarists conveniently. Many would disagree with me, but
I would concede that you can keep your Cassiopeia. However, success with
aquarists and public aquaria alike comes with giving these creatures
large tanks. I reared mine at 1 per 100 gallons.>
Apparently I was
told the wrong info as to what they would eat as a staple (from the
store) and will make the changes in there diet accordingly as well as
separating the moon and up-side down jelly.
<excellent>
I can only
ask that this accompanying e-mail will be posted with my last or the
original not posted at all because I am not as irresponsible as you
gentleman make me sound. I have been successfully keeping marine life
for over 8 years and have never made a purchase without doing research
or getting the advise from my local fish store.
<will be noted for
the editor... the last message is gone and posted though>
Perhaps a
list of recommended suppliers in most large cities or an approval which
store could carry stating that they Wet Web Media approved would be
beneficial to hobbyists like myself.
<heehee... you give us too
much credit :) We are here to share opinions/information only... our bit
to help the industry is in helping to forge educated consumers, not
authorize dealers. We know that consumers (educated or not) are what
drive any industry. If enough people are prudently hesitant to buy
jellyfish, sharks, anemones, etc... then the stores will order less of
them. Market law>
I am sure that all true marine or fresh water
hobbyists would put there trust in a store if they see your approval.
(Just a thought!)
<its a humbling suggestion. Kind thanks>
I
appreciate you harsh honesty and I write this e-mail because I do
respect the advise and opinion of the Wet Web! Best Regards,
Michael
<and I am grateful for you empathy and thick skin <G>. I am going to
make a wonderful grumpy old man one day :p Until then I'll work on
honing wit. Best regards, Anthony>
Bought a jellyfish, now what
do I do? 3/303
Hey Crew,
<whassup>
Over 1 month ago I
bought a 20 gallon hex to set up as a jelly fish tank.
<hmmm... a
single jelly fish I assume/hope? Yes? Even the smallest Cassiopeia gets
6". This tank is only 12 " wide>
I put a 304 Fluval on it and
extended the outlet with flexible hose which I drilled several holes in
it and buried it under the substrate (to help give the jellies some
lift.
<also put a coarse foam block on the intake to protect it
from getting slurped in>
Well, now I have one upside down and one
moon jelly
and they both seem somewhat sluggish in movement.
<Yikes... mixing species of stinging animals of any kind is usually a
bad deal. Certainly so for jellies and ever more so in a small tank>
I have been feeding DT's phytoplankton and the water quality is just
fine.
<that's interesting... because these jellies are autotrophic.
What organismal feeding they do is on zooplankton. Who was the rocket
scientist that said they would eat phyto as a staple?>
Should I be
adding the same additives I put in my 54 corner reef?
<I don't
know... what additives are you adding to your 54?>
I just cannot seem
to find any info regarding jellies and the store I purchased them from
is very reputable but seems to have limited knowledge.
<you cannot be
serious. You bought them (!) and brought them home without knowing what
they eat or the slightest clue about their necessary husbandry? And
without doing any sort of remedial keyword search on our archives to
even the Internet abroad (there is tons of info out there on the upside
down jellyfish specifically)... you are instead going to let the life or
death of these animals depend on a random answer from this forum?!?
Wow... serious reality check here. Do you know that these creatures are
actually living (well... for now) and not inanimate objects or
furniture? Seriously>
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE, any advise on feeding,
housing, water quality, tank mates (if any) would be very helpful.
After all, you guys are my only hope! Michael J. Bukosky
<"only
hope", huh? Don't underestimate yourself Michael... I see that your
e-mail signature says you work in a Lab. I'm thinking if you were savvy
enough to get hired, you are savvy enough to do some basic research
(starting with a simple keyword search on any big search engine) then
come back to us, if you aren't too jacked by then, to answer honest
questions after you've made at least a half-hearted effort. Please do
the hobby a favor too and have some concept of an animal's needs before
you buy it to prevent the waste of a living resource that I assume you
admired enough to want to buy in the first place. Case in point: I went
to the first search engine that popped into my mind (yahoo.com) and
typed in "upside-down jellyfish". That yielded 3,700 hits on the first
try. Looking at that first page, I see the scientific name of this
animal is "Cassiopeia andromeda". Guess what happens if you type that
into a keyword field <G>? OK... now that I'm done chastising you here
for your request to have us "enable" you, I will tell you that I have
raised these jellyfish from larvae to full adulthood in in culturing
pools under natural sunlight. You will need to give these jellies full
reef lighting or get rid of them to someone who can or wants to invest
the $ in that kind of lighting system. They feed on nanoplankton which
you cannot pour from a bottle (Dt's phyto or zoo- subs are not suitable
prey). They need very deep fine sand (lagoonal) and they need a mature
refugium inline that has preferably been set up for 6-12 months before
you purchase the jellyfish. I'm almost certain your jellies will be dead
within 6 months if they even see 3 months. They are currently starving
(no full reef lighting and no nanoplankton). You need to move fast to
save them bubba. Good luck. Anthony>
Blue, Fast-Moving
Jellyfish - 8/23/03
In one of your questions, the inquirer had
seen blue jellyfish and wondered about keeping them. The picture that
was appended was of Catostylus, maybe C. mosaicus, not Cassiopeia, I
think. These little beauties need lots of wide spectrum light and
constant feeding. Good luck! TKVW
<thanks kindly for your input...
will be sure to post. Anthony>
<Note from Marina, jellyfishes are
Chris M's specialty!>
More on keeping Jellyfish - 2/9/04
Wow thank you very much for the personalized response, you guys need
raises! <Hahahahah! Raises??? Hahahahahahah. Volunteering is a reward in
itself. Please pass on all you learn. That is my reward!>
I have
attached two jpegs of what they look like that I've found through your
site and links, <Excellent!> I guess they are dyed jellyfish when they
come in different colors and from the looks of it they're not going into
my reef tank because they need cold water. <Right you are, unless you
have a method of providing their needs?? Usually said methods are
expensive and time consuming. Also, a note on the dying of animals,
never, and I mean never, should a person support a business that sells
dyed animals. Here is some information on the most commonly dyed animals
we find quite often in aquaria:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/dyedcorals.htm > The information I've
found says that they need a special tank called a "Kriesel" I believe.
<Yes. Means "carousel" in German. The tanks were originally used on
their sides for holding schooling fish, but later a researcher/aquarist
turned the tank on its side (making it vertical). If you ever get a
chance to go to the Long Beach Aquarium or the Monterey Bay Aquarium you
could get a good look at these tanks as there is a display of a Kriesel
without the fanfare (hiding of the tank)> Would this be possible to rig
a hexagon tank with low powered power heads situated on the sides
blowing a whirlpool effect? <Could rig it but I don't think this is
still an ideal setup for a jellyfish. More to it than circular current
as it were, as I am sure you read.> Or is it supposed to be more like a
rotating wheel, which would prove much harder to make? <Exactly> The
tank that was at my LFS was just a nano cube, but I'm sure that's just
for display and not intended for keeping them alive very long. <Yes. But
I can guarantee that store owner will tell anyone who will listen, that
it is no problem to keep them in any tank. That you just need to feed
them. blah, blah, blah. Good of you to do research before purchasing, my
friend. Very responsible! Thanks for the very good questions. ~Paul>
Keeping Jellyfish - 2/13/04
Hello! <Hello there, Wendy>
One
day, in a far away future, I'd like to keep jellyfish. <Cool. One day I
hope that Jellyfish keeping will be more successful> Firstly, I'm not
completely crazy (yet) or so naive that I don't understand how crazy
that statement is. <Not crazy at all. I can understand the attraction.>
I saw the display at Monterey some 10 years ago, <Ah...have you been
lately?? I work there on weekends, and we have added the Jelly as Art
show. "Amazing" is just one of the words we often get describing the
displays> have had marine tanks only 6 months, <Ah, new to the hobby,
eh? Well, welcome aboard> so expect I'm looking ahead another 10
years...and another 10 tank upgrades... (and you thought you had
expensive tastes). <Hehehe. You don't even know. Don't even get me
started. Heheheheheheeee>
My question is: has anyone done this on
anything other than a commercial scale? <Oh, I am fairly sure it is
being done> Or am I looking at a commercial scale set-up? <Probably
looking at a mix of the two. The basics are: A Kriesel tank, pumps, the
right live types of food and a lot of it. Know your animal and it needs
i.e.. water temp, very clean source water, feeding needs etc. Here is
the current source for Kriesel:
http://www.envisionacrylics.com/ from Kriesels (most jellies) to
tumblers (for moon jellies) they have it all, and it is the place we
purchase our holding tanks for our Aquarium jelly exhibits> What kind of
study do I need to undertake? <Keep on asking around, get books, ask at
the public displays. Come to the Aquarium and we can maybe get you
behind the scenes with a "Jelly" aquarist> Marine biology courses? <Not
necessary unless you plan to study them. I hope this helps. ~Paul>
Thanks!!
xx Wendy
Reply to Jellyfish keeping - 2/13/04
Thanks so much.<You are certainly welcome> The encouragement is great!
<Well, we do try to inspire and you did sound like you know that you
will need money and research to succeed. If you are realistic about the
undertaking then it makes my job that much the easier> I haven't been to
Monterey since but HAVE visited the website. <Cool. A great place to be>
I love it. <Me too> We are planning a trip to the States at Christmas...
I must add California to the itinerary. <Please do. Look me up when you
get out this way and we will see what we can do.> Behind the scenes
would be a dream-come-true. <We could put something together depending
on you interests and time> Thanks for the website!! <Thank you for being
part of it all>
Cheers <The same to you ~Paul>
Wendy (Sydney,
Aust)
Jellyfish keeping - 2/22/04
Hi Bob,
Greetings
for a great web! I'm looking for information to raise and take care
about jellyfishes in aquariums (Aurelia aurita, Cassiopeia maybe). I
live in Spain and here none sells and it's not information about it. <http://www.wetwebmedia.com/scyphozoans.htm
and
http://animaldiversity.ummz.umich.edu/accounts/cassiopeia/c._andromeda$narrative.html#food_habits
and http://www.liveaquaria.com/product/prod_Display.cfm?siteid=23&pCatId=543
and
http://www.envisionacrylics.com/> I'm trying to get information in
internet (to feed them, kind of tank, ...) , and I want to buy the books
that it can help me. I want to know more and more and more about
Aquariums since I bought one near 4 years ago. Do you know where can I
buy some books for help me, please? the basic problem is that I live in
Spain. :/ <Try to search for species in your favorite search engine.
Also, contact the husbandry departments at you favorite local public
aquarium. Most would be happy to talk about them. I would be remiss not
to add that I highly recommend leaving jelly keeping to the pros.>
Thanks a lot,
Ariadna
Jellyfish keeping
hello,
I don't understand how
to build an aquarium for jellyfish. Is it possible to get a picture or a
diagram? thanks << Wow that is thought one. Jellyfish are certainly not
recommended for most hobbyists. Although easy to care for in a proper
tank, acquiring a proper tank is difficult. I've seen some
presentations on hobbyists who were able to convert small (20 gallon)
aquariums into Jellyfish tanks by adding flexible plastic to round out
all of the corners. In good conscious I can't recommend setting up a
Jellyfish tank until you tell us more about your experience with marine
systems. They really are not the best beginner biotope and I would feel
better advising you to keep something else. >>
Email: XXXX
<< Adam Blundell >>
Re:
Jellyfish
well, I don't want to keep them, maybe in a few years,
but I participate in a forum and a question that is always asked is how
to keep jellyfish in captivity. << Okay so the real answer (I guess) is
that an empty tank, without corners is the best scenario. These can be
made and modified to include a very slow moving circular water flow.
Because these tanks are bare bottom, they usually have a side refugium
with the substrate and skimmer. >> All I want to do is to explain it to
the many people who want to know that and don't know english (we are
from Israel). You can visit us at: www.dag.co.il << Wow that is great to
see such interest in jellyfish from so far away. I wish I could be of
more help, but I'm not sure how best to describe the set up. You may
want to contact the Atlantis Marine World in New York. They have made
and displayed several small jellyfish tanks. The whole key is to have
lots of filtration taking place, and a tank without any corners or
edges. Best of luck. Adam Blundell >>
Upside down jellyfish 9/8/04
Hello.
<howdy>
I have been
planning on making a clam tank and have been designing it for over a
month. then I saw an article talking about the upside down jelly fish.
and I admit it, I want one. The tank it would go into will be shallow
with a wide bottom, gentle current flow, and bright lights. the only
problem is, according to the article, they secrete their stinging cells
in their mucus, and it can kill other animals in the tank.
<they
really do best in a species tank. muddy lagoonal set up would be nice.
Do consider some Thalassia sea grasses too for the biotope>
my
question is, are clams vulnerable to the stinging of the upside down
jelly fish?
<they would be a very unnatural combination and the
clams might easily outcompete the jellies as filter feeders. Not
recommended. Please do consider setting up a natural display>
No
dolphins were harmed in the making of this email. I did have to kill a
few baby seals though.
<ahhh... OK, Club Happy in Boise. Just Happy
in Pgh - Anthony :)>
Keeping a blue jellyfish
Ok this email will most definitely receive a scathing response but here
goes. I bought a blue jellyfish from my reputable marine store and they
admitted they didn't know much about it. They usually don't sell hard
to keep things and said to feed it DT's. << That's my advice as well. >>
The owner took one home to learn about it. I bought it on an impulse for
16 bucks and would like to do whatever I can for it. << Good deal! But
only if you are prepared with a good tank for it. >> It would have died
in someone's tank so at least I am trying to get info from you guys.
Right now it is swimming around every corner of the tank looking happy,
but you are the experts. << Corners are bad, and having rounded sides is
very helpful. Also, low water flow and lots of phytoplankton. >> This
is the neatest specimen I have ever seen. It is now my favorite over my
blue ribbon eel which all the websites said 99% would die in captivity
and I've had it 1.5 years. The jellyfish is 1.5 inches in diameter and
1.5 inches down to the 8 tentacles. It's in a 55 gallon tank with some
gobies and live rock. I also feed brine to the gobies. Pristine water
and established over a year. It doesn't seem to have any problems with
my filter intakes. Any chance of keeping this amazing creature alive for
a while? Thanks for any help. << I had one for quite a while. I think
the biggest challenge really is feeding it. I'd recommend Cyclop-eeze
(although I don't know if it will eat them), maybe very small golden
pearls, rotifers, live phytoplankton, Tahitian blend. >>
Brett
<< Blundell >>
Jellyfish
Hey Bob,
I just purchased an
upside-down jellyfish. I had never seen one before and I probably
shouldn't have bought it, but it was only
five dollars. I don't know
anything about it. Is it hard to keep alive? I assume that it is. Also,
what would I feed it? I know some
jellyfish sting, but does this one?
It has feathery branches and blue leaf-shaped appendages. It is in a
thirty gallon reef-tank. Thanks for
the advice. Joshua Burney
>>
Arrgghhh, I do hope you're not absconded by aliens in a UFO who have a
similar approach to livestock selection...
These are photosynthetic
reef animals... that need "reef type" settings to survive for any period
of time... TAKE THIS ONE BACK!
Bob Fenner