Question, Clown Loach... gen. care
4/29/08
Of late I been hook on Clown loach spending a lot of my time searching the web
trying to find as much about them as I can.
<As luck would have it, the current (May 2008) issue of Practical Fishkeeping
has a superb article by Emma Turner about these fish. Apart from running a big
aquarium store in England, she has this wonderful aquarium at home with around
30 of the biggest and happiest clown loaches you have ever seen. She knows her
stuff, and this article is essential reading. Among other topics, she stresses
the facts these fish need to be kept in reasonable numbers and must have a diet
with plenty of fruit and vegetables, not just meaty foods.>
I refuse to buy one clown loach let alone 6 until I have a tank worthy of them.
My problem is every one seem to have a different idea as to what the minimum
tank size one needed to house 6 clown loach, and nobody seem willing to say
anything about the tanks footprint measurements.
<To some extent this is because not everyone experiences these fish in the same
way. Many specimens never get very large, perhaps because of a stunting effect.
Aquarists who never see Clown Loaches more than 15 cm in length may well feel
that a tank around 250-300 litres is more than adequate. But once you've seen
really big specimens in the 20-30 cm bracket, you'll understand why tanks
between 500-1000 litres are much more sensible.>
Real-estate is priceless for big river fish that love the bottom, but how much
real-estate do they need to live long haply lives? A minimum tank size to keep 6
clown loach happy would be my hart's desire.
<If you can, and the budget is there, aim for something 500-1000 litres. If you
have to have a tank at the smaller end of that size spectrum, then quite
possibly fitting a sump would allow you to up the water volume, improving water
quality. Big canister filters and quite possibly additional aeration or
powerheads will also help by adding the flow of water. Unquestionably these fish
need filters offering turnover at least 6x the volume of the tank, and frankly
the more the better.>
With it I can see if I have room for the minimum sizes tank, and with luck a
tank far bigger then that.
<Sounds like a good plan. Do also review some of the other Loaches; there are
some superb smaller species on the market at the moment, especially among the
subtropicals. Relatively small tanks kitted out with high performance filters
and maintained at subtropical temperatures can make great homes for Schistura
loaches for example, such as Schistura sp. "Crimson", alongside which you might
keep some Danios or fast-water barbs. In the UK at least loaches are the "big
thing" at the moment, with dozens of new species appearing in stores every
years. Not all make great aquarium fish, but some do.>
Bigger is better unless it no longer fit in your house.
<Indeed! Good luck, Neale.>
Loach tank
12/2/07
I was originally going to get 6 Clown Loaches for my Oscar's big tank but
couldn't find any big enough that he wouldn't try to eat so I decided to put the
six 1-2 inch Clown Loaches I bought into a 125 gal tank with my Severum and 13
Cory Cats.
<Sounds a good plan. Clowns are fairly slow-growing though, so it may be a few
years before you're reading to trust them with your Oscar.>
I quarantine for a full month so I still have these 6 in quarantine. Well then I
found four 2" Clown Loaches all alone in a tank a few wks ago and bought them
and have THEM quarantined. I also looked online and in fish stores for Blue
Loaches (Botia modesta) awhile back and couldn't find any, so when I saw 4 3"
Blue Loaches 2 days ago I snatched them up, too. All these quarantine tanks but
they're all doing wonderful and eating great!
<Very good!>
That makes 14 small (for now) Loaches total. I unexpectedly found another 6 foot
long 125 gal tank for dirt cheap, I couldn't resist the price-do you see where
this is leading....? I don't feel I can put this many Loaches in a 125 gal with
a Severum & 13 Cory Cats (can I?) even though they grow slowly.
<At least while they're young, they'll be fine. It'll be cozy! At the end of the
day what matters is water quality: if the nitrite and nitrate levels are fine,
then a tank is 'working'. That said, the more space, the better.>
I think a "Loach Tank" is in order and am going to use the 125 gal for just the
Loaches. I'm worried about already being overstocked though because I keep
seeing "dire warnings" on online Loach sites about Loaches getting to 16". Neale
previously told me that after about 10 yrs 6-7" would be considered good growth
for Loaches in home aquaria.
<Indeed. Clowns do tend to be slow growing. I have seen very few captive
specimens over 8" in length, and specimens approaching 12" are extremely
uncommon. In my opinion, what matters rather more with Clowns is their
sociability. I'd sooner people concentrated on their need for being kept in
groups than the fact the odd specimens reach enormous sizes. If people worked
around the idea of keeping 6+ Clown loaches around 6-7" in length, it'd be a
better world.>
In your opinion, how many Loaches could I put in a 125 gal tank?
<Well, all the Clowns for a start. At least for the next 5 or 10 years! The
really big specimens are fish that are well into double-figures in terms of age.
As and when that happens, you can adjust things accordingly.>
If it makes a difference my ammonia, nitrites & nitrates always stay at zero and
I change anywhere from 5-10% every 1-2 days just to give them all fresh water.
It's probably unnecessary but it makes ME feel better (my Oscar is messy and
likes to eat).
<Sounds good. I often recommend 50% per week, but like you, I often find myself
doing small, daily water changes simply because my Panaque catfish produces so
much solid waste (wood chippings!). So long as the water quality parameters are
good, that's what matters.>
I hope I haven't already over-stocked my soon-to-be Loach tank.
There's so many places to ask questions at but I don't get answers I trust
anywhere but here.
Thank you for that and thank you for your time. If not for this WWM I don't
think this re-newed fish craze of mine would've happened!
Mitzi
<Sounds like you're having a lot of fun with your hobby. Clowns are amazing
fish, and real puppy-dogs once settled down. I visited 'Marge' the 12" Clown
loach this last week (she's featured on the Loaches Online site) and very
impressive she is too. If I recall correctly, she's something like about 20
years old. She lives with 50 of her closest friends in a nice big tank.
Definitely one of the most impressive aquaria I've ever seen. So you've made a
good choice with your new livestock. Enjoy! Neale.>
Re: Loach tank
12/2/07
I LOVE the pictures of Marge I've seen!
<She *is* darling. About the closest thing to a Fish Celebrity I've seen!
Everyone seems to know about her.>
But they also had me pretty scared when I found myself with 14 of these gorgeous
Loaches.
<My assumption is that they won't all grow to full size. A combination of social
interactions and dissolved metabolites will keep the majority (the subdominant
individuals) at a smaller size than the biggest specimens (the dominant
individuals).>
I had nightmares of them all getting as big as Marge by next Christmas and
having to move all those chunky butts into a bigger tank.
<I can't remember how old they said she was. But Clowns are said to live
anything up to 50 years. They are big, but very slow growing. They get to the 5"
size quite quickly, around 8" after about 10 years, and then very slightly
bigger each year subsequently.>
I know they grow slowly. But a general rule of using 8" for maximum sizes gives
me a number I can wrap my brain around to avoid overstocking, the 125 gal should
be fine for them for plenty of years yet.
<Exactly so.>
I'm used to Cichlids and have to keep reminding myself that Loaches *want
company.
And yes.... you're the one that got me interested in Royal Plecs and I've since
found out what Poop Machines they are-mercy! I love him though. I thought and
researched long and hard and have ordered an Eartheater to go into a 55 gal with
the Royal Plec. With that amount of "wood chippings" I need something to keep
the sand stirred up so the powerhead can push it into the filter.
<Should work. But honestly, it's easiest to keep one corner of the sand lower
than the rest of the tank, and then siphon out the chippings as-and-when. The
good news is the wood chippings contain virtually nothing except lignin, and
have zero effect on water quality.>
I may just keep those 2 in there together. Such is the dilemma I seem to have
with fish-I wanted the Plec to go in with my Oscar but couldn't find one big
enough. The Royal is so messy that I ended up having to give him his own tank
and an Eartheater lol! I ended up falling so in love with Loaches that I've now
got too many to go in with my Severum & Corys so the Loaches also end up getting
their own 125 g tank. It's to the point I'm scared to venture to the LFS. The
fish themselves are cheap compared to the big tanks they need.
<Yes indeed! That's why we recommend against Goldfish and Guppies as "cheap"
pets for children; fish really aren't cheap in any meaningful way. Sure,
maintenance costs are low, but setting up a proper tank for whichever fish you
buy will always be tens of times more expensive than the fish itself.>
I'm excited about my Loach tank though. I'm using sand and huge gnarly pieces of
driftwood with hidey holes, powerheads and big filters. They'll love the water
movement.
<Loaches are almost all mountain stream fish. The more water movements, the
better. There are some very neat powerheads with magnetic clips on sale these
days. Designed mostly for marine tanks. The magnets (like algae scraper magnets)
fix the pump onto the glass wherever you want. They're cheap and incredibly
effective.>
Thanks, Neale. Here's hoping I'm done getting 6 foot tanks as I've run myself
completely out of room now.
<Quite so! There was a story in a fish magazine here recently about a guy that
basically flooded his basement to make a gigantic aquarium. Very cool though! He
had to go swimming to clean algae off the glass!>
I trust your opinion to the point that I *always read what you have to say on
WWM about something before I take it as fact. "If Neale didn't say it, it ain't
so."
You may not feel like a Fish Hero but to so many of us scattered across
cyberspace, you are.
<Very kind.>
Mitzi
<Take care, Neale.>
Re: Loach tank
12/2/07
You're the best, Neale, thank you. I'm going to find some of those magnetic
powerheads, what a perfect solution. I've noticed the 4 Blue
Loaches are considerable pushier (with each other anyway) so maybe I'll put them
in with the Royal Plec & Eartheater.
<Sounds a good idea. Loaches are not exactly peaceful fish, but rather
hierarchical, meaning that all fish will struggle to be the "alpha" within the
group, and only once the group is settled will peace reign. This is certainly
the case with the Blue Loach (currently saddled with the unpronounceable name of
Yasuhikotakia modesta). In small groups, none of the fish is prepared to give up
on its ambitions. So you get a lot of chasing and snapping as each fish tries to
assert its right to lead the group. A bit like a Presidential Primary really.>
Just center the tank around bottom dwellers. I don't want the Clowns to get
pushed around by the bigger Blue Loaches.
<Good idea. Clowns actually handle themselves pretty well in boisterous tanks,
but erring on the side of caution is no bad thing.>
How dare you tempt me with filling a basement with water? That would be the
coolest thing. Like the underwater viewing tanks at the in Oklahoma City Zoo. I
kept thinking how much my fish would love having something like that.
<We all have dreams like this!>
Thank you for everything.
Mitzi
<You're welcome, Neale.>
Clown Loaches 8/24/06
Hi,
<Hello>
I have a clown loach that keeps rubbing across a terracotta pot piece in
the aquarium.
<What they do... are "clowns">
I gave it a water change and changed the filter and also turned the temp. from
80 to 84 degrees.
<Good>
Can you tell me why he is doing this and what I can do about it. He looks
perfectly fine.
<Is likely. Unless you see definite signs of disease, I would not be
concerned... Do know that this is a social animal... Please read here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/clownloachfaqs.htm
Bob Fenner>
Sherri
Clown loaches hiding for too long? 8/14/06
Hello there crew, My question is concerning my 55 gallon freshwater tank-
more specifically- a pair of clown loaches. I've had them for almost a year
and they are growing quickly, and keeping my snail population in check.
<Neat!>
Recently I put in a hollow piece of artificial drift wood and the opening is on
top, so now both of them have taken to living full time inside.
<Very common>
The problem is they never come back out, or at least not that I have noticed,
and after a few weeks I get nervous and pour them out.
<Mmm, no need... will come out "eventually"...>
When they come out they are really pale, the orange is totally white and the
black stripes are just light grey. Their color returns quickly but they act very
nervous if
they cant get back in. They have other places to hide in the tank, but they
don't seclude themselves the same way in those. Are they going to just sit in
there until they die?
<Nope>
or are they breeding?
<Not likely... really have to be quite large (several inches long)...>
I would appreciate your help on this one, Thanks -Julian
<I'd try offering some favored food during the lights on hours... bloodworms,
black worms, sinking tablets... and being patient. Possibly adding a third,
smaller individual may cause these two to be more outgoing. Bob Fenner>
Re: clown loach, sys., beh. 8/25/06
Hi again,
This loach had a partner clown loach when he was bought a couple
years ago but they fought a lot and the other didn't make it. I don't believe it
was due to the fighting. His other tank mate died so there is only a little 2
inch Pleco of some sort in with him. It is a 20 gal tank. Is this unhealthy for
him( stunt his growth or pine in loneliness) He seems aggressive but not a
killer. He is 5 inches now.
<Not enough room for other Botia here... but are social animals, best kept in
small odd numbers where the environment allows. BobF>
Sherri
Clown Loach sys. - 5/7/2006
Hello everyone,
<<Hi Lisa, this is Lisa!>>
I recently just cycled a new 55-gallon tank (fishless cycling). It has been
running two weeks since the cycle completed (Ammonia 0, Nitrites 0, Nitrate
almost negligible (5-10 PPM), real and artificial plants.
<<It is not still cycled unless you are still adding ammonia to feed the
bacteria.>>
I'd like to have some clown loaches in this tank eventually but am concerned due
to their susceptibility to ick.
<<They also reach a foot in length and live for more than 2 decades!>>
My plan is to introduce them (I'm thinking of three 3" loaches) into a
quarantine tank (10-gallon) for the first few weeks.
<<They won’t stay 3” for long. I would double that tank size, at least, to
house 3 Botia macracanthus for life.>>
Even if they get ick there, hopefully, with a raised temperature and if
necessary, medication, I can treat it while they're in the quarantine tank.
<<Heat alone won’t really do it.>>
My problem is what happens if they get ick when I move them to the larger 55
gallon community tank which would most likely have a slightly lower temperature
(even a couple of degrees) than the quarantine tank? Wouldn't the move, coupled
with the lower temperature change bring about the ick again?
<<If you QT properly, and rule out the introduction of the parasite to your
water, so shouldn’t worry about it being ‘brought out’. QT first, and if the
temperature is higher in the QT tank, don’t just plop them into colder water
(not due to ick, but stress in general).>>
Thanks in advance for any help/suggestions you may have. Lisa
<<A much larger tank is in order! Good luck. Lisa :)>>
Aggressive Loaches Not Clowning Around - The Most Respectfully Submitted
Email EVER! 10/28/05
Hi, Kindly accept my sincere regards for such a excellent site. I set up my
first 15g tank in July this year, did some stupid things, some wise things
(reading your site) and have finally stopped killing my fishes. In fact I now
have now a second 55g tank with 3 goldfishes and a freshwater minnow called
tiger shark
My question is regards with my 15g tank, it has a filter, heater, and is a
established tank for three months, original occupants were goldfishes now
shifted to 55g.
15g tank has two silver dollars 1.5”, 2 platy, 2 sword tails, I wanted to add
some loaches. I read extensively and come to conclusion that clown loaches were
schooling fishes and decided on a minimum of 4 fishes 1.5”. The fishes sold to
me do not seem to be clown loaches although they look like clown, this fellow
said that they are called “Rani loaches” and are same. However my problem is
that these loaches have started picking on dollars, striking at their eyes or
base of tail. This problem is now so acute that dollars are now showing signs of
stress. Kindly guide me why is this happening. If I separate the fishes which
can I put with goldfish or should I return them. Thanks Sandeep R
< I went to loaches.com and could not find any fish listed there when I searched
for rani. All loaches are not alike. Some are small and very peaceful while
others can be very aggressive and get large. Please go to loaches.com to
research the right loach for your particular tank situation.-Chuck>
Freshwater Clowns? Uhh, Clown Loaches? - 11/25/2005
I do hope you can give me some insight as to what may be going on with my
clowns....
<Clowns.... Freshwater.... I'm going to have to assume you mean clown
*loaches* here, yes?>
I have a 35gal tank and I have 4 clowns aging from 6 yrs to 12 yrs old
<These are slow growing animals, but by 12 years of age, under proper care, they
should be nearing a foot in length. These animals should be in a much, much
larger system, if this is the case.>
and I have never had any problems with them. Last night at feeding no one came
out they all are staying in there hiding spot inside an urn. Now tonight I have
lost one of my guys and I notice on him that the tips of his tail are white and
a few spots.
<Not quite enough description, here.... If these are white spots like grains of
salt, please read here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwich.htm
and the files linked at the top of that page.>
I still have 3 that don't seem to have the spots but once again no one came out
to eat.
<A bad sign.>
Also in the tank is an angel that does not seem to have any problems, so it is
confined to my clowns.
<Mm, if it is ich, it is the entire tank that is infected. But again, there's
just not enough information to go off, here.>
Where do I start and what can I do???
<Start by testing your water for ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate. Ammonia and
nitrite must be maintained at ZERO, nitrate less than 20ppm. If these are not
so, fix them with water changes. Beyond that, please read about health and
disease here: http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwmaintindex.htm
.>
Any help in this will be great. Thank you, -Dawn Tweedy
<Wishing you well, -Sabrina>
Another Clown Loach for a 10Gal? 12/16/05
Hi Crew,
<Hi, Pufferpunk here>
First off I would like to thank you for your time. I currently have a
ten gallon tank that has been set up for six months now. The ammonia level is
0, nitrites are at 0 and nitrates are <20. I have a five inch tire track eel,
a two inch silver angel, and two one inch clown loaches. Yes I do know
that all of these fish get rather large and I will be buying a fifty gallon
tank in about six months. The two clown loaches were purchased about a week ago
and are doing great. I read on your site that you should have at least three
clown loaches in a tank because they are very social schooling fish. I was
wondering if it would be a good idea for me to purchase one more small clown
loach for my tank to have a total of three or if it would be too crowded in my
ten gallon. Any advise would help.
<I would definately not buy any more fish for that tank. Even in a 50g tank,
the fish you have now will get quite large. Clown loaches can reach a size of
close to 12". I have had 2 together for a long time & they seem happy (they are
living in my 125g). It would be nice to have a school of them but even in my
tank, that wouldn't be feasible. Be sure to research the adult sizes of all
your fish before you purchase them. Also, be sure to do lots of water changes,
especially while in that small tank. I do 50% weekly, on all my tanks. ~PP>
Thank you very much, Stuart
Escape Artist Clown Loach and Eating Habits - 12/20/2005
Seasons Greetings to the Crew!
<And to you, Steve!>
I discovered a small problem this evening that may require me to tear up
my tank to rectify. So before I dig in, I thought I'd check to see if anyone
has any experience with the problem at hand.
<Alrighty, sounds like a plan.>
I have two large freshwater aquariums (650 gallons and 200 gallons)
plumbed to a common 150 gallon sump filled with bio-balls.
<Wow, can I move in?>
The sump feeds a Sequence pond pump that pushes the return through a
Hayward pleated pool filter and UV filters before dividing the flow back to the
two aquariums. The large aquarium is home to a number of medium sized gold
Severums, rose line barbs, rosy barbs, moonlight Gouramis, Juraparoids, and
large Congo tetras. The smaller aquarium is home to an assortment of small
tetras - cardinals, rummy nose, red minors, harlequin, and penguins, as well as
three large flower shrimp.
<Sounds excellent.>
On Friday I added three large 5 inch clown loaches to the big aquarium.
<You'll get a better effect with a few more - these schoolers put on
great antics in groups. And in your 650 gallon tank, I'd have no qualms
recommending a few more! Do please remember to quarantine, though, as ALL clown
loaches are collected wild, and often bring parasites with them.>
Today I was shocked to find one of these loaches swimming in the smaller
tetra tank.
<Yikes!>
After thinking through the possibilities, it became obvious that the
clown loach swam upstream through a return in the large aquarium until it found
the divide leading to the smaller aquarium and followed the current through the
1.5" plumbing into the smaller aquarium.
<Wow, what a trip....>
I understand that clown loaches enjoy eating snails and crustaceans and
so am wondering how quickly I can expect them to make a meal of my three 3"
flower shrimps.
<Mm, I doubt the loach will harass the shrimp. As long as they're not
bite-sized, they should be okay, I think.>
The smaller aquarium is filled with large landscaping rock and numerous
plastic plants and would represent a not-so-fun filled evening of tearing
everything thing out of the tank to catch the crafty clown loach. I would be
happy to leave the clown loach in the smaller tank if the shrimp had a chance of
surviving.
<For the loaches' schooling desires, better to get this fellow back into
his school, and prevent a reoccurrence of his plumbing escapades.>
Who wins - clown loach or flower shrimp?
<For now, likely a draw. I doubt the loach will have any interest at
all.>
Thanks for your advice and continued contributions to the hobby. You
guys and gals are the best.
<And thank you for these kind words!>
Sincerely, Steve in Minneapolis (current temp: 4 below zero)
<Yee-IKES! I thought it was chilly at 40 in the Santa Cruz
Mountains! If you get snow, shovel a little extra for me, okay? I sure do miss
it. Wishing you well, -Sabrina>
Clown Loaches sick or need therapy? 2/9/06
Hi-
<Hello there>
I bought six clown loaches this past fall (lost one right away but still have
5). For the first few months they were very visible in the tank and
quite active; even clicking excitedly over their algae chips.
<Ah, yes>
But for the past few months, they spend almost all of their time hiding behind a
few pieces of slate that I have in the tank. Nothing has changed in the tank -
not inhabitants or decor or plants (or outside the tank for that matter). Except
that I did have 4 Rosy Barbs when I brought them home. I'm down to one now so
I'm wondering if a lack of dither fish could be the problem?
<Yes, could be... or perhaps whatever led to their loss>
The one Rosy doesn't seem to be as active as he was either. The Corys and
Gouramis behave the same and in fact the Gouramis may be more active than they
were. The loaches don't have visible signs of Ich but could a behavior change
be a symptom?
<Yes, but you would see the spots... and quickly>
I'm especially wondering about the dither fish because I don't really want any
more fish in the tank but I would get small active
fish if you think that could be the problem.
Thanks for all your help solving puzzling fish problems!
Holli
<I would be changing more water, more frequently, checking your temperature,
water quality... to suit these fishes. Bob Fenner>
Re: Clown Loaches sick or need therapy? 2/10/06
Thanks for the speedy reply. Actually after I lost the Rosies, I increased
my water changes to at least 90% once a week.
<This is too much at one time...>
Sometimes twice. My water is too hard but it was hard for the first few months
too. I'll try the dither fish and see how they like that.
Holli
<Real good. Bob Fenner>
Clown loach no info. 2/10/06
I have a community tank consisting of tetras, a pleco, and recently the
addition of 4 clown loaches in an attempt to look after a snail problem....three
of the loaches are doing well, good colour, active, etc. However the third has
lost colour, is very faded, and spends much of it's time away from his peers,
often at the top of the tank swimming erratically. I'd read that the ammonia
could be the issue however have tested and they are 0%, like wise the ph is
good. what now?
help
Rebekah
<... water quality? Temperature? See WWM re requirements, ranges. Bob Fenner>
Sick Fish?????
Robert (Bob),
I have two fish now that seem to have the same problem... From what I can figure
out, it seems to be swim bladder disease.
<Mmm, but what is the cause/s of the swim bladder anomalies?>
Here are the symptoms.... The first fish, (Red Platy) I noticed about two
weeks ago. He would seem to rest on the bottom of the tank and occasionally make
a swim to the surface of the tank. After closer observation I noticed that he
wasn't just resting on the bottom, but seem to be having trouble swimming. By
which I mean, that it seem to take great effort to move from any given spot.
Seem to move in place. After keeping close eye on the little guy for about a
week I decided he wasn't getting any better. If anything it was worse. So at
this time I place him in a 5 gal. quarantine tank. I added 1 tsp. of Aquarium
salt and 1 tsp. of Fungus Eliminator by Jungle Labs. He's been in the quarantine
for approx. 4 days now with no visible improvement, (doesn't seem to be getting
worse either). Now I've noticed my second victim to this.... Prob. my favorite
little guy in the whole tank. It's a beautifully colored clown loach. I've been
watching him for the past two days in which he seem to rest on the bottom with
very little movement and what seem to be heavy breathing with his mouth acting
like it was gasping for air. He then decided to hide in one of the caves I have
setup. He finally came out this evening and just sat there showing the same
signs as when I saw him a couple of days earlier. I continued to watch him
through the evening and he finally came to a resting point on the bottom against
the front of the tank, ( kinda leaning toward one side... almost laying on one
side.) At this point I placed him in the quarantine tank as well.
Now for my question.... Am I correct in the diagnosis??
<Mmm, you are to be commended for your keen interest, careful observations...>
Is there anything I'm doing wrong?? ( by the way, the tank does have a few live
plants, and PH and Nitrate/Nitrite levels are all right on target) What can I do
to correct this problem?? and get my little buddies feeling well again.
<I do believe the Platy is suffering more from "genetic" causes than anything
else (not infectious, parasitic disease, nutritional deficiencies... and that it
will get better or not... of its own accord (nothing more you can really do for
it)... This livebearer does just "have problems" of this sort nowadays...
sometimes, large numbers of imported livebearers show this symptomology. And the
Clown Loach is really just doing "what Clown Loaches do"... in resting at odd
angles, breathing hard at times, hiding in castles... Not to worry here. If you
want to see it out more often, do consider adding one or two more. I would place
it/him back in his main tank.
Sincerely,
John R. Aulgur
<I am sending your note to a friend, Jeff, who is also a Clown Loach keeper. For
his comments, input. Bob Fenner>
Re: Sick Fish????? Clown Loach
Just wanted to update you on the Clown Loach situation. Unfortunately he
passed away sometime last night. I found him on his side, not breathing,
and the color in his stripes slowly fading. Checked the chemistry of the tank
and all seems fine...,(within required levels). Not sure as to what or
why he ended up this way, but as soon as I can find some more I will try
again.... (of course after doing a little more research/reading). Thank you
once again for the help.
<Ahh, sorry to hear of your loss... this does happen with Clown Loaches at
times... unfortunately. Less when they're in a group... and ones kept for months
tend to live for years... sometimes many. My thoughts are with you. Bob Fenner>
Sincerely,
John R. Aulgur
Re: Sick Fish????? Clown Loach Jeff
I concur. The Clown loaches do rest at odd angles, sometimes on their backs
or upside down! This is perfectly normal. So is the appearance of heavy
breathing. I've had three loaches for quite some time and they have always
exhibited this behavior. Bob's right about getting more, the loaches love to
school and chase each other around all day long. We started with one and he was
pretty sedentary until we added another. Our single loach would hide in
a small flower pot almost constantly until we got another. He's now grown from
1.5 inches to over six inches, so its impossible for him/her to fit
through the opening now.
<Ah, as good a response as I had hoped for>
As far as the platys, we have platys with our loaches as well and they seem to
fall ill after 6 months to a year and gradually darken, start breathing
hard and then die. No other fish in this tank seem affected. Various attempts at
treatments including salt and antibiotics in quarantine tanks
have failed to help. I have noticed that the pH can hasten this. A pH drop to
below 6.8 for more than a couple of weeks will generally result in a
fatality or two. Since you are keeping plants, your pH is probably near neutral
or slightly acidic. This might be something to look into.
<Thank you Jeff. See you soon. Bob Fenner/Dogfish>
Re: Sick Fish????? Clown Loach Jeff
Thank you for you quick response. Really helped to have someone who is more
knowledgeable put my mind at easy quickly. Once again, thank you for your help
and quick response.
Sincerely,
John R. Aulgur
<A pleasure. And you did receive the response from Jeff? I cut/pasted it below.
Bob Fenner>
Sick clown loach
Hi
I have two clown loaches in my aquarium for the last 2 weeks. Today I found him
lying on the bottom of the tank and the colour in his stripes are slowly
fading. I know clown loaches are prone to lying on the bottom of the tank
looking dead but it is the fading colour that is worrying me.
Do you have any idea what may be wrong with my loach??
<Very very likely nothing is wrong at all... Clown Loaches are
notorious/well-known for both their brilliant, delightful coloring, markings AND
clown-like behavior... Do check your water quality, perhaps offer some favorite
food (like blood worms, tubificids...) and don't worry. If the other loach looks
fine, and neither have symptoms of outright disease, they're likely fine. Am
sending your note to our resident loach-man, Jeff, for his input. Bob Fenner>
Thanks
Lisa
Re: sick clown loach
Hi Robert
My clown loach died today however the other one is still healthy and swimming
around normally so hopefully it will stay healthy. The one that
died seemed to be smaller and had lost weight since we bought it.
Lisa
<Sorry to read of your loss. Have witnessed these mortalities in newly acquired
Clown Loaches... consider that "something", likely parasitic or infectious, is
wrong internally... not catching in most all cases. Bob Fenner>
Clown Loach Question
About two months ago I purchased a large (4-5") Clown Loach to add to my 72
gal bowfront aquarium. About 2-3 weeks ago he developed black spots over his
body?
<Don't know, does it?>
None of the other fish (5 Gouramis/5 Corys/1 pictus cat/2 balas) developed
black spots. All the fish, including the loach continue to eat fine (dry
flakes/fresh worms).
<I see>
The water is clear, the ammonia and nitrate are basically nil. The water is
6.7ph. I do about 15% water changes every two weeks and vacuum the bottom. The
live plants are not only doing well, I have a great crop of baby plants coming
up.
<Sounds good>
But I have a black spotted clown loach? The spots do not look like any type of
parasite. Once in a while the loach will rub against some sandstone rocks, but
its very infrequent (almost only for a couple of days after I change the
water)?
<Nothing to worry about in my estimation. This fish species does "scratch" quite
a bit... and I've seen these "melanin" markings in them as well>
So are the black spots dangerous to the other fish? Is there anything I should
do?
<Enjoy your fish/es... Perhaps get it a pal... they are social animals... maybe
a nice "castle" or other dark hiding, fun place for it to hang... Bob Fenner>
I appreciate any information you can provide me. Thanks - Mark Corrinet.
Re: Clown Loach Question
Thanks for the assistance. Your prior advise on the lighting for the tank
worked very well also. My 5 year old son loves the tank.
<Ah, good>
I am relieved that the clown is ok. I want to purchase him some friends, but
large clown loaches are rare on the coast were I live and I have had a standing
order for two more. So hopefully he will have more friends soon. There are lots
of hiding places for him so that's not a problem.
<Small companions would be fine here as well... and do grow quite quickly>
One other question. I want to add more fish to the tank, but anything small dies
a rather sad death due to the pictus cat (4-5") (as I found out to late with ten
neon tetras) and anything gentle like mollies or similar get stomped on by the
Gouramis. They beat my beta almost to death before I saved him
and moved him to another tank (bad reason, but I did get another aquarium out of
it). I don't particularly like cichlids. Is there anything else I could
add that you might suggest?
<Many things. Please consider the many Barbs, larger Danios... maybe even a
freshwater "Shark". Please read here re:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwsubwebindex.htm>
Also could I add one of those green puffer fish? Can they live in non-brackish
water? I know the puffers can nip fins (probably serve the Gouramis
right), I would say it would be even money if the puffer can hold his own. (the
Gouramis are one of the big blues, a white/gold color and three small grey
blues.
<I don't recommend a freshwater or more brackish water Puffer for your system...
too much trouble, possible aggression. Stick with more easygoing, hardier
species here>
Thanks for your continued kindness and information. Take care - Mark.
<You're welcome my friend. Bob Fenner>
Clown loaches for snail control
<Ananda here tonight, answering the freshwater fish questions...>
hi guys need your help again if you do not mind .
<Not at all -- that's what we're here for.>
100,s of stinking snails. these are the cone shaped type not sure of scientific
name.
<Probably the ones commonly called "Malaysian trumpet snails".>
guy at local fish store said clown loaches will not eat them shells too hard
<Baloney. My clown loaches eat these all the time. They don't need to crush the
shells; loaches suck the snail out of the shell.>
want to refrain from chem.s- he suggested a product called had-a-snail.
<I'm surprised he's trying to sell you chemicals rather than more fish.>
at my wits end heeeeeeelp meeeee rocky
<Check out our loaches page and its associated FAQs:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/cobitids.htm
...also http://www.loaches.com has much
info from loach fans. --Ananda>
Clown loach playing with black gravel -- pics? (03/02/03)
This may be a rather bizarre question, but I'm sure I saw a series of photos
of Clown Loaches that were moving black pebbles to the floor of their cave. Most
of the gravel in the tank was a different color and they seemingly wanted the
black gravel in their cave. I thought there was a link from this site to the
series of photos, but I have searched every way I know how and I can't find it
anywhere on the web. Have you seen these photos?
<Nope, and I didn't have any luck in my searches, either. I'd check at
www.loaches.com and post on their boards -- someone there might have seen or
heard of these photos. --Ananda>
Loach party? (06/10/03)
Hiya campers!
<Hi! Ananda camping out in front of the computer tonight...>
I purchased some plants about a month ago, and while the peeps in the store
SWORE there were no snails in that tank, obviously there were as I have
apparently become a snail breeder (ick).
<Unless, of course, you have puffers or loaches! Since I have both, I actually
have a snail farm tank.>
Someone recommended loaches, and I went to the good LFS (which is 40 min.s away)
to pick up some yo-yos. Of course, they had none so I purchased 3 clowns instead
(like em just as well, but was hoping NOT to need a new tank in the near future
LOL).
<They don't grow super-fast, but they do grow. Kudos for getting a trio!>
One of the clown didn't make it (no surprise; I understand they are all wild
caught and they can be tetchy).
<Yup! Be very, very careful to match the water temperatures with all water
changes!>
The other 2 are happy, hale n hearty, and will be out of QT next week and into
the main tank.
<HOT DANG SHE QUARANTINED HER NEW FISH!! [insert applause here] My
loach-fanatic friend says you should try to get clown loaches that are at least
a couple of inches long (excluding tail length). And look for the ones that are
the most robust.>
I went to the icky LFS today to get some bloodworms (its closer), and noticed
THEY have yo-yos. So my question is, if I purchase a yo-yo to replace the clown
I lost, will he be just as happy hanging with clowns as he would with other
yo-yos?
<I haven't had yo-yos, but I'm not certain that they would.>
(This is assuming I can get the lil guy to survive; the icky pet store is a fish
morgue.)
<Oooh.. then don't get them there!>
I understand loaches are not happy alone (hence my original purchase of 3) but
can't seem to find if they will be happy with other types of loaches. I checked
your faq and loaches.com, but there were no clear answers.
<You might want to post on both the WetWeb boards at
http://wetwebfotos.com/talk
and the boards at loaches.com. We do have a yo-yo loach fan on the WetWeb
boards.>
I'd prefer to understock the tank as its a 25 gallon, and I've already got 2
angels and a liposarcus in there (and yeah, there will be a larger tank in the
future LOL just hopefully not till next year); hence my thinking of only getting
the single yo-yo. Any suggestions?
<Shop around for another clown loach. I usually like to get my fish from
independently-owned stores. But not with the loaches. I admit to getting mine
from a chain store, because they *consistently* had the healthiest clown
loaches. Something else to keep the loaches happy: give them some caves they can
hide and sleep in. My loaches absolutely love playing "loach pile" in the carved
strawberry rock pieces that came with my 55g tank. When they cruise from one end
of the tank to the other, I swear they go out of their way to swim through the
holes in the rocks!>
Thanx!
Allison
<You're welcome! And please join us on the WetWebMedia discussion boards and
give us a progress report. --Ananda>
Clown Loach with Distended Stomach (05/29/03)
<Hi! Ananda here this morning...>
One of my clown loaches, "he's" only about 2.5" so still young, suddenly
developed a heavily distended belly. The fish is otherwise healthy and has
been, swimming around, eating voraciously. I did drop a pea in the tank earlier
in the day.
<One of my clown loaches got rather bloated-looking once. I tried peas, but they
weren't interested. I did some reading and found that it might have been their
diet of mostly dry (and freeze-dried) foods. I took my bloated clown loach and
put him in a hospital tank with one teaspoon of Epsom salts per five gallons of
tank water. The next two days, I added another teaspoon each day, so I had a
tablespoon of the Epsom salts per five gallons of tank water. I then fed the
clown loach treats like frozen/thawed bloodworms, live blackworms, and even a
few Mysis shrimp. In about a week, my clown loach looked like his more slender
self. I did do a daily 5%-10% water change, adding back enough Epsom salt to
keep the level up.>
But I also removed another clown loach from the tank that hadn't eaten in at
least a week or two, and was "wasting away".
<What are you feeding them?>
All other parameters in the 30G tank are fine: ammo, nitrite, nitrate all at
0. UV sterilizer running fine. Other mates are 3 male rainbows not quite full
grown, 6 cardinal tetras, 3 albino pristellas, a Rubbernose pleco and two baby
dwarf Bristlenose (both under 2").
<Hmmmm. Depending on what kind of rainbows you have, I think you are either
pushing the limits or passing them on stocking this tank.>
Any idea what is with my clown loach's tummy and if I should be worried?
<If it isn't just bloat, it may be parasites. If that's the case, I'd suggest
Metronidazole, at half dosage for double the duration.>
Or did he just swallow half of the pea (it broke in half upon entering the tank)
and it is showing (seems unlikely to me)?
<If the swelling is visible for more than a few hours, it's not just an
undigested pea... --Ananda >
Re: Clown Loach with Distended Stomach (05/30/03)
<Ananda here again>
Thanks. I think it was something "he" ate! Looks fine now (and did yesterday
too). Probably, he can't believe he ate the WHOLE THING!
<In other words, "Clown loach go >burp!<" ... Thanks for following up with the
good news... --Ananda>
Clown loaches and snails
Hi gang,
<Greetings!>
I have a planted tank with several medium (3") clown loaches...initially stocked
to control snail stowaways on plants, which they do well. In fact, not only
have the loaches become one of my favorite fishes in all my tanks, I actually
breed and raise Ramshorn snails just so I can give them a treat a few times a
month! =)
<I’m sure they love this, I do it myself with my clowns.>
My question: I have a couple LARGE (2" or so) Gold Inca (not exactly sure of
the species) snails in need of a home. They've been housed in my quarantine
tank for nearly a year, so I doubt introducing pathogens would pose a risk to
the tank, however, would the clown loaches pose a risk to these big guys?
<Very possibly. I know I’ve seen clowns eat snails that were over an inch in
size so I’d be afraid to try it even with snails as large as yours.>
Also... now that I have your attention, hehe. What are some species of plants
(if any) that would do OK in a moderately aerated tank? I'm not looking to win
any awards in these tanks, just to add some "live" decorations.
<A lot would depend on your lighting. Some of my favorites for moderately lit,
moderately aerated tanks are Anacharis (this one is rumored to be touchy but
I’ve always had good luck with it), Elodea, and Anubias.>
Thanks a bunch, and keep up the good work on WWM! Cheers, Michael
<Thank you and you’re welcome! Ronni>
Snails and clown loaches
Hi guys/gals, hope you are all well!
<Yes, thank you>
I am having trouble with an outbreak of snails and want advise about clown
loaches that are NOT eating them!!
<Unusual... it may well be that they are just not "familiar" with them as a food
source. Do try "squishing" a few smaller (softer shelled) specimens and leaving
them in with the loaches without their usual meaty food items for a couple of
days... this will usually "do the trick">
I went to LFS last Tuesday and bout 3 clown loaches since I've read they do well
in groups of 3. They are rather attractive but I was a little concerned about
over stocking my tank- it's a 15 gallon planted tank- was doing extremely well,
with 2 rasboras, 2 white clouds, 3 Otos, 2 cherry barbs. But I have a piece of
driftwood that has never caused me trouble- but I added 2 ml of Zoe, vitamin
supplement for fish, and it turns out that upon close reading of label, Zoe also
helps invertebrates grow- so I think that is where all the snails (look like
Ramshorns) came from- a ton of them. They've eaten holes in a lot of my plants
and that's why I wanted to get the loaches.
<Mmm, well, your loaches will eventually "out-grow" this size system>
I wanted to get a dwarf loach, Botia Sidthimunki , but the guy told me they are
sometimes aggressive and my fish are rather timid lot! So I decided to go for 3
loaches and risk overstocking tank. I do weekly changes, about 2-3 gallons, and
it's always pristine.
I've had these fish for 6 days, and THEY ARE NOT eating snails! in fact, when I
feed flake food to my other fish, the 3 rush to top and push others around and
eat flakes!! Is this normal? Perhaps the LFS fed them flakes??
<Maybe, and not unusual... they are called "clowns" for more than their colorful
markings>
What do I do know, since I still have snails-- took out 12 small ones this
evening?? Is dwarf loach aggressive?
thanks in advance...
Rosa
<Try the "squished" possibility. Bob Fenner>
Re: Snails and clown loaches
Dear Bob,
thanks for response. I was on loaches.com and someone there gave me same advice-
so will try that. Meanwhile, I've read the zebra loach is a more snail
aggressive loach and they don't get quite as large as clowns, or at least that
what LFS told me.
<This is so>
Any suggestions re substituting the clowns for the zebras?
<I would stick with the Clowns for now, maybe swap them out for Botia sidthmunki
later if the Clowns don't work out. Bob Fenner>
thank you again,
Rosa
Black Spots
<Hello! Ryan here>
I was researching your site but I couldn't find much on Black Spot on clown
loaches. I had just transfer my clown loaches to a new 55 gallon, that was set
up for 8 months. Few days later so far what I can see 2 of them developed black
spots on their bodies and fins. Please help, I heard that loaches are very
sensitive to medications because they don't have scales. Any recommendations?
This is already 3 days later, hope I don't loose them. Thank you, hope to hear
from you soon. Iveta .
<1 drop per 2 gallons of Maracide should be fine. This can be increased to 1
drop per gallon if needed. Please do this in a quarantine to be safe. Clown
loaches can be on the sensitive side- so add the Maracide gradually. It's the
sudden change in aquarium conditions that are deadly. Best of luck! Ryan>
Lookin' for Loaches
Hey guys, first thanks for all the great info on this site. It has saved a
lot of headaches so far. I have a 25 gallon tank that just finished cycling. I
have 3 Serpae Tetras and 2 Zebra Danios. I have a fine sand substrate and I am
looking for a fish to add that would help stir up the bottom of the tank a
little. The LFS recommended a Clown Loach but that advice I'm not sold on since
I've heard they can grow to 12 inches. Thanks for any ideas.
<And indeed they can! There are so, so many options available for you. Any of
the smaller loaches, Botia striata, Botia dario, Botia lohachata.... Kuhli
loaches.... soooo many loaches out there! Also Corydoras cats. http://www.loaches.com
is a nice place to start looking at loach options, and you can find loads of
info on cats of the genus Corydoras at
http://www.planetcatfish.com
- as well as on the wetweb site and FAQs. I would like to mention that loaches
and Corys are scaleless, and that you might want to keep an eye on them to see
if they react poorly to the sand if it is at all sharp. Also, please be sure to
keep loaches or Corys in groups of three or more, as they are schooling
fish. -Sabrina>
Clown Loaches Eating Tetras?
Hello,
I have a 54 gal. community tank stocked with various tetra's, Angels, YoYo
Loaches, 3 Clown loaches, and some Neon's. I recently bought 6 more neons to
add to the tank and have seen my Clown Loaches eating them. Is this normal
behavior?
<Nope>
The Clowns are about 4" long and have been living peacefully with the other fish
including about 6 neon's. It was only after adding the new Neon's that the
problem started. Any advise?
<Did you actually witness your Clown Loach striking the neon in a Jaws like
fashion? Is it possible that the new fish died due to maybe stress from the
move, and the Clown Loach was just cleaning up the remains? Most likely the
Loach was just scavenging the left overs. Sorry about your Tetra. Loaches
mouths are not really designed for killing, but they can be a little aggressive
and are capable of harassing other fish, if the loaches are killing your Tetras
you should look into separating them, or getting larger Tetras. Best Regards,
Gage>
Thank you,
Kurt
- Skinny Disease? -
I just lost one of my clown loaches... had 2, he got real skinny within 2-3
days... he just stayed on the bottom... would come up and try to eat but looked
like he did not get much. Someone said it might be "skinny disease" what is
this... <Caused by bacteria.> how do you treat it... <Antibiotics - erythromycin
in the food.> And how do you prevent it. <Keep on top of water quality issues -
most often, disease susceptibility is directly related to water quality.> Had
added a dwarf gourami recently but had been QT'ed for 3 weeks... and looked
fine. Please help... don't want to loose anymore clowns. <Please tell more about
your husbandry - water change regimen, what you feed, water parameters, etc.>
Thanks in advance, Monica
<Cheers, J -- >
Clown Loaches
Hi, It's been a while since I spoke to you all.
<Welcome back>
Unfortunately I seem to have a new problem. I have 2 clown loaches, when I got
them they were both the same size. As they got older one had become larger than
the other. I had been told by my LFS that they were schooling fish and I should
at least get 2. So I did. I was also told that they would get along as they
grew. But as it turned out the larger one is picking on the smaller one. Are
they naturally aggressive toward one another, or would a larger amount (1 or 2
more) ease the problem between the 2. Any advice would be much
appreciated. THANK YOU DS
<Clown Loaches are somewhat aggressive, and also playful with one another, I
would add between 1-3 more, depending on the size of your tank. They will be
happier with the increased number of fish, and the aggressive one can spread the
beatings around so no one fish is picked on too much. Best Regards, Gage>
Buffering Fresh, 2.1
>Marina,
Thanks for the advice.
>>Quite welcome.
>!ST bubbles from the bubble stones, not the powerhead.
>>Gotcha, so you've got excellent oxygen/carbon dioxide (O2/CO2) exchange.
>I did check KH and GH.... both WAY TOO LOW...... so I guess the best thing to
do is to find some of the Seachem products.
I do like Seachem best, as I said. The products were quite easy to find online,
and relatively inexpensive.
>I have read that clown loaches do much better as a pair or more? Is that not
so?
>>They may be a bit happier, but honestly I've never known them to do poorly if
kept singly, either. They can grow quite large, though, something to consider.
>Thanks for all the help. Monica
>>Again, very welcome, I'm glad I was able to answer your questions. Marina
Clown loaches 'n' columnaris
Hi - I purchased 3 clown loaches about 3 or 4 weeks ago. They've seemed fine
until about 3 days ago. 1 of them has white around his mouth. Could it be
cotton mouth? How would I treat this?
<This sounds like columnaris (mouth fungus, mouth rot, other names). I would
treat with a broad spectrum antibiotic like Oxytetracycline, preferably in a
medicated food, if possible.>
I had something similar about a year ago that started with a Dojo and 14 of my
19 fish perished. I treated it with Penicillin upon advice from a local fish
store. I have a 29 gal tank. Testing yesterday showed everything was fine.
<What were your test results? Usually this bacterial illness is brought on by
high nitrates, perhaps a pH other than what the fish prefer, low oxygen
concentrations, etc.>
Thanks
SG
<Wishing your fish a swift recovery, -Sabrina>
This Clown's Not Joking
Hey Crew, <Hello! Ryan with you>
I recently had to shut down my 75gall saltwater tank because it is too big/heavy
for my new apartment. <Sorry to hear> To ease the pain of this loss, I purchased
a small 5 gallon Hex. Eclipse system for my dresser. Cycled the tank for 3 weeks
w a platy. The plan was/is to plant the tank nicely and put a nice Betta in
there (of course got a show quality fish from Canada to be shipped next
week!). Also wanted to get one Corydoras cat to keep the bottom clean. Here is
the problem/mistake I made ALREADY. I hadn't dealt with freshwater fish for a
long long time and thought I knew "enough" to do this w/out reading. If I had
stuck to my 2 fish/plant plan I think I would have been ok. But when I went to
get my Corydoras 2 days ago.....I came home w/ a Clown Loach instead. I thought
"they're nicer and serve the same purpose." Wrong....<At least you didn't make
me tell you!>...I decided to read AFTER the fact and see that it won't fit in my
tank for long and needs to be in groups of 3 or more. <I have seen this fish
well over 8 inches> And I'm starting to wonder....do they even scavenge??? <Not
in the way a true scavenger does> I've fed him 2x and while he gets excited, he
doesn't seem to find the food as it sinks to the bottom. Will he find the food
at night on the bottom?? <Yes> Secondly, will this guy be ok by himself or does
he NEED to be in groups. <he needs to be returned, he will die in your setup
within a few months.> Thirdly...should I just bring him back or give him
away?? <Bring him back, stick you your initial plan! It was a good one. See
ya, Ryan>
Chuck Clowns Around with the loaches
I have a 90 gallon show tank with discus, clown loaches and Bushynosed
Plecos. It is decorated with wood and single piece of holey stone which gives
the loaches many hiding places. The substrate is typical natural colored
aquarium gravel. I was considering removing the gravel and leaving the tank bare
bottomed so I could keep it very clean. Is that going to be a problem for the
clown loaches?
< I would not remove all the gravel. I would leave about 1/2 inch to 3/4 of an
inch of gravel or fine sand. There are bacteria living on the gravel that help
break down the fishes waste. If you removed all the gravel you would probably
encounter big ammonia spikes every time you changed your filter and that would
affect the entire tank. I would service the filter once every two weeks and then
gravel vac the substrate on alternate weeks.-Chuck>
James Nyman
Growing Clown Loaches
Hi Bob!
<Hello Mohammad>
This is Ahmed from Pakistan. I have 3 clown loaches in my 5 feet tank. 7 Bala
sharks, 1 rainbow shark, 1 paradise Gourami are the tank mates of my clown
loaches. I have 2 questions from u concerned with my loaches. Firstly what food
should I offer to my loaches to attain maximum size in the minimum time n how
many times in a day should I feed my fish?
<Clown loaches will eat most any type of foods that make their way down to the
bottom of the tank, but should be offered some high/er protein rations daily...
worms of all kinds (even chopped up if large), insect larvae, shrimps... sinking
pellets are good if high quality. Best to feed them twice per day... And you
likely know these are very long-lived fishes. I know of some in captivity for
more than thirty years>
I serve floating pellets to my fish. Though I know that they (clown loaches)
grow pretty slow. Secondly when I see my loaches from a greater distance they
don't hide but when I reach near to aquarium they float just like a bullet n
hide in a drift wood like a flash. Are these fishes shy in nature? Thanks Bob.
<Do look into and use some sinking foods as well... keep your tank covered (to
prevent jumping), keep up regular water changes (weekly) and you'll be surprised
how quickly your loaches will grow. Bob Fenner>
Clown loach with nibbled fins
Hi there -- been a long time since I've written. I have a 180 gal tank with 4
clown loaches (2 are 8 inches long and 13 years old; 2 are 3 inches long and
about 3 years old) 10 small glass catfish, 2 Plecos and one black skirt
tetra. One of the smaller loaches looks like his fins have been nibbled
off. He looks good otherwise and eats well. I haven't seen anyone nipping at
him, although one of the larger loaches gets impatient with him (haven't seen
actual contact, though). They had been co-existing peacefully for 2 years
without incident. There have been no new additions to the tank. There are lots
of hiding places, and the tank is very clean with bio-ball filtration and weekly
40 gallon water changes. The temp is at 80F.
Any ideas on who the culprit(s) might be?
< Sure sounds like one of the other larger loaches is the culprit. They are
getting old enough and large enough to where they might be thinking about
breeding and might be picking on the smaller loaches as part of territorial
disputes.-Chuck>
thanks
Tom
Very small Clown Loaches
Hi there,
I would like to know what clown loaches look like when only days old - 1
week? We have just discovered babies in our tank and we only have clown
loaches and another type of fish that are multiple. I know the loaches are not
easy to breed but these have a bright yellow sack so do you have any
photo's that would help in the identification, can't find anything on the net.
Thanks a million
< Most baby fish have an egg sac attached to them. As the egg sac is being
absorbed the fish should start looking more and more like the adults whatever
they may be. Usually clown loaches get to be about a foot long before that are
breeding size and then scatter their eggs about. I know that they are bred in
the orient using hormone injections but this would indeed be a rare occurrence
if it were the clown loaches in fact that bred.-Chuck>
Cheers,
Michelle Trute
HLLE on Clown Loach
Greetings, all. I have a 180 gal FW tank. <!> I keep it at about 80F. I have
two 13 year old clown loaches <!!>(8+ inches) and two smaller ones (3-4 inches).
I also have 9 ghost catfish, 1 black skirt tetra, three hatchetfish and two
large-ish Plecos. <!!!> I wrote awhile back about one of the smaller loaches
having nibbled fins. Now, I notice that one of the larger clowns (the largest,
in fact) has three, almost regularly-spaced craters or lesions (bites?) on his
dorsum, just behind the "head". They do not look infected, and he still eats
voraciously. The tank is very clean, with bio-ball sump-based filtration and a
40W UV light. 40 gallon water changes weekly. Could this be hole in head? No
white/slimy fecal matter and he acts healthy. The marks are in a row, all inside
one of his dark stripes. <It does not sound like the few fish I have seen with
hole in the head (HLLE) but it sure is possible. The fact that the holes are
"clean" and in a row makes me think it is not HLLE. Although not directly fatal,
it can lead to secondary infections that are. Watch for redness or a white pus.
I found a good link for you to read up on. See: http://www.masla.com/fish/hlle.html.
BTW Great job on keeping your fish! 180 gallons and a rather light bio load! Big
fish in there though. Make sure you check the nitrates and try to keep them
below 20ppm. Don>
Thanks! <No, Thank YOU!>
Tom <Don>
Lumpy Loach – Mycobacterium Infection? – 01/11/2005
Hi,
<Hello!>
I have a 75-gallon tank with three 14 year-old clown loaches and two large green
kissing fish.
<Must be some pretty large loaches, at that age! It wouldn’t be a terrible idea
to try for a larger tank, if possible.>
One of the loaches has large lumps all over his body under the skin, appears to
be very swollen – even his eyes appear to be bulging. He is hiding in the back
of the tank and will not come out to eat; he just stays in the same place
breathing very rapidly, in an upright position, leaning on tubing. He has been
like this for about a month and I
really didn’t expect him to be alive this long since I just noticed his illness
right before I went out of town. I assumed that he had an age related problem
since a couple of his tank mates have passed on over the past couple of
years. I haven’t been able to find out anything about this particular illness.
<To be quite honest, this sounds to me like a very good indication of
mycobacteriosis. The swelling, pop-eye, and lumps/tumors/granulomas are very
strong symptoms of this myxosporidian bacterial infection. It’s really quite a
good thing that the critter did not die while you were gone – a dead fish can
release literally millions of “spores” that can infect other fish in the tank!>
The nitrates in this tank stay fairly high even with frequent water changes and
Poly-filters in the filters.
<Yes.... These are very large fish in a (comparatively) small tank; increased
water volume would really be a good idea.>
There are no indications (redness, etc) on his outward appearance that would
suggest a bacterial or fungal condition. I would try to treat him in a separate
tank if I knew what to try, or at this point would it be better to euthanize
him?
<Sadly, mycobacteriosis is essentially incurable. There is some indication that
Kanamycin sulfate may have some effect, but recovery is unlikely, I’m so sorry
to say. Either way, should you choose to medicate or not, definitely remove the
fish as soon as possible from the healthy animals – I can assure you, you do not
want this to spread, if that is, in fact, what it is. Also, PLEASE read the
following link, so you can understand what risk this illness might pose to
you: http://reefkeeping.com/issues/2003-07/sp/feature/index.htm
. Do please understand that without seeing the fish for myself, I cannot
guarantee that this is an accurate diagnosis – but based on the symptoms you
describe, it is my best guess. Gah, I hate being the bearer of bad news.>
I appreciate your consideration. Thank you, Karen Chaney
<Wishing you and your loach the best, -Sabrina>
Clown loach FAQ, actually petfish hypochondria
Hi,
I have a 75 gallon tank with 5 clown loaches (approx. 5 inches long), 2
catfishes, and 2 discus. After cleaning the filter in my Fluval 304, I noticed
1 of my clownloaches developed partial eye cloudiness in one eye and another
clown loach developed what started looking like a small 1mm x 5mm whitish
bump turned into a round pimple-like bump.
<Good observations>
They have a great appetite. What can I use to treat them?
<Mmm, I prescribe nothing... just time going by... the markings are/were due to
abrupt chemical changes in your system... not a pathogen... and besides, even
mild medications will harm your other fishes>
Do they need to be separated in a "sick" tank?
<No>
You have mentioned for other internal bacteria diseases or infections to use
Flagyl, but how much ?
<None>
Let say I have Flagyl 500 mg tablet form.
<... this material, Metronidazole is quite toxic... kills the kidneys of fishes
easily... Do NOT use it in this instance>
Would I go by the approximate weight of the fish ? What is the weight of a 6
inch 15 year old clown loach ? Can I crush up the Flagyl tablet and dilute
it with tank water then soak it in Tubifex worms ? Will it further harm the
rest of the healthy fish or will the antibiotic make the other fishes
bigger and healthier ? I've heard of using Methylene blue approximately 6 drops
per gallon on the entire tank. What is your feelings on this and
where would I buy Methylene blue ? 15 years ago, when I bought the tiny little
babies, one of them would not eat and was wasting away. At that time
I didn't have my heart and soul invested in them because I just bought them.
So I figured I would experiment. I had left over amoxicillin (from my
sick cat). If memories serves me correctly, I crushed up a tablet, separated it
to approximately 1 mg, dilute it with water, soaked it with
Tubifex (the worms died instantly), then fed it to the sick fish, which was in a
breeder tank inside the 75 gallon tank. So the sick wasting fish would
accidentally have to suck and antibiotic soaked worm. A week later, he was
swimming with the rest of the fishes. The rest of the other fishes ate
whatever antibiotic soaked worms floated out of the breeder tank. And they all
lived !! 15 years later they are XXL and were healthy until now. But
now I don't want to experiment. Please advise. Thank you for your time.
Tammy
<Tam... don't fall prey to the "pill" mentality... these are not "safe" to just
add... and there is no need to generally add any of them to otherwise
well-maintained systems. I would add nothing here. Bob Fenner>
Clown Loaches with white spots laying on the bottom of the tank
I have a new 90L tank (just over a month old). I have slowly introduced 8
Neon Tetras, 1 Siamese Fighting Fish, 2 Plecostomus, 2 Clown Loaches and a
growing snail infestation.
<Suspect these last two are related>
I am a complete beginner here as this is my first ever tank, I have read some
books and many web pages but none seem to answer specifically my question.
Please let me explain a little first before asking yourselves. After introducing
the Clowns they seemed to hide behind plants and rocks for the most part of the
day, I hardly ever saw them.
<This is normal behavior... they're new.>
This did not worry me as they appeared to be doing their job (the snail
population dropped dramatically). The Fighting Fish never seemed to display his
colours as he did in the shop, this was solved by adding a mirror to the side of
the tank. One day after adding the mirror I noticed a little white spot on one
of the loaches on the rare occasions I saw them, by the evening it was covered
and the other fish started developing it. By the second day I had added
Interpret White Spot Plus No6. Over the next few days the spots diminished on
all the fish except the loaches, after the second dose the other fish seemed
clear and the loaches if not clear at least diminished. The loaches however are
no longer hiding in the back of the tank where I can't see them, they are laying
one on top of the other huddled up next to they mirror and barely moving. Every
now and then they will dart into the middle of the tank for a few minutes then
return and lay still for ages. My question is are they still suffering from the
White Spot, are they suffering from something else or is this normal behavior?
<Likely just the white spot/ich>
Please excuse any ignorance here but I really am beginning to worry about them
as it says on many pages white spot can be lethal, while on just as many it says
it can be easily cured.
Tony Robertson
<Ignorance is acceptable... we're here to diminish this... Your fish, indeed
your tank "has ich"... Please read here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwich.htm Re: the medication,
did you remove all chemical filtration (e.g. carbon) from your filters? This
will remove the med. Did you raise the tank temperature? I would... all the
livestock you list can easily tolerate the mid 80's F... but not the ich. Know
that the loaches are "ich magnets" (i.e. very susceptible to this parasite), AND
sensitive to ich medications... you will want to check the label, what you can
re the med... and likely use half doses... Don't add any more livestock for a
few weeks till after this problem is solved. Bob Fenner>
Re: Clown Loaches with white spots laying on the bottom of the tank.
Dear Mr. Fenner
<Tony>
May I say thank you very much for you advice, it has helped to belay my fears
quite a bit.
<Glad we have helped you>
You asked if I had removed the carbon filters, I had as that was an
instruction with the white spot medication although I must admit I was unsure as
to why I had to do it but my guess matched your reason. You also suggested
raising the temperature, this I had not done as the instruction suggested
raising it to 26c while I have had my tank at a constant 27c since the second
day after installation.
<I might raise it as much as 29C... the rationale: the causative organism
(Ichthyophthirius multifilius) cannot tolerate heat as well as its fish hosts>
It is now two days since I first wrote and things have improved a great deal
with the Clown Loaches. All signs of ich appear to have left all the fish, the
loaches (the ones I was worried about the most) seem a tad paler than I recall
but they do seem a bit more active. They are not laying on top of one another
anymore but rather moving around on the bottom of the tank. I definitely believe
they are going to live, which was not my belief a couple of days ago.
<Do understand the general life cycle of the protozoan...>
I had planned on adding a few more fish later this week but I think now I will
wait a week longer.
<Yes! At least a few weeks... you may well simply be in "mid cycle">
I'm hoping to add some Angelfish, Red-tailed sharks and some small striped
ones I saw in the shop last time I was there but unfortunately don't recall what
they were called. I will seek advice from the shop before making any purchases
as they did seem very knowledgeable last time. I had been blaming them for the
ich in my tank but I now realize and understand that it is extremely common so
I'll forgive them, but it won't stop me asking for a discount. Again let
me repeat my thanks as your advice and web pages were deeply appreciated.
Tony Robertson
<You are welcome. Bob Fenner>
LOAFING LOACHES
Hi Guys, I hope you can shed some light on why my 2 clown loaches have
suddenly become very listless with one in particular just lying at the back of
the tank. This is a marked change in behaviour as they have been very active for
the month since I introduced them to my 200 litre planted tank. Ammonia,
nitrites and nitrates are fine and ph is 7. I do seem to have a bit of an algae
problem despite doing weekly water changes and was wondering if the level of
dissolved organic compounds may be too high and affecting the loaches adversely.
I've since cut the lighting back to 9 hours and am going to reduce the amount of
food I've been giving them. Any advice would be appreciated.
Regards, Jane
< It is not uncommon for loaches to be found occasionally lying on their sides.
Many new aquarists become freaked out by their loaches strange behavior but it
is normal for them. If they really are sick then look closely for ich. These
guys can pick this up in a tank when all the other fish seem unaffected.-Chuck>
Clown Loach
I have 2 loaches, 2 black tipped sharks(?), and have just added 2 Oscars. I
only mention all of the above because I do not remember seeing this problem
before the Oscars were added. One of my loaches is constantly swimming at the
surface with his mouth wide open, never closing it. He is seriously faded and
seems to have red cheeks (I know that is silly but really what it looks like).
The sharks are very worried about him and so am I. Can you help me?
Kim
<Sounds like this fish is extremely stressed... by? I would check your water
quality... for ammonia and nitrite at least... Has this tank been set-up long?
Is it big enough for these fishes? How is it filtered? Is it cycled? Please read
here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwmaintindex.htm
- scroll down to Environmental Disease and read the Related FAQs files. Bob
Fenner>
Clown loaches won't eat 8/9/05
Help!
<Hey Jeff! I did see you called...>
I have a 30 gal tank with three large clown loaches, about 6 yrs old. The tank
also had a Kissing Gourami but this fish died a couple of weeks ago. It died
slowly, it stopped eating and grew thin. Tried treating in in another tank with
Maracyn II but this did not help. Now the loaches have stopped eating and they
hide most of the day. What can I do?
Regards,
Jeff Hulett
<Start a series (daily) of a few gallon water changes... and try not to worry...
these fish can go a very long time w/o eating... I recall your message said your
Corydoras had spawned again (a good sign that your overall water quality is not
off)... Likely the loaches are "going through some changes" with the warmer
weather... will be fine in a week or two. Bob Fenner>