
|
|
Moray
Selection FAQs
Related FAQs:
Moray Eels,
Morays 2,
Moray Eels 3,
Moray Identification,
Moray Behavior,
Moray Compatibility, Moray
Systems, Moray Feeding,
Moray Disease,
Moray Reproduction,
Freshwater Moray Eels,
Zebra Moray
Eels, Snowflake Morays,
Freshwater Moray
Eels, Other Marine Eels ,
Related Articles:
Moray Eels, The
Zebra Moray (Gymnomuraena zebra),
Ribbon Morays,
The "Freshwater" Moray
Eels,
Freshwater
Moray Eels by Marco
Lichtenberger,
Non-Moray Marine Eels, Snake &
Worm Eels,
Enchelycore pardalis.
|
|
|
Skeletor Eel – 10/31/09
Dear Crew,
<Hi Bill.>
Have you ever heard of an eel named Skeletor Eel (Echidna xanthospilos)?
<Of course. But I have to note - by the power of Grayskull - it is among
the most stupid common names I’ve heard for a fish… >
All I have read is that it's semi aggressive and it only grows to 2' in
length
<Both true… Is about as aggressive as a Snowflake eel or a Banded moray.
Quite comparable to the latter>
, but it's super rare.
<Sometimes a bunch of them appears in trade. Sometimes even in the
freshwater section…>
No mention of how suitable to aquarium life and what they eat.
<Quite adaptable to aquarium life, occurs naturally in a range of
biotopes and even occurs in freshwater (cannot be kept in this
condition). For diet see other eels of this genus such as the Snowflake
eel and the Chainlink eel: mostly crabs, shrimps, fish, cephalopods. You
can also feed clam and mussel meat. Be sure to use vitamins about once
per week.>
Have seen one for sale at FFExpress and would like some more info before
considering purchasing it. Tried various sites to no avail, it's like a
new discovered Eel that no one has any info on.
<It’s similar to the Snowflake eel on one hand and to “Freshwater”
morays on the other hand.>
I have a 125 gallon FWLRO tank with 3" Tomato Clown, 6" Hippo Tang and a
6"
Pinkface Wrasse. They will all be moved at the end of year to a bigger
tank leaving this tank for the eel but in the meanwhile, will adding
this Eel to this tank be ok?
<Your fish are in my opinion too big to be hurt by a medium sized E.
xanthospilos. The clown is the most endangered specimen.>
He is 12" long right now. Also, should an Eel be quarantined?
<Ideally, most fish are quarantined. Since moray eels can carry harmful
bacteria, this can be a good idea if a proper quarantine system is
available. Clarify if the fish was already quarantined by the trader.>
If so, how long?
<Four weeks should be enough. Also a good time to train it to frozen
food if necessary.>
And how big of a quarantine tank for this one footer?
<If you can keep the water parameters in a 29 gallon tank stable, it can
be sufficient if it has proper artificial caves and a good oxygen supply
(current, skimming). If a bigger tank is available (about 50 gallons),
it would likely be easier.>
Thanks for your help, Bill
<Welcome and good luck with this beautiful eel. Marco.
PS: Some reading about similar species:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/FWSubWebIndex/fwmorayart.htm
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/snowflakemoray.htm >
Skeletor Eel II – 10/31/09
Dear Marco,
<Hello Bill.>
Thanks for you quick reply.
<Welcome.>
I totally agree with you, what a stupid name.
I called FFExpress and they told me that he has been there for a month,
in a tank by himself
and eating well. Eating all kinds of frozen food like krill,
silversides, squid and shrimp with the shell on.
Unfortunately I do not have a quarantine tank ready, was not expecting
to buy an eel so since they have had the eel for over a month, I think
I'll just take a chance and put him in my 125 with the other guys. I
just got a call from FFExpress and he reinforced what you just wrote me,
that this eel is close related to the Snowflake and Chainlink eel
species. Likes to eat crustaceans. BTW, how do I add vitamins to his
diet?
<Either by dropping them onto the thawing food item and leaving them
there for about a quarter of an hour or by using a syringe, which
appears to be more efficient. Adding vitamins is inevitable in the long
run when you are feeding frozen foods to eels.>
I actually wasn't worry about the eel with the fish stock I have but
vise-versa, my Pinkface Wrasse is pretty aggressive towards new
tankmates and so is the Tomato Clown. You don't think they will nip at
the eel, do you?
<This eel – like all eels – needs safe caves, either rock gaps or PVC
pipes, to hide itself if necessary. I think it will be able to stand its
ground. Most fish recognize eel tank mates (except thin ribbon eel
species) as predators and after some first confrontations leave them
alone. A 12" eel is physically able to tear a 3" Clown in half.>
Thanks again, Bill
<Welcome Bill. Feel free to send some pictures/a report if you get the
eel. Marco.>
Re: Skeletor Eel – 10/31/09
Dear Marco,
<Bill>
The eel should arrive Tuesday, once acclimated I'll take some pics for
you ok?
<That would be great! Thank you.>
Thanks for all your helpful answers,
Best,
Bill
<Cheers. Marco.>
Re: Skeletor Eel – 11/05/09
Dear Marco,
<Hello Bill.>
The Skeletor Eel arrived safely from Live Aquaria. Excellent packing
job, bagged 7 bags thick with warmers and packing peanuts to keep the
Eel warm. Acclimated like they told me and now he is in the tank.
Already found a couple of places where he likes to hide, none of the
resident fishes have bothered him so far. Once he starts to get out
more, I'll try to take pics.
<I'm looking forward to that.>
He is about 12-13" in length and about as thick as a thumb. Beautiful
markings, dark brown color with yellowish/creme spots. I have a question
for you. Will a Golden Moray Eel (Gymnothorax miliaris) be compatible
with my eel?
<Likely, yes. Just watch the first meetings and feedings more closely.>
Whatever info I was able to dig out on my Skeletor eel says that he
doesn't get any bigger than 2 feet and so is the Golden Moray. Could
they coexist in a 125 gallon tank?
<If you can keep the water parameters in line: yes.>
Thanks again for all your help, Bill
<Welcome. Marco.>
Re: Skeletor Eel – 11/06/09
Dear Marco,
<Hi Bill.>
I was feeding the other fish and the newly acquired eel must have
smelled the food so he started swimming around in the back so I fed him.
Gave him 2 pieces of squid and he
was all over it. That was only 6 hours after getting him out of the
shipping box. I'm very happy that he is eating already.
<Yes, this sounds very good. I’m glad the eel is eating already.>
Today he is hiding in some rock cave and didn't come out to eat but at
least he didn't escape last night LOL. Here is a pic of him yesterday,
will take more whenever I can get his whole body.
<Thank you very much for sending. A beautiful specimen.>
Thanks, Bill
<Cheers. Marco.>
|
 |
More rare moray questions; G. berndti, sel. - 09/29/09
Hi (Marco?),
<Yes, how did you know?>
I've located a Gymnothorax berndti (Y-patterned moray/Berndt's moray)
and will, in all likelihood, be snagging it. To refresh, I currently
have a Japanese Dragon and a Koke (E. lichenosa), each about 30", in a
150 'Cube' along with a lionfish. The tank also housed a kidako, he has
since been moved to a 72 for the time being. Filtration is overkill, I
generally read double zeros with teenage nitrates. Temps average 72-76.
<Sounds good.>
Like every other eel I'm looking for, info on captive care is impossible
to come by.
<I agree. And this is definitely another rarely kept species.>
What compounds this is that this eel, as I'm sure you know, is a deeper
water species.
<Yes, but apparently it is sometimes also found/caught in more shallow
waters as pictures by standard scuba divers show.>
The specimen is being offered by a reputable company and is currently
being kept in the same system as a Dragon and Koke. Is there anything
you know of that I should be aware of?
<Nothing specific, maybe offer it more dark shelter to see if it shows a
even higher preference for a darker environment than your other eels.>
Sort of off topic - I picked up an acrylic 180 at a fire sale last
month...I think I am going to give the cold water system a shot, and
then try and find myself an E. anatina and E. ramosa...wish me luck!
<I do! Sounds good.>
Thanks as always, Pat C.
<Cheers. Marco.>
Re: More rare moray questions; E. kamara; Input by Bob? –
09/30/09
Hi Marco,
<Hi Pat.>
Thanks for the reply...the Berndti is coming this Friday, I'll let you
know how it goes.
<Good. It would be interesting to know if you see any signs of a
fastened metabolism when it has settled in. I’m curious if the captive
specimens are adapted to the surface temperatures as the diver pictures
of this species could suggest.>
Here's one more question for you, I'll be astounded if you have any info
on this species: Enchelycore kamara of Palau and Guam, and the Line
Islands.
<I got the first description by Böhlke & Böhlke here. That’s basically
it.>
It's a newish species and I can't even find a photograph of it.
<Newish like from the beginning of the 1980s?>
Do you know anything about this species? Are fish collected from the
above locations?
<Collected: yes, but exported? Palau has banned live fish export last
year. Guam should be possible (it’s an unincorporated territory of the
United States; I just assume you are in the USA). Line islands does as
far as I know also export live fish. I don't know any importer of
ornamental fish from these areas in the USA (maybe Bob does).
<Mmm, yes... there are a few... particularly from/on Kiritimati
(Christmas Is.)... Don't know anyone personally though. RMF>
There also remains the big question if someone will be able to catch one
of these apparently not often seen eels at all. I guess the best would
be to travel over there and personally take care of the project.>
Thanks! Pat C.
<Hope this helps. Marco.>
Re: More rare moray questions
10/2/2009
Thanks so much for the insight guys!
<Welcome.>
I'm actually going on my first wildlife collecting trip in Trinidad in
January, though unfortunately I won't be collecting fish.
<Too bad... some nice morays there.>
I'll try to get pics of the Berndti out soon!
<I am looking forward to that and your experiences with this species.
Cheers. Marco.>
Re: More rare moray questions; DOA – 10/05/09
Marco,
<Hello Pat.>
Well I've had an awful weekend...the berndti arrived and appeared
disoriented and weak, even after a lengthy acclimation period. He spent
Friday night poking out of a crevice, retreated into the back of the
tank and passed away some time last night/early this morning.
<I am very sorry for you.>
Words can't express how awful I feel for this rare and beautiful animal.
I've read the horror stories in you FAQ's ("My G, funebris is in a 20
long...") and hope you understand that I did everything in my power to
save him.
<I am sure you did->
The vendor does not want the body back and I hate to let him go to
complete waste. I was hoping you might know of a researcher in the field
that might be able to make use of him as a scientific specimen to
further the study of these creatures. I plan to freeze him, so he should
be pretty well preserved.
<Within the USA David Smith (smithd@si.edu; Museum of Natural History
Washington, DC) or John “Jack” Randall (Bishop Museum Hawaii;
http://hbs.bishopmuseum.org/staff/randall.html) might be interested in a
G. berndti or able to tell you other contacts. Usually the place and
depth a specimen was caught at would be an important information if
available, most are preserved in alcohol, because ice crystals destroy
tissue to some extent. Might be good to clarify that with a possible
interested researcher.>
Thanks, Pat C.
<Take care. Marco.>
<<Mmm, will ask. RMF>>
Re: More rare moray questions -
10/05/2009
Jack, could you use a Gymnothorax berndti?
BobF
Gymnothorax berndti
Bob:
No, thanks. The Bishop Museum has many specimens.
Aloha, Jack
<Thank you mate. A hu'i hou! BobF>
Re: More rare moray questions
- 10/06/2009
Thank you Marco. I actually reached out to David at the Museum of
Natural History first as they are much closer to me. I'll likely focus
my finances and efforts on getting a cold water system set up and
hopefully locating E. anatina and E. ramosa at some point in the future.
<Good luck Pat. Cheers, Marco.>
Re: More rare moray questions - 10/05/2009
Marco,
<Pat.>
Thank you for your kind words and the contacts. I'll reach out to them
immediately.
<J. Randall (asked by Bob) already noted by mail that the Bishop Museum
has no interest.>
I'll also let you know of other species I find in the future; at the
moment I'm hesitant to try berndti again, at least until I can speak
with someone with success in keeping the species to ensure I am
exercising proper husbandry with this particular animal.
<Yes, I only know of vendors, which typically keep them just like other
eels a few months maximum until they sell them.>
Thanks, Pat C.
<Cheers. Marco.>
Re: More rare moray questions 10/7/2009
Just heard back from David; he can use the specimen for DNA
samples...very glad that it's not going to complete waste.
<Ah... good. I'm already interested in the results of this study.>
Thanks, Pat
<Best wishes. Marco.>
Bioload Question 7/29/09
Hello.
<Hi Austin>
I am wondering what the bioload difference is between [3 moray eels]
<One, two, three feet?>
and [two 3.5" PJ Cardinals, one 5" Vlamingi Tang, one 3" Smith's Fang
Blenny, one 3" Bar Goby, and one 2" White Tiger Goby]. If you would like
any more information, please feel free to ask.
<Bioload cannot always be determined by the length of the fish. How much
waste the fish produces must also be taken into consideration. Moray
Eels are large waste producers and the bioload will be much heavier than
the combination of fish you listed.>
Thank you!
<You're welcome. James (Salty Dog)>--
Austin Rice
Viper moray question – 07/15/09
Hello (Marco, I assume?),
<How did you know? Hi Pat.>
I am currently looking at an animal labeled as a Viper Moray...the size,
description, and attached photo seem indicative of E. nigricans, but I'd
like to get your opinion as I have no desire to take on an Enchelynassa
canina.
<It is an Enchelycore for sure, no Enchelynassa. Very likely E.
nigricans… or a Pacific species (isn’t the ocean where the animal comes
from known to the current keeper?)… like E. bayeri, hard to tell from
the picture.>
As to the former in captivity, do you have any experience?
<Yes… similar to other larger Enchelycore species.>
Please note that this picture was not taken by me and I am not
representing it as my own....I don't know if that dictates whether or
not you are able to post it.
<Nor do I.>
In case you recall, the E. lichenosa is doing fantastic...
<Great to hear.>
I'm in the middle of planning a tank upgrade as we speak and hoping
against hope that I'm able to find a E. anatina some time after that.
<You know these two cannot be kept together? The E. anatina will need
colder temperatures. You’d likely have to catch one yourself or know
someone from the Northern subtropical Atlantic (esp. Canary Islands) to
help you out.>
Thanks, Pat
<Welcome. Marco.>
Viper moray pic
Sorry, forgot the pic in the last email.
<Got it. Thanks. But since we cannot post it, I'll delete it. Marco.>
Eel from Monterey Bay – 03/31/09
Thank you for your time and response. Sadly the porcupine puffer didn't
make it.
<Sorry for your loss.>
I do however have another question that hopefully you can help me with.
My brother brought home an eel from the ocean (Monterey Bay) and he is
just a little guy, about 3 inches.
<Two big mistakes: Taking home an animal you don’t know and putting it
into an environment that does not resemble its habitat.>
I don't know what kind of eel he is.
<Send clear pictures.>
I tried to look him up but he pretty much looks like all of the eels I
have seen on the internet. I was told at the LFS that he wouldn't make
it because he was a cold water eel beings as he came from Monterey Bay.
<Won’t do well in the long run.>
But I didn't want to let him just die so I figured I would just give it
a try. He has been in there for 4 days now and seems to be doing very
well. We are trying to feed him thawed octopus and he doesn't seem to
want to eat.
<Possibly you’ll have to start with live food like small shrimps.>
Do you have any tips or anything that I can try to keep this guy alive?
<Sure: Find an adequate, chilled home or set up another tank in a cold
place. Since the eel already is in your tank I cannot recommend putting
it back into the sea.>
I can't do a chiller because its a tropical tank but he seems to be
doing ok so far.
<”So far” being the key words here. If this is a sub-tropical to
temperate water eel it won’t do well in a tropical tank, because its
metabolism is not designed to run perfectly at higher temperatures.>
But it would be really awesome to have this eel for a long time as it
would make a cool story about how we got him. I can send a pic if you
would like if it would help to know the type of eel.
<Yes, much of what could be given as advice depends on the species or
even the group we are talking about.>
I've always wanted an eel and this one is really cool, because he seems
to change color and stuff. He gets along with the 2 damsels and clown
fish. I just want him to eat something. I just don't know anything about
eels so any help would greatly be appreciated. Thank you for your time.
<Let’s start with some clear pictures, an ID and possibly finding a
cooler home for the eel. Cheers, Marco.>
Looking for an Eel Expert, ID,
sel. 8/1/08
Hi Crew,
<Hello Kirk.>
I am a very confused on the difference between Muraena lentiginosa and
pavonina.
<They are frequently confused in the hobby and even scientific
literature.>
Fishbase and Live Aquaria lists lentiginosa as only getting to 2 feet
long, a manageable size.
<That information is correct.>
Other sources list it as a fish eating monster topping out at 60 inches.
<Fish eating: Yes; monster: No; size: max. 2 ft.>
I would like to add an eel to my 8x2x2 (roughly 280 total gallons)
"Aggressive tank", I of course don't want to lose any fish.
<A zebra eel would be the best choice.>
I had been considering the Brazilian Dragon (M. pavonina I think?), its
tough to find much information on this guy as well, or the Goldentail
Moray (Gymnothorax miliaris). Which one of the three (if any) of these
would you recommend with fish?
<I do keep/have kept all three of the listed species and would only
recommend the Goldentail moray for your project. The Brazilian Dragon
(Muraena pavonina) gets significantly larger (about 70 cm, 28”) than
indicated by Fishbase (51,2 cm, 20”) and is the most aggressive moray
species I have ever kept (I do have 2 of them at the moment). In my
opinion they are best kept alone in single specimen tanks. M.
lentiginosa is not that aggressive, but still more than the G. miliaris.
Remember, even the G. miliaris is a predator that can eat any fish to
about 1/4-1/3 of its own length. So your other fish should be larger.>
Tank mates would be Coral Beauty (big one) and Black Velvet Angel, Red
Tooth and Sargassum Trigger, Harlequin Tusk and Sunset Wrasse as well as
my most recent and final (other than an eel) addition a young Sohal
Tang. I have kept a Snowflake and Zebra Eel for many years in another
tank, just looking for something different to keep.
<The fish-eating morays are a definitely different experience, but a
Zebra eel is certainly the most safe moray choice for fishy tank mates.>
Thanks for any help, Kirk .
<Welcome! Cheers, Marco.>
Re: Eel on Diver's
Den...follow up for Marco, sel. – 01/15/09
Based on my tank size (8 foot 240 gallon) and inhabitants (Sohal Tang,
Asfur and Coral Beauty, Sunset Wrasse & Harlequin Tusk, Sargassum &
Redtooth Triggers), would I be better off with Gymnothorax miliaris
(either the Goldentail or Banana) or Muraena lentiginosa in a
"semi-aggressive" community?
<Both eels are possible choices for your tank. The Gymnothorax miliaris
is generally more peaceful, and less likely to bite any of your fish.
The risk is only slightly higher for the M. lentiginosa, but – in my
opinion – still acceptable. I do not think it will eat the sunset wrasse
or the coral beauty, but the possibility that it might try (if it is a
very aggressive and large specimen freshly imported) has to be noted.>
How about Brazilian Dragon should one come available?
<Muraena pavonina. My personal experience with these is: they are much
more aggressive than the ones suggested above, especially the adults. I
keep them alone or with strong morays like larger Gymnothorax ocellatus.
Even those can have scars from time to time. My largest adult would
assuredly make a massacre in your tank, the only fish it showed some
respect for in the past was a G. favagineus, but they are too large in
the long run for the M. pavonina.>
Any other you might recommend?
<Chainlink Echidna catenata, White eyed species like Gymnothorax griseus
and Gymnothorax thyrsoideus. All not too aggressive species between 2
and 3 feet. I'd exclude potentially more aggressive morays like G.
fimbriatus, G. rueppellii and G. nigromarginatus. Larger species (G.
funebris, G. favagineus, G. nudivomer, G. moringa, G. vicinus, G.
undulatus...) and too small species (G. melatremus) as well as ribbon
eels should be excluded. Also have a look here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/morays.htm >
I had a wonderful Snowflake for 5 years in a previous tank and would
like to try something else. I know Zebra is a good choice, I'm not
really a fan, they look more like a big worm than an Eel to me.
<Yes, its round head and low fin are perfect adaptations to move through
the gaps and holes inside coral reefs on the hunt for hidden crabs and
shrimps. This is what it does in nature. It’s the most safe eel choice
to keep with fishes.>
Thanks again, Kirk.
<Welcome. Marco.>
Green Moray Eel –
System 04/09/08
Hey Guys,
<Hi.>
Just had a quick question on green moray eels. I'm going to be buying a
300 gallon tank 6x3x2.5 high and wondered if I could house a green moray
in it into adulthood?
<I don’t think so. For a few years it may be okay, but eventually you’ll
need a bigger tank.>
I was wanting to buy a young one and raise it up and figured if it was
fed a maintenance diet instead of power fed it would never grow to be as
big as they do in the wild
<No, they will reach their 6 to 7 feet when properly cared for.>
( I've heard Tesselata eels generally don't grow to much more than 4 to
5 feet in captivity so maybe about the same length?).
<G. favagineus stays generally a little smaller than G. funebris. Those
reports of very large (up to 10 feet) Tesselata Eels are not confirmed
by science, might be stories or rare exceptions.>
Don't mistake maintenance for starvation diet lol would never do that
just more fed in moderation. He would be the only resident in the tank
<He would eat most tank mates anyway.>
(until an adult were I would like to add some fish too small to be
eaten) and the tank would be over skimmed just more concerned if he
would be comfortable in a tank that size. Just don't have room for a
larger tank and have always been in love with the green morays so any
advice would be greatly appreciated.
<My recommendation would be to choose a less dangerous and smaller moray
eel species, something below 5 feet. There is a huge selection. Have a
look at an adult in some public aquarium or the ocean and I’m sure
you’ll re-think the 300 gallon idea. See
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ca/volume_3/cav3i1/eels/Eels.htm for
experiences with large Green Morays in the home aquarium.>
Thanks again!
<Good luck with what you decide to do, Marco.>
Green Moray Eel, now
Enchelynassa canina – System 04/09/08 4/13/08
Hey Marco,
<Hi.>
Thanks for the reply.
<You are welcome.>
If not the green then my other choice was the Viper moray (Enchelynassa
canina), which are supposed to get to an adult size of 5 feet. I was
just wondering if I imported a large one
<Smaller specimens are easier to transport and adapt better to captive
life. I think your tank could support an adult individual of this
species if it's well filtered and skimmed.>
would you think it would ignore fish say the size of a dwarf angel being
it would be too small to bother with trying to eat?
<I do not think dwarf angels would be safe, but I have not tried them as
tankmates. In fact I have not kept E. canina personally, but can only
comment from experiences with other fish-eating morays of similar size.
Mine (e.g. G. favagineus) have eaten even smaller fish over night, when
those were asleep, but I am planning to try tiny Gobiodon okinawae
somewhere in the future when I have enough Acropora for them.>
Just thought it would look sweet to have a bunch of small colorful and
peaceful fish and to have a big ominous beast lurking around in the
shadows.
<While the idea sounds reasonable (this is done in large public aquaria
with very large morays and very small fish), it will be difficult to do
at home. Chances are best when the little fish are in the tank first,
and if these fish are still juvenile specimens. Be aware that an adult
Enchelynassa canina is a very dangerous pet that can easily mutilate
your hand or arm if given the chance.>
Thanks in advance for any help you can give me on it
<Cheers, Marco.>
Re: Green Moray Eel,
now Enchelynassa canina – Tank mates 04/14/08
Hey Marco,
<Hello.>
Thanks for all the advice so far. If not small fish with the viper moray
do you think a good sized meleagris puffer would make a good tankmate?
<No, I’d bet a 1 foot puffer (the maximum reported 19 inches will be
hard to find) will be eaten. Chances for small fish (size below two
inches, no dwarf angels as suggested in the earlier email) would be more
promising. A large grouper might work, but while the eel would likely be
able to live in your 300 gallon tank (with good filtration), I doubt a
massive 2 foot grouper, which would be the size necessary to be (mostly)
safe from your 4 foot moray, would do well in there.>
Just don't see puffers to high on most animals like to eat list.
<I have seen morays eat puffers without being intoxicated. But a moray
may die when a puffer manages to puff in the predator’s mouth,
eventually you may lose both. There were pictures of such coincidences
on the net, and even porcupine fishes were found inside of larger
morays.>
Incredible as the vipers morays are it would be nice to have some other
movement in the tank.
<Sure the temptation to try tank mates is there, but from my aesthetic
point of view, a tank with one large moray is impressive enough. If you
provide sufficient water quality, you can have many different corals and
turn the tank into a nice reef section, and possibly even try some small
coral dwellers like Okinawa gobies.
As a side note: Since you considered a G. funebris first, do you know
Gymnothorax castaneus aka fox moray aka chestnut moray? Looks very much
the same and usually stays shorter than 5 feet. It’s from the Eastern
Pacific and rarely traded. Nonetheless, the same problems are to be
expected re tank mates, danger to yourself as with the E. canina.
Cheers, Marco.>
Re:
Green Moray Eel, now Gymnothorax castaneus (Panamic green),
sel. - 04/14/08
Hey Marco,
<Hi.>
Yes I do really like Gymnothorax castaneus as well but heard
they were horribly shy and hide all the time so I took them off
my list. Have you had any experience with them?
<Not from the aquarium trade, it’s not imported over here so
far. I strongly doubt it is generally much shier than G.
funebris given how many photographs of it in nature exist, and
how often they are seen by divers. This is among the top
predators in the rocky reefs of its distribution with not many
enemies as adults. I’d expect exactly the same as with G.
funebris: The young often hiding, but the adults quite outgoing
and curious. These two species are closely related.>
I have a Japanese dragon eel in one of my tanks and they say
they can be shy as well but he's always out and a bout and one
of the least shy eels I've ever owned so guess just comes down
to the individual.
<Exactly. There are general statements possible and published
about each species, but not all moray individuals seem to read
what we write.>
I sent a picture of my dragon eel with his purple Rhinopias
roommate cause you seem to be a pretty big eel nut like me lol.
<How did you come to this conclusion? Mmh… looking around you
may be right. Thanks for sharing the picture!>
Anyways thanks again for all the advice always like to have all
the info before I start a new tank.
<Very good. Cheers, Marco.> |
|
Expensive tastes! RMF
|
Moray or Ribbon
Eel... sel., fdg... – 01/09/2008
Hi -
<Hello.>
I am trying to select between two eels offered for sale at my LFS. One
is a banded moray about 12"
<Several species are traded as such e.g. E. polyzona and G.
enigmaticus.>
long and the other is a white ribbon eel about 15" long. Both are
feeding well
<Hope you have seen the White ribbon eat in person.>
and have been in the store for a couple of months. Here's my question. I
have a 55 gallon tank that's in the stamp of a 75 gallon, so it's very
shallow - around 15" high. I'm concerned about the chances of the eel
escaping. The top of my tank is pretty secure except in the back where I
have the hoses and cords running out. Is one species more likely to try
and escape than the other?
<All moray eels (ribbon eels are morays, too) are escape artists and
might try to escape. Since the Ribbon eel is so thin even as an adult, I
think it is endangered the most. Anyway, you will have to secure any
holes, e.g. with tight fitting foam, for the banded eel, too. Drying up
on the floor is one of the most common reasons of losing these wild
caught animals. Providing enough shelter and no boisterous tank mates
will also help to reduce the escaping activities drastically.>
Would you recommend one over the other?
<The Banded moray will likely be easier to care for.>
Thanks.
<Welcome. Marco.>
Moray Eel Species
Only tank for a 75g suggestions 12/28/07
<Hello Joe>
I had been planning on making my now 75g grow out tank as a species only
tank for a prized Japanese Dragon Moray eel. I know this eel max's out
at 3' so I'm a little concerned that the tank may be too small even if
he is the only one in it.
If it is too small for a DME what size eel should I be shopping for to
place in a 75g species only tank and do you have any good suggestions?
<This tank should be fine for the eel as it will spend a majority of its
time in a cluster of live rock waiting to ambush some prey. The main
points of concern are not the 75g tank size which is the smallest tank I
would use, but that water parameters are kept as constant and close to
Natural Sea water (NSW) as possible. Keeping Nitrates and Phosphates as
low as possible too will aid in the long term survival of this animal.
Finally, feeding it appropriate foods is also very important. Train the
eel to take frozen Saltwater Fish (as Freshwater fish will be too fatty)
and thawed frozen shrimp from the grocery store. These are much cheaper
than aquarium prepared frozen foods for predatory fish) Frozen foods are
best as they will limit any introduction of parasite or disease that
live foods could introduce. Hope this helps-Rich...aka...Mr. Firemouth>
Thanks
Joe
Moray Tankmates, which moray? – 5/14/07
Hi, would a undulated moray get along with a clown trigger, niger
trigger or a powder blue tang? I would like to pick just one of them for
a tank mate. And which one would be the best choice. <<RMF would NOT
place a Muraenid with Balistids...>>
<Depends...which moray?
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/morays.htm There are quite a few in the
genus...and it does make a difference re: my advice.>
Thank you
<Adam Jackson.>
Moray on 125, Sea Biscuit on the Outside... 1/8/07
Hi. I am in the process of cycling a new 125 gallon aquarium. During
the past several weeks, I have been pondering a list of possible tank
mates.
<Good timing>
Two of the fish are going to be a porcupine puffer (about 4") and a red
volitans lionfish (about 4" to 5".)
<These fishes will get much larger here... and do keep your eye on the
puffer... can get to being nippy toward the Lion>
These fish are coming from my 55 gallon. They are both health and
thriving. (The move is to provide them with a bigger tank in which they
can more comfortably grow.)
<Good>
The other tank mate I wish to add is a moray eel. After my research, I
have narrowed it down between the Goldentail moray, the Yellowhead
moray, the black edge moray, and the white-eye moray.
<All "nice" aquarium species, for folks with room...>
Of these, my favorite is probably the golden ail moray (for it's looks
and modest size.)
<Mine too>
Would this eel or any of the other morays mentioned above work in the
environment mentioned above. Thanks for any help and the best of luck to
you.
Scott
<As the saying (at least used to go) goes for when you've got to "guess"
on multiple-choice exams; "Stick with your first choice"... I would go
with the Goldentail here as well. Bob Fenner>
Re: Lions In My Tank? 12/6/06
Thanks.
<You're welcome>
It's always reassuring to hear your opinions.... Just when you think a
retailer can be trusted... He tells you a Dragon Wrasse is an algae
feeder that will get along great in your community tank....
<Those darn dealers.>
I noticed on your FAQ's some various opinions about predator fish and
starfish. Would I likely be ok with a sand star and or brittle or
serpent stars in a tank with larger fish (some predators): lionfish,
snowflake or zebra moray, etc? The other fish I'm more familiar with
and am not concerned about... But would crustacean feeding eels harass
various starfish?
<It's possible, depends on the particular eel's personality. In your
moray selection, keep in mind that the Zebra Moray can grow to a length
of over 4 feet, but are a little more aquarist friendly than the
snowflake. The Zebra Moray also tends to be out more during the day
than the Snowflake Moray. James (Salty Dog)>
Re: Lions In My Tank? 12/6/06
Oh? I have heard quite the opposite... That both zebras and
snowflakes in captivity would likely stay beneath 3ft...
<Will all depend on feeding habits and size of tank. Again, the
Snowflakes generally
will attain a length of 24" and the Zebra up to 54" under aquariums
conditions.>
And that Zebra's are more
reclusive... Snowflakes more active.
<My answer is based on the general behavior of these species. All fish
can/will develop their own personalities as I mentioned.>
From reading through your FAQ's...
It also seems more likely that the snowflake might like to taste fish a
little more frequently than zebras.
<Zebras generally are no threat to other fish inhabitants, where
Snowflakes can ambush other fish small enough to be swallowed.>
Do zebras tend to get more girth to them than snowflakes?
<Yes>
In any case, it seems like either of these are truly the best morays to
deal with... And I do realize that every individual is different. I
just hope to get a fish friendly healthy eel
that I won't lose fingers to :)
<If your worried about fingers, you are a safer with the Zebra Moray as
it is considered as one of the most mild mannered morays.
I'm sure you are aware that both can inflict very painful bites. James
(Salty Dog)>
Lionfish and an eel (crosses fingers). Rhinomuraena 12/3/06
I have a 55 gal tank that I am setting up for a lion fish, a fu
Manchu to be specific,
<Gorgeous, though shy animals>
I have a SeaClone skimmer (I would strongly suggest nobody buy 1 of
these I can't get mine to foam without it foaming like a rabid dog)
<We're in agreement>
I plan on putting in my red sea classic skimmer in my wet/dry (using a
75 gal rated wet/dry). I've read many places that the lionfish can go
into a 30 gal tank, although its my experience that almost nothing
should go in that tank for long unless its a damn damsel,
<Ditto>
I've also seen places that say some eels will do fine in smaller tanks
if they are solitary as well. My real dream is to get a ribbon eel, I
have a guy at the LFS that will get 1 and hold it for 3 weeks and show
me it eats before I buy it, in fact he insists that he hold it for 3
weeks,
<Good for him, them>
I haven't yet told him to get a hold of a blue ribbon but that is the
dream, I've seen some smaller black ribbons and I know ribbons in
particular are smaller, thinner, than most eels so I was kind of hoping
that you would tell me, well Josh the lionfish will do just splendid in
the 55 and as he is sort of a recluse the eel will do fine for a couple
of years until you get a 120 gal tank to them in.
<Mmm, nope... most Rhinomuraena (by far) perish w/in a few days to weeks
in captivity... this is posted on WWM:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/rhinomuraenafaqs.htm>
I am expecting you on the other hand to say well Josh the lion will be
fine but there is no way any eel of any kind let alone the 90% mortality
rate ribbon eels can go in a 55 gal tank.
<Oh! Yes>
If a ribbon as I expect won't be able to go in the 55 but you know of
another that will work with a fu Manchu please suggest. Please
sir/ma'am don't crush my dreams, to much.
Mucho appreciated
Josh, the eel dreamer
<Perhaps one of the smaller members of the genus Echidna. Bob Fenner>
Moray selection 11/27/06
Hope all is well at WWM,
<Hey Josh, JustinN with you today, after a wonderful Thanksgiving
weekend, thank you>
My Snowflake eel died awhile back and I am in the need for a moray.
<Sorry for your loss>
I definitely know that I do not want another snowflake.
In my opinion snowflakes are boring, and not aggressive enough for my
liking of a moray.
<Ok>
I am really looking for something that's not aggressive to the point
where I have to worry about all my fish. But I want something with a
little bit of an attitude, to the point where other fish know that
pushing it around will not be tolerated.
<Mmm, a precarious line for sure>
I am having a hard decision with the following. A Jeweled moray,
Brazilian dragon moray, Goldtail or a Green wolf eel.
<The wolf eel is out of the question, as these get HUGE. Any of the
others will likely be a wonderful addition> <<Mmm, actually... the
writer may be referring to Congrogadus... the Dottyback... RMF>>
At LiveAquaria.com they have a Goldtail moray for sale.
This is the specimen in question; He cost 230 dollars and is 12 inches
long.
<I see this, is a beautiful specimen>
http://www.liveaquaria.com/diversden/ItemDisplay.cfm?ddid=12296&siteid=20
My question with it is one would a Goldtail be a good eel for a 90?
<Is a little small, but with good maintenance should be ok.>
Two is that over priced?
<For a 12" adult beautiful specimen such as that? No, not IMO>
Three, do you trust LiveAquaria.com for a clean, healthy specimen?
<If you mean, do they have the proper facilities for good care of these
pet-fish, and good at handling shipping, then yes, absolutely. They have
been in business for a long time and have their reputation for a reason.
If by that you mean would it be ok for you to bypass a standard
quarantine procedure for this creature, I cannot recommend such.>
thanks a lot
Josh Schiff
<No problems, Josh. Hope this helps you! -JustinN>
Re: moray selection
11/28/06
Thank you for you very fast response.
How ever I wanted to make sure that we are on the same page when it come
to the green wolf eel.
I was talking about the Congrogadus Subduscens. But either way I think
I will stay with one of the other morays.
<Oh! I see this... would be as suitable as the others.. Lovely species
as well. I was thinking of Anarrhichthys ocellatus... to 2.5 meters in
length! See FishBase for some info on this massive, but lovely creature:
http://filaman.ifm-geomar.de/Summary/SpeciesSummary.php?id=3813 I
amend my statement about the carpet-eel, it would likely be an excellent
addition as well. -JustinN>
Social Eel? 7/7/06
What eel do you think is the most comfortable in the reef aquarium?
<Depends on the make-up (livestock-wise) of the system... but likely an
Echidna species or Gymnomuraena>
I know the risk with keeping them with inverts, but I think the zebra
moray is the candidate for me.
<Great animals>
My only real question is do they hide all day like many morays or are
they out during the day.
<Do come out a good bit once acclimated>
I am hoping to have an eel that will at minimum keep its head exposed if
not take the occasional lap around the tank. What do you think? As of
right now I
have a ghost moray that I have only had for about a week and I never see
him. Can I expect the same from a zebra?
<Mmm, no... the latter is much more outgoing... though both take time to
"get used" to new surroundings>
I love eels but I am on the hunt for the "best" eel. Any suggestions.
Thanks.
<Mmm... please read here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/ca/volume_3/cav3i1/eels/Eels.htm
and the linked files at the bottom. Bob Fenner>
Richardson's Moray 6/10/06
Hello Crew,
A local LFS has had a Richardson's Moray (Gymnothorax richardsonii) in
their tank now for 3-4 months. Certainly not the flashiest looking of
eels (now about 10-11 inches),
<About as large as it will likely get:
http://fishbase.sinica.edu.tw/Summary/speciesSummary.php?ID=6579&genusname=Gymnothorax&speciesname=richardsonii>
but would look better under proper lighting. No one seems to be
interested in him and he seems to leave the various tank mates he's had
alone (triggers, puffers, angels, .
Very little information is available on the web. His small adult size
(13") is appealing. I can't find information about his demeanor. Will
he be more like a zebra or a dragon eel?
<Am only guessing, but I'd say more like the former>
Why aren't these eels more talked about?
<Of the two hundred plus species of Muraenids, only a handful make up
ninety some percent of those offered in the trade. I have seen
Richardson's in the wild (Cooks, Polynesia), but never in the industry>
His relatively low price ($29) is also appealing and the LFS is willing
to cut that in half because of the length of time in their tank and the
relationship I have with them. Funny thing about him, I can't see any
teeth like you would see on a normal Gymnothorax. Makes you wonder how
"piscovorish" he would be.
Thanks as always for the help
Jeff
<Again, am guessing, but I'd say this species is likely to be a general
omnivore. Bob Fenner>
Snowflake Eel Wanted 3/24/06
I live in the suburbs of Atlanta, Georgia, and would like to know if
I could find any snowflake eels near where I live for a very cheap
price. Could you help me? My email address is XXXX@bellsouth.net <Peter,
in your area this shouldn't be too difficult to find. Call the shops in
your area. I'm sure they can order one for you if none are
stocked. You will have to deal with the price. James (Salty Dog)>
Thank you!
Eel Selection - 2/15/2006
Hi Bob,
<Todd>
I have a 90 gal tank, its not finished cycling yet however I am planning
ahead. I really would like to have an eel in the tank when it is time,
and I have read much about what there is to consider. Since my tank
will be a reef community tank, crustaceans will be abundant.
<?>
The "praised" eel I keep reading about is the Snowflake Eel, and
coincidentally also the one at the LFS that really got my head stuck on
the idea of having an eel. My biggest concern, is the crustation that
this eel likes to eat.
<Crustacean>
I have images in my mind of placing this great eel into the tank and the
next day any emerald crabs or cleaner shrimp
have been devoured. My second concern, is that the eel grows to two
feet. Although my tank is 4 feet long and should be sufficient for
space for a Snowflake Eel, I am hoping to avoid very large specimens so
that I can have more healthy living space for more inhabitants.
<Will eat the crustaceans, eventually grow too large for this tank>
The other Eel species I have read about that peaks my interest that may
be a better fit (if I can find one) would be the Pacific Golden
(Gymnothorax melatremus). I may be way off but I would think that the
small size of this Eel would deter it from eating larger (more
expensive) "show" crustaceans and also help with my goal to maintain a
lot of space for a higher quantity of smaller inhabitants (instead of
having a few big fish I would rather have several smaller fish and
variety).
My method of thinking, again maybe way off, is that the eel should be
one of my first tank inhabitants so that it can have first choice for
the cave in the tank that it likes best as it's dwelling before other
tank inhabitants "make their homes" ( I have several suitable cave
area's in the rock and there is one particular large cave that if I was
an eel, It would be my first choice).
Would you recommend that the smaller Eel would be better for what I am
hoping to accomplish in the big picture?
<I wouldn't give such advice w/o knowing what else you intend to stock.>
Is the snowflake actually a better choice because of other
reasons? Should I abandon the idea of having an eel at all if they need
to coexist with crustaceans, or is there perhaps another species that I
should consider?
<I would not stock an eel with a "community" tank...>
I am new to salt water, and I think I should stay away specimens that
might require the care of a more "experienced aquarist".
<I'd try other, smaller fishes than... or settle on a FO system... or
build your collection around the/an eel species...>
Thanks in advance, and you have an excellent resource here - I have
used it several times already as I learn my way through my novice marine
experience.
Todd
<Keep studying Todd... you'll soon know what your choices are. Bob
Fenner>
Moray Eel article 1/8/06
I just read your article, both parts, on the idea of Moray Eels as
pets. I just wanted to say that I have been fascinated with them since I
was a little girl in Hawaii and on various aquarium trips (the one in
Albuquerque, NM has several BIG Green eels in it. They attack the glass
randomly). I thought it would be impossible to own one but your
information has given me a little hope. The Banded Moray looks similar
to the Green one and seems to be several feet less large.
<Yes>
Now I just have to figure out how to get a wall-sized aquarium through
my front door.
<Heee! A few strong friends>
Thanks ever so much!!
Kristene
<Bob Fenner, who hopes to put up a public aquarium at NELHA (formerly
OTEC) north of Kailua-Kona, on the Big Island... with a large (perhaps
circular tank from Mitch Gibbs) display of Puhi (local morays).>
Re: fish compatibility and new news ... Cramming in a moray
12/24/05
Hi Bob,
<Chris>
Sorry, another question. I think I am going to go with the
porcupine puffer, however, I recently discovered a site (Marine Center)
that sells all sorts of marine fish
<An excellent company... many rarities, good service, quality>
and states that a Honey comb moray can be kept in a minimum size tank of
55 gallons!
<Mmm, well... at an absolute minimum perhaps>
A little hard to believe but never the less it sparked my interest
because I have always wanted on and since I have a 110 gallon tank with
no inhabitants currently, maybe this could be a possible fish I could
stock, I hope. They say that in nature They can grow a little under 6
feet but rarely exceed 3 feet in captivity.
<Do agree with this... but a three foot fish in a four foot long tank
(55)?>
If It is possible for me to keep this eel, would it be fine with a
porcupine puffer providing that the puffer is large enough.
Thank you again!
<I do wish you and your livestock well... do keep an eye on them. Bob
Fenner>
Chris
Moray Eel Selection 12/14/05
Hi,
I've recently set up a 400 litre marine aquarium consisting of a
jewel
<Juwel?>
rio
<Rio>
400 tank and two Aqua medic bio star hang on filter/skimmers. I have
transferred 60 litres of mature water from a long established tank that
I have upgraded from and topped it up with salted RO water from my LFS,
but have not yet added any fish.
<Sounds good>
I have seen a 2ft Tesselata eel that I think is really cool, and the guy
in the shop said they are very hardy and he would be fine as the
"starter fish" in a new system, is this true?
<Not IMO, and this tank is too small...>
If so, I know a 5ft long 400 litre tank will not be suitable for its
entire life, but the LFS said it would be around four years before I
would have to upgrade to a larger tank, how quickly do they grow?
<Not pertinent. This system is too small currently>
My final question is would I be able to keep any tankmates with him?,
maybe a lionfish or porcupine fish?
<I would not do this>
(At the fish store he is currently in with a large dogface puffer, 2
banner fish and a large porcupine fish).
Thanks
Kev
<There are some other species of Muraenids/morays that are smaller, more
compatible... these are covered on WWM. Cheers, Bob Fenner>
Moray Eels and some Article Clarification 12/7/05
Hi,
<Hello Kev.>
I have been trying to get hold of a Hawaiian Dragon Moray in England for
over a year now with no luck (only one fish store said they could get
hold of one, but it would cost around $1900),
<For that much you could almost fly to Hawaii and see them for
yourself.>
so I have decided to look at other options, I have ruled out the
Tesselata eel due to its size
<Oh yeah, that’s a big one.>
but I am interested in Gymnothorax flavimarginatus & Gymnothorax
meleagris, as these eels do not exceed four feet I was wondering why
your moray section says that these two species are not suitable for
aquarium use,
<I’ve read that article and from what I got out of it the author (Bob
Fenner) did not say that these two individual eels were inappropriate
but more that morays are inappropriate in general, here is a direct
quote, “Unfortunately, with the exceptions that we'll mention, as a
rule moray eels are best left in the seas from which they came.
Generally they get too big, are too ornery, even dangerous for
aquarists, rendering bacteria-infested bites to the unwary. Of the
several varieties often offered to the hobbyist, scads refuse food or
readily escape the confines of too-small, inadequately-secured aquaria.” >Yes.
RMF<
As for recommendation of the Tesselata, the article mentions that it is
, " the Leopard or Tessellated Moray is one of the few members of the
genus I can honestly endorse for home use,” This does not mean that
the specimen is a good home choice, simply that if you MUST have this
genus, that this specimen should be chosen over some of its cousins
which can reach 10 feet in length. It is also my personal experience
that this specimen adapts to captive life and prepared foods much
easier, having said that, I must mention once more that it still attains
a great size at almost 6 feet and is not suitable for the average home
aquarium. There are a few other much more suited animals which Bob goes
on to list in the article, out of those my personal favorite is:
Gymnomuraena zebra, the Zebra moray.>
<<Oh! Oh! They're MY favorite, too. The ones I've handled
are so amicable, "bullet-proof" (don't frighten easily, just very
nearsighted, that they are truly pets. Marina>>
but recommends the Tesselata which I have been told is one of the
largest, aggressive morays available.
<One of the largest and aggressive readily available, yes…the largest
and most aggressive period, no.>
Thanks Kev
<Welcome, Adam J.>
Chainlink moray and pistol shrimp, Or, Fish Soup That's Not as
Good as "Siete Mares" - 11/28/05
Hi. I have a 45G reef with a regal and purple tang, a maroon clown,
a marine Betta, a Longfin fairy wrasse, a pistol shrimp/goby combo
<Yikes! Would you like some water with your fish?>
and I just recently came across the cutest little Chainlink eel. I
couldn't help myself. He ate right out of my hand and he's really tiny,
so I took him home. My question is, do you think my little ol' eel will
take out my awesome pistol shrimp? If so, how much and what should I
feed him to keep this from occurring? I'm hoping not to regret my
decision in the near future. Please help. Thank you!
-Ash
<It is possible that it will consume the shrimp, but unfortunately you
have much larger issues at hand here. Sorry to be the bearer of bad
news, but your tank is very heavily overstocked with inappropriate fish.
Neither of those tangs, singly, should be in a tank of under 100
gallons, and some would argue that even this is too small. Fairy wrasses
are highly active and would also benefit from a larger tank. The marine
Betta will also outgrow your tank, and is also quite likely to mistake
your shrimp for food.
Even short-term, this crowded tank is an almost impossible proposition
to maintain healthily. If I were you, I would focus on thinning down the
fish population to something that you can support long-term. Many ideas
for more appropriate stocking may be found on WetWebMedia. Best regards,
John>
Tesselata Eel Tank Size and Behavior 11/3/05
Hi,
<Hi Kev.>
I am considering keeping a Tesselata moray in a 144 gallon aquarium
<Short term I hope, this is a tank buster at a potential 5 feet+ in
length.>
am I right in thinking that I wont be able to keep any other fish in a
tank this size?
<Or the eel for its entire life.>
If this is the case, how lively is the eel likely to be?
<Most morays are rather reclusive and become slightly more active at
night or feeding.>
I don't want a tank that looks empty most of the time.
<Lost of other good choices that could give you much more variety and
enjoyment in my opinion.>
Thanks
Kev
<Welcome Adam J.>
Mexican dragon eel 10/21/05
Hi,
I've wanted to setup a saltwater tank for many years and was given a 55
gallon tank by a friend so I decided to jump in. I've always wanted
eels so I've been reading everything I could find and came across your
web site. Today I came across an eel that I really liked and was
informed by the owner that it was a Mexican dragon eel. My questions
are, is a 55 gal tank big enough for this eel and say a lionfish?
<Mmm, no... not even just for this species of eel... needs at least
twice this volume>
Is this type of eel hard to find normally and usually
expensive, because I know Hawaiian Dragon eels are.
<Is about the same retail in most places in the world... a bit cheaper
closer to the source>
And lastly how must live rock/and what type of filtration should I go
with?
<Please read here:
http://wetwebmedia.com/morays.htm and the linked files above>
A friend is going to give me a wet/dry system that he was going to use
on a 120 gal tank and I was
looking at an Aqua C Remora hang on protein skimmer. Is the wet/dry
system needed for just these two fish? Any help would be appreciated.
Thank you
Larry
<Please read on WWM re wet-dries, marine filtration... Bob Fenner>
Smaller Eels for Smaller Tanks 10/6/05
Hi Bob and Crew,
<Hi Josh, Josh here today. I guess this feels like you've answered your
own question, and rightly so.>
I currently have a 65g (36" x 18" x 24" high) tank, that I would like to
have as an eel tank, the eel being the only inhabitant. <Good call
here> Although I find species like the snowflake and ghost eels
stunning, I am drawn to the Gymnothorax genus. I find
both the miliaris and lentiginosa to be incredible, however I fear that
a 65g may not be sufficient to house the animal throughout its life
<indeed>. I was hoping you could recommend some other eels that are
suitable for a tank this size. Please tell me that people with smaller
tanks are not restricted to only a few eels!
<Unfortunately, tank size dictates much for us all. I would view it as
a "goal" more than a restriction. You would most likely run out of
space eventually for most eels. Maybe try a small specimen and plan on
"growing" your tank with the eel. More on eels here,
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/marine/fishes/index.htm
Thanks so much.
<Glad to help. - Josh>
Re: Tesselata Moray in a 60" x 30" x 30" tank 9/11/05
Thanks for the quick response, In light of your opinion I have
decided to reconsider, my LFS also say the Tesselata Moray in their
experience is the most aggressive Moray.
Would a Dragon Eel be more suitable? and if so could I pair it with
a Lion fish?. I have contacted my LFS in England, and they say they
could source me a dragon eel in 3-4 weeks for 600 -700 English pounds,
would you say this is a fair price?
(Tank size 60" x 30" x 30")
>>>Hello again,
I'd say that is expensive, but about what I'm used to seeing nowadays
for that animal. I paid $100 for mine (roughly 200 pounds?) 10 years
ago. They are a better choice in the size department for sure given your
tank size. How about a zebra moray, a dragon moray, and a Mexican
dragon? You could put all three in a tank that size.
He should be fine with a lion fish.
Cheers
Jim<<<
Eel problem... actually, selection 9/5/05
Hello Again
I completely agree that a tusk gets too big, just wanted to make sure.
But my next question is (I seem to have lots of them) which species of
eel I should get for my 75. I have been thinking about the Barred,
Snowflake, Jewel, or any other species you could suggest. I am just
looking for an eel that would be happy and comfortable in a 75 gallon
tank for probably its whole life.
Thanks Again
Patrick Nikiel
<Of those listed, just the Snowflake. Please read here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/moraycompfaqs.htm
and the linked files above. Bob Fenner>
Releasing eels back into the oceans 8/15/05
PLEASE HELP!!!!
<Okay>
I bought a small (at the time) green moray eel 6 years ago. Of course
the LFS did not inform me and neither did I do my research, shame on me
shame on them, prior to buy this beautiful creature. He has become part
of our family, I can pet him almost the whole length of his body,
excluding his head. He, of course, has become much too big for me to
handle.
<And dangerous>
At this time he is about 5 feet in length and as big around as a
baseball bat. He is in 180 gal tank and as we both know is and will be
much too small for this part of my family. It is very heart breaking
for me to get rid of him, but would rather get rid of him then to keep
him confined. I have contacted some of the local state aquariums with
no success. Can you please help with what the laws are with releasing
these creatures back into the oceans.
<Likely this is not allowed, but even if there are no specific statutes
re, please do NOT do this... possible introduction of other organisms...
make that probable... and your pet eel may well not survive>
He is perfectly healthy and his hunting skills are still in tact, I
think. I have tried to put other larger fish, i.e. lions, groupers, in
with him in. Forget it he knows how to attack. As you can tell this is
a hard for me and my husband to do, but feel it is in the best interest
of THE EEL to either release him into the wild or place him in a public
aquarium.
<Or perhaps someone who has much larger quarters>
I am willing to pay the cost of transport and will do it myself if
someone can help me with a GOOD home for him. I refuse to put him to
sleep!!!!!!!! I made the mistake and I am willing to do what it takes
to let him live. As you can tell I am going to have to have therapy
over this. Any info (or support counseling) you have on this would much
be appreciated. I would like for you to post this and encourage people
to REALLY do their research on their purchases. This is much to heart
breaking.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND KNOWLEDGE,
Karen
<Karen, do try calling the larger service companies in your area (look
in the "Yellow Page" directory of your phone book under "Aquariums,
Service"... Very likely there is someone with a very large, nice system
that will continue to look after your cherished pet. Bob Fenner>
BIG EEL DELIA
I forgot to mention my location (and the eels). We are located in
Asheville, NC. Hi to all of you regular readers of WWM you know who you
are!!!!!!
Thanks again
Karen
<Mmm, would you like us to post contact information? BobF>
Eels, Gymnothorax tesselata/favagineus yea, G. moringa nay?
Hey there,
I was just cruising your moray FAQs and articles and I was A:) blown
away by your knowledge and B:) confused and confounded by your
recommendations on species suited to aquaria. You list the spotted moray
(Gymnothorax moringa) as a bad species for home aquariums, while you
recommend the tessellated moray (Gymnothorax favagineus ). I have one of
each in my aquarium (135 gallon; the spotted is about 20" and the Tessy
is about 30", there is also a 16" Epaulette shark), and I must beg to
differ. My spotted is tame, active and even playful, while the Tessy is
aggressive and reclusive. He is also constantly rearranging his hideout
by wiggling his body and sending substrate flying. When his rocks
finally topple over he becomes irate, having ruined his shelter.
Inevitably, he will then try to attack me as I fix his house.
<Yikes!>
The spotted on the other hand happily shares his shelter with the shark
and occasionally swims about. Is there something regarding spotted
morays I'm missing?
<Doesn't appear so>
I should also
point out that the spotted tops out at about four feet, while
tessellated morays can get close to six.
<Yes>
Also, I was wondering, is smelt a satisfactory food for morays?
<Yes... a bit oily, but very palatable, nutritious>
I mix it up with squid, shrimp, salmon and even sword fish sometimes
when they're lucky, but they LOVE smelt. Is this ok?
Thanks,
Pat
<Thank you for the input Pat... Am going to (on your advice) move the
TWA Spotted Moray into the "good" column. Cheers, Bob Fenner>
Re: Tale of two eel species, smelt
Bob,
I'm glad I was able to help, and my spotted was happy to hear that his
name had been cleared, and both eels are pleased that they can continue
to enjoy smelt as their favorite dish.
Thanks,
Pat
<Mmm, now I'm getting a hankering for a smelt sandwich! Thanks, Bob
Fenner>
Anonymous Eel (Sure Ain't F/W!): Part II & We are So Rude.. How
Rude are We?
First off sorry about typing in all caps.
<Apology Accepted. :-) >
But you don't have to be so rude.
<Hmm...I've reviewed the initial query and my response, and I have yet
to find a case where I was rude and/or shallow and/or demeaning.>
Some people are not as smart about this fish as you are.
<I do not claim to know everything about this, or any other fish. I am
merely a normal person that volunteers answering a massive amount of
questions from a massive amount of people for a fish web site.>
Second, he is a Gymnothorax tile (scientific name) in case you did not
know.
<<Gymnothorax spp.>>
<I did not know a single thing about this eel from the email you sent.
By providing this information, I am able to answer your previous
questions here. I do sincerely hope that you possess a rather large
aquarium (~500 gallons, give or take), as Gymnothorax species attain a
very decent adult size. From this page:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/moraysii.htm
"Most Gymnothorax species get too big, are too aggressive and strong
for all but the most humungous systems. If you're going to try these,
watch your fingers, tankmates and lock (yes, lock!) that cover down. For
cooler water species, do invest in and run a chiller. species get too
big, are too aggressive and strong for all but the most humungous
systems. If you're going to try these, watch your fingers, tankmates and
lock (yes, lock!) that cover down. For cooler water species, do invest
in and run a chiller.
Too often offered to the hobby are the Atlantic green G. funebris, to
eight feet! Others include G. javanicus, the Javan or Giant Moray (to
ten feet!) and G. flavimarginatus to a mere four feet."
I would personally recommend returning the creature.>
And I went back to the pet store and got all the info I needed.
<Eegh! The pet store, in most cases, has to be the worse place to go for
information. Sure, there are responsible ones, but that certainly is not
the norm. You were very right to come to us for an answer. Just a heads
up, a bit of research will teach you more than you could ever need to
know, and it is most often accurate, unbiased information. May I point
out the Google search feature implemented into WetWebMedia's homepage?>
Maybe next time show people a little bit of respect and don't be so
shallow as to think that you are too good to talk with common courtesy.
<I do not think I am too good to talk with common courtesy. In fact, I
do not think that anyone is. Just for your information, this is a free
service. We are normal people with normal lives who have taken time out
of those lives to assist people with their fish problems. We don't get
paid for this, aside from in thanks, which we get plenty of. I think
that Anthony put it best when I asked how to deal with your email:
"The bigger WWM gets, the more people we serve/satisfy... and the
greater the number of minor meanies occur just the same."
All of that said, if you don't like my attitude, next time you have a
question, be sure to ask for "Anyone but Mike G." Frankly, I do not like
yours, so that would suit the both of us very nicely. Have a wonderfully
pleasant afternoon, Mike G>
Meleagris eel
I would really like to add a 'golden moray' to my FOWLR system. It
has several other fish in it already (puffers, grouper, angel, trigger)
with the smallest being the trigger (Huma) at about 4". I'm hesitating,
so that probably means I shouldn't do it, right? I have another eel by
himself, a retic moray, who is very aggressive and will eat anything
that he sees, or at least try, even though he only gets thawed food (he
got a taste for tankmates, so now he has none and I have my other,
larger tank... a common story, right?). I see other people with other
morays in their fish only tanks, living quite peacefully. But my
experience tells me there is another side to the coin. Meleagris was
mentioned several times, but I couldn't find anything 'in general' about
its temperament. I have wanted an eel in the system from the beginning,
but as described above my first attempt didn't work out. Any thoughts?
<Reuben, are you sure you meant miliaris or did you really mean
meleagris. If it is the meleagris, they can grow up to 40". I suspect
you have a rather large aquarium that your keeping these critters in,
correct? Anyway, here is a link on eel compatibility.
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/moraycompfaqs.htm James (Salty
Dog)>
Meleagris eel - II
Sorry to split this into two e-mails, but I just realized that I
forgot to mention how big the miliaris eel is. His skull (which is the
part that matters, no?) is about an inch long.
<Don't understand, "skull is the part that matters", matters to what?
Fish loading in a tank, if that is what you mean, is based on the total
cubic inch size of the fish.
<Other info was sent out earlier. James (Salty Dog)>
Gymnothorax miliaris Eel, Not G. meleagris? Which is it?
Hey James, thanks for the quick response.
<You're welcome>
I may have meant meleagris... could you clarify? The moray I'm talking
about is the golden-tail moray...
<I was looking for info on your original ID of Golden Moray and not the
Gold Tailed Moray.>
...this particular individual is the mostly gold variety with a few
brown dots. On your site, on the moray intro page it is listed as
Gymnothorax miliaris...
<Yes>
... with the gold variety coming predominantly out of Hawaii.
Fishbase has another eel, a "turkey moray" listed under meleagris, and
also lists miliaris (but you have to search it because for some reason
it isn't listed with the genus Gymnothorax... I suspect nomenclature
issues. I think I'm talking about miliaris, with a maximum size around
30" (comparable to a snowflake eel). I do have a large aquarium (210)
which I have since my other eel has to live in the other tank (which was
too small for all the fish I had purchased without reading first
anyway). Now I have both tanks doing fine and with good amount of space
for the fish I have. And I still really want to have a moray in the tank
with my fish... I'm just trying not to be resigned to a snowflake (which
are nice, but I had my heart set on a more yellow moray... color scheme
and everything... you know...). So this "Golden Tail Moray" is what I am
really inquiring about. Which one is it, and will it be alright?
<What is listed on our moray intro page will be correct. In the short
time I've known Mr. Fenner, I can assure you there will be no errors
present. Very few fish are compatible with morays as you well know, and
my reasoning is if it can't eat it, then it's compatible. Obviously you
won't have any eel predators in your tank, and I would avoid putting an
eel in with any slow moving fish. I think you are on the right track
doing your homework on the WWW. Most any questions are answered here.
Good luck with your eel selection. James (Salty Dog)>
Miliaris eel
Thanks again. You're right, I don't think WWM has any errors... in
fact, you guys and the book are like my bible as far as aquariums go.
<I believe that is the intention, to help others.>
Thanks for all of the invaluable information. I'm sure you know how
difficult it can be to find reliable information (hence the common name
problem - golden moray, gold tail moray, banana moray, yellow moray...
why doesn't everybody just use Latin names?!)...
<Most hobbyists don't like Latin names, much easier to remember common
names such as Gold Tailed Moray, Yellow Tang, rather than miliaris blah,
blah, blah>
... and I applaud your more than thorough job of providing it.
<Thank you!>
What kind of eel?
Bob,
<Hi there>
Great site! My son must have an eel. Currently we have a 125 gallon reef
tank, Aqua C 240 skimmer, Korallin Calcinator, wave makers, great water
quality. We have 65 pounds of live rock and sand with two SPS corals and
one bubble tip anemone, one fish which loves the anemone. Additional
tank mates shrimp, (I know these will not last with an eel). What would
be the best way to go when cost is not that big of a consideration? In
advance - Thanks for
your time.
<Mmm, a tough one... not only the shrimp, but the anemone and coral may
be threatened (by physical movement, pollution from wastes... You
definitely want to aim for a small/er species, slow-growing... I would
likely stick with my plug for an Echidna species... Please read here:
http://wetwebmedia.com/morays.htm
re Morays in general, and on to the Related FAQs (linked, in blue, at
top) on Selection, and Compatibility. Bob Fenner>
2 Moray Eels and Aquascaping
Been through your great site. I'm planning to get a 125-gallon tank
(48X24X24) and the following inhabitants:
1 snowflake eel
1 leopard eel (I like the fact it's active during the day. Please let
me know if there are any other nice looking eels that are active during
the day)
<There are quite a few... but this size system... and keeping the
Snowflake... I would not add any more>
1 Volitans lionfish
School of 3-6 small fish.
<May be food items for your Lion...>
I want to get eels that are 1.5 - 2 feet in length. Would this setup
work?
<Only for two specimens maximum>
Can you recommend small schooling fish that are too big for the leopard
to eat?
<Likely Damsels of a schooling, upper water column nature. You can read
over these selections on WWM>
Also, aquascaping question: On the MorayFAQs3 page, Anthony mentioned a
subterranean plumbing system described in his Book of Coral
Propagation. He mentions clear tubes siliconed below the sand and
against the front glass to see the eel swimming down below. I would
like to do this too. But would this not defeat the purpose of having a
place where the eels can hide? I'm thinking that light will be able to
get through to the eels.
<Mmm, maybe... though Muraenids do not have keen vision, and likely
light will be limited here>
Finally, he mentions there were two stalactites of rock coming down from
the ceiling. How's this done?
<I suspect he is suggesting siliconing the base of these stalactites
from a glass support above the water. Bob Fenner>
Thanks
KC
Re: 2 Moray Eels and Aquascaping
Bob, thanks for the response; very helpful. Forgot that the
lionfish might also eat the schooling fish if they're too small.
I actually meant to ask if there's another eel I can substitute for the
Zebra, to keep my options open. Any suggestions on other eels that are
similarly active during the day? KC
<Not really... as stated, I encourage you to stick with just the one
species here, the Snowflake (Echidna nebulosa)... most suitable for your
size, shape system. Bob Fenner>
- Adding an Eel -
Dear Bob,
I came upon your site last evening and tried to read as much as I could
about this eel. We have a 400 gal tank with: large porcupine puffer,
rainbow puffer, 14" French blue angel, 14" gray angel, 5" queen angel,
5" emperor angel.10-12" Naso tang, 4"yellow tang, 6" blue tang, 5" Huma
Huma trigger, blue line trigger,7" white face angel, 8" blue ring angel
and some small ( 2-3") damsels that were the starters.
The guy who takes care of the aquarium and our fish wants to add a
dragon eel. I am not sure of it's current size but he says it grows to
18" and is docile. I have read so many conflicting articles, letters and
statements that I feel unsure of this addition. Are my current fish
going to be in danger?
<Not necessarily, but I think I'd forgo this choice in your situation.
While this is a very good looking and docile eel [in eel terms] your
tank sounds like it has enough going on without the added bonus of an
escape artist in residence. I think you'll also find it won't be exactly
cheap. If you can live without this, I would.>
Please respond ASAP if you could as he would like our answer by Monday
10/04/04.
Thanks for your time!
Sincerely,
Linda
<Cheers, J -- >
- Adding an Eel, Follow-up -
Dear WWM FAQ Crew,
Thanks so much for your rapid response! <My pleasure.> I completely
agree with you. This was not a specimen I was looking into, but offered
by our "tank caretaker". <All the more reason to pass on it.> This is a
seasonal home so we are not there much through the winter. I just did
not want any problems with the other fish being in danger. I also don't
know exactly how large it would get and basically want to keep the
"peace" in my aquarium! <You can expect the Dragon eel to make it to
about two feet.>
Thanks for your quick reply, I really appreciate it. Will stay tuned to
your wonderful and informative site!
Sincerely,
Linda
<Cheers, J -- >
Eel in a 45 gallon?
Hello Crew,
I love this resource. The best I've found by far in keeping me from
inadvertently mistreating fish. Thank you so much for providing it.
Don't worry. I didn't buy something without knowing how to care for it,
but I am hoping to avoid such in the future. :)
The moray page says, "A minimum of forty gallons for the smallest of
morays." I wanted to know if this means total water volume vs. main
tank volume, as a permanent home or until it gets bigger, and what
species would do best in a smaller tank. I have a 45 gallon that may
eventually go from a peaceful reef to a more aggressive tank whenever I
can get a larger tank for a bigger reef and transfer most of the
inhabitants. I'm interested in the possibility of an eel and could
maybe add a sump for increased total volume and a more powerful skimmer
to keep water quality up, but I don't think I'd want to add an eel if I
could have no other fish in there. I was thinking a snowflake
originally, but then I read here that it needs at least 60 gallons.
Live Aquaria carries what they call Uropterygius concolor (ghost eel or
unicolor snake eel as it's called here) that supposedly only needs 30
gallons, but that's the only eel I've seen on a fairly reputable site
that seems like it might need less room than a snowflake. Does their
description sound accurate at all, or does this eel need far more room?
They don't mention it living in brackish water as your site does, so I
worry.
http://www.liveaquaria.com/product/prod_Display.cfm?siteid=21&pCatId=1737&TopCatId=29
The Chainlink (Echidna catenata) is suggested at 30 gallons on Marine
Depot and 125 on Live Aquaria, and I tend to assume the pessimistic
requirements are more likely to be right, especially when the site
claiming 30 suggests 30 for a snowflake as well.
Ideally I'd love to have a small eel someday that could live with a
couple 3-6" fish like maybe a maroon clown and a long-nose Hawkfish, so
is there one that fits the bill offhand, or should I really make other
plans?
Thank you,
Ben
Hey Ben,
A snowflake or a chain link moray will live in your tank for a time, but
both will grow to need larger quarters eventually. When I make fish
stocking recommendations, I like to set the person up long term, not
just for 2 or 3 years. In staying with this method, I'd have to say
steer clear of these eels. Although they are both hardy and easy to care
for species, they are more appropriate for tanks 75 gallons and above.
They will both jump from tanks that are not securely covered as
well. The eel you linked to may work, but I've honestly never kept that
species so can't comment from direct experience. I have to say though,
that it really isn't all that attractive IMO. I would make other plans
for your tank. 3 or 4 small fish will do much better in a tank that
size.
Jim***
Moray selection questions
hey what's up you guys!
<< Diving and fun in the sun. >>
(firstly, your website's awesome, I spend hours reading through
all the FAQs.)
<< I'm glad it is useful, but you should thank Bob. >>
anyways, I've decided I want a saltwater eel for my 29g aquarium,
<< Bad idea. I can't think of any eel I would put in a 29 gal. >>
I know that's small, but I'm planning on upgrading in a year or two to
a much larger (60-100g or so)
<< In that case, I say wait a year or two until that tank is up and
running. >>
and the LFS said it takes some eels (i.e.: Chainlink/snowflake) 3-4
years to
reach max size. so I've been researching and found the Dragon Moray and
love
it. however, I need some solid info, I've seen several conflicting sites
saying it is either very aggressive or fairly passive, which is true? <<
Well they want food. So if you don't feed them, they will be
aggressive. If you do keep them well fed, then maybe they won't
be. Either way I would be cautious and treat it as though it will be
aggressive. But once again, not in a 29 gal. >>
secondly, how expensive are these dudes and how fast do they grow? (I
know
they get up to about 3') also, would a dwarf zebra lionfish be a good
tankmate? << Yes, good tank mate. I see them as similar in environment
condition needs and would feel comfortable with them in the same tank.
>> and what type/brand of protein skimmer do you recommend? << The
bigger the better. >>
(preferably less expensive w/ good quality if possible) what's the best
way
to get a dragon moray? one of those online suppliers or have the LFS
order
it? << I would go with a LFS because they can bring it in and quarantine
the fish before you buy it. Much better than chancing the health of an
online fish (at least is my opinion with this specific fish) >> (ps. my
LFS is very reliable and I have great confidence in him as he is
a biologist and my boyfriend has known him for years, etc.) sorry about
all
the questions, I just don't wanna screw up and kill any marine critters!
<< Bigger tank, take is slowly, that is my advice. >>
thanks so much WWM!!!!
-Stacey
<< Blundell >>
Non-fish-eating Eels?
Hi,
Are there any moray eels that will leave smaller fish alone like
clownfish and damsels?
Thanks for any info
<The crustacean eaters... e.g. the members of the genus Echidna and
Gymnomuraena... are good choices here. Bob Fenner>
Re: Eels?
Thanks for responding so fast!
So would a snowflake moray be okay with small fish? Would it try to eat
them or would it basically ignore them, since fish aren't even part of
their diet in the wild........I think?!
<Echidnas rarely consume fishes... in the wild or captivity... only when
very hungry w/o other foods available>
Biggest fish in the tank is going to be a Firefish goby. Would a small
moray be preferable or a larger one, that way the eel would be able to
get use to the fish and he wouldn't even be able to get the other fish
down their through?
<Yes, to start>
I found the coolest baby snowflake at the pet shop and its in the tank
with Chromis and baby blue tank and it looks like it he thinks they
aren't even there! Eel is only about 4-5 inches. how big do you think
they would get in a 70 gallon. Thanks again for the info!!!!!
<Ultimately about two feet in length, over several years. Feed it
crustaceans like cocktail et al. human consumption shrimp on a feeding
stick. Bob Fenner>
Marine Eel Selection
<Hi Matt>
My little cousin was interested in getting an eel, but was disappointed
to learn his 20 gal. tank would be too small. There is a 190 gal fish
only tank residing in the living room. it contains some damsels
(hopefully dinner), clownfish, tangs, and a Foxface lo. It may soon
contain a puffer as well. Are there any eels that would be good
candidates for this tank? he was hoping for a dwarf moray or snowflake.
<Actually I think a snowflake might be suitable for the tank but I would
make sure it has a top on it. Good luck, MacL.>
matt
Dwarf Golden Moray (5/16/04)
I have plans to purchase a dwarf golden moray but I am having
trouble finding info on these eel. In a fish magazine these was a brief
article on them, saying that they would be good in a nano reef. <How
Nano? Looks like they get to be about a foot long. Do count on it to eat
any small fish and any crustaceans in your tank.> What I do know is that
they are a yellow to gold color with bright blue eyes. Can you tell me
anything about these eels? <If you do a Google search, there's lot's of
info out there. I got a lot of hits.> The scientific name is
(Gymnothorax melatremus). Marine Depot Live has a waiting list for them
and other individual have them listed from $250 to $450. What do you
believe the true price range is? <From what I saw, people have paid
anywhere from $200 to over $500 each> I can buy directly from a
wholesalers who has them priced at forty dollars. Thanks, Andy <Sounds
like a steal. I hope it's not "too good to be true." Steve Allen.>
Dwarf Hawaiian moray eel source 2/17/04
Do you know of ay sources to obtain Gymnothorax melatremus? I have
been looking to purchase one and no one seems to have one. Tell me more
about this eel and why it is so hard to find.
<one of my fave eels... a fantastic reef safe species... max adult size
8-10" (20-25cm). The better wholesalers each get them a few times
yearly. One of my fave places for rare and unusual is Erik and Denis
Reynolds place in Cali... AM4fish.com Scott Michael has used and cited
them for rare and usual fish species photo ops often too. best regards,
Anthony Calfo>
Moray question 10/30/03
Are any of the breeds of moray suitable to be housed in a 90 gallon?
<hmm... a few. Depends on what other tankmates you might have. Your best
bets are the crabs eaters versus the fish eaters.>
If so, which ones. Also, what is the recommended order that an eel be
added.
<Snowflakes are excellent overall and top the list. Add them sooner
rather than later>
Should he be allowed to settle in and calm down, or should he be the
last specimen added.
<the former>
I've been looking at a snowflake, but was advised by one of your staff
to look into the zebra.
<the zebra is even more sedate and peaceful than the already
well-behaved SF... but zebras are notoriously finicky feeders. Never to
be recommended as a first moray species>
I've checked out a few zebras at my LFS and most of them seem so
inanimate to the point that they look dead. Is this natural or could
these possibly be poor specimens?
<nope... they are indeed staggeringly shy if not sedate>
I have yet to see one open mouth breathing like the others. Which you
have to admit, is one of the cool things about morays.
<hmm... yes. cool. And more conspicuous with the narrow beaked fish
eaters which tend to be larger, meaner and more tricky for you. Stick
with the snowflake my friend... just a wonderful species overall.
Anthony>
A Foray Into Morays? (Thinking About Getting A moray Eel)
Hi,
<Hi there! Scott F. with you today!>
I am interested in purchasing a Zebra Moray Eel from my LFS, I have also
just purchased and just set up my 75 gallon SW tank. I plan to put live
rock in there too. I am interested in putting the zebra along with a
Valentini puffer or one of the smaller puffers (5" max) and a butterfly
fish, maybe a raccoon or Copperband, and a Tang (Big enough not to fit
inside the Morays mouth). Would the 75 gallon be big enough for the eel
to live its whole life?
<Honestly, I'd say no. Sure, this fish, like many Morays, does not swim
all that much, but you still need to think about it's ultimate size
(they can reach almost 5 feet long!) and the copious amount of metabolic
waste the fish produces. And, to be quite honest with you, the other
fishes that you are proposing are simply too much for this sized tank.
Part of the pain (and fun) of planning a community of fishes is the
mental "projections" that we must make as to the prospective
inhabitants' needs and requirements. I like your thinking about the fish
living "its whole life" in the tank...That's how we need to think. I'd
shoot for much smaller fishes, or species from the families that you are
interested that are much, much smaller...Did you know that there is a
"Golden Dwarf Moray" that only gets like 10- 12 inches long? check out
Marine Center (see link) for availability. They are very pricey, but
they are hardy, long-lived, and very appropriate for a smaller system!
See- you can have your moray...You just need to make some
concessions...It's a trade off, for sure!>
Also would the other fish be able to co-exist in a 75 gallon with the
zebra for their whole life?
<As above...Re-configure your proposed population...We have awesome fish
resources on the WWM site that you can check out!>
Thanks for your time, I appreciate what you and the other crew do to
help us out. Thanks once again,
Gerard
<Glad to be of assistance, Gerard! I'm sure that you'll develop a great
stocking plan for this tank! Good luck, and have fun! Regards, Scott F.>
Are White Eye Moray Eel's rare?
<Gymnothorax thyrsoideus? Not exceedingly so. Not in the wild within
its range, nor the pet-fish interest. Though this species is not one of
the "more commonly offered" Muraenids>
I am having trouble finding them in the aquarium trade. Are they
seasonal?
<Nope. I would try one of the mail-order/internet marine livestock
suppliers... like MarineCenter(.com) or MarineDepot, Dr.s Foster &
Smith... they can get them>
Thank You
Brandy and Keith Prentice
<Bob Fenner>
Zebra Moray - 8/20/03
I currently have a 55 gallon hexagonal aquarium and a 29 gallon
rectangular aquarium. (Both are separate.) Can either of these tanks
support a zebra moray eel?
<the 55 could just barely IMO if it only housed the moray (no other
fishes). This is a very thick and hefty species... not the smallest
either growing to over two feet long>
If not is there any other species of moray eel that would be better
suited for the aquariums?
<a snowflake moray would be much much better... hardy, handsome and
generally a more slight adult than the zebra. Fine for your 55 gall>
Thanks for your time
<best regards, Anthony>
Eels for a 150gal
Ok, I want a large moray for a 150 Gallon Tank. I know the
tesselata would work, as I was told (thanks IanB)<it wouldn't work for
its entire life, but what about a Green Moray?<they get too large> Or
perhaps
a Zebra Moray? <A zebra moray should be ok> And I am not talking about
these fish being able to remain in it for a little while, I mean for its
life. <also you could get a snowflake eel> Thanks for your help!<IanB>
- Eel Selection -
Hi Bob.... great website....
<JasonC here this morning.>
I've had snowflakes in the past but am looking for something different
for a 90-gallon fish-only tank that I have set up. I've looked at
several site and several species, but am still not sure which eel I want
to purchase.
Here are my hang-ups...
1. Price (I really can't afford to drop a lot of cash on the fish),
<Then this will be your main limiting factor.> 2. size (I don't mind
something that gets large, but not one that will possibly outgrow my
90), 3. temperament (I'd rather not have an eel that might take a chunk
out of its other tankmates), 4. looks (I want something somewhat
attractive etc..., but I'm really not sure.
Not sure what advice or suggestions you might be able to give me, but
any thoughts would be appreciated. I did see a golden tail or yellow
spot in my local store the other day, he was $65 which might be more
than what I want
to spend..... not sure which species it was. <Sounds to me like you need
to make the big decision. There aren't many eels that stay small...
snowflakes are common, relatively cheap, and don't get too big. Many of
the other eels that fit that bill are expensive. More on your eel
choices here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/morays.htm >
Thanks.
<Cheers, J -- >
Dragon Eels and Tesselata Eels
Hey guys,
My first question is about Dragon Eels. How easy are they to keep?
<Very much so. Same old challenges of not letting them get out of the
tank... getting big, being messy...>
I currently have a Chainlink eel and a Blackedge and they are pretty
easy to take care of. Both were really easy to switch to frozen food and
are fairly fun and personable. Is a dragon the same way?
<Yes>
Or am I looking at something that is gonna be more difficult to care
for?
My second question is that I have fallen in love with Tesselata eels. I
currently have an empty 75 gal that if I got one would go into until he
outgrew it. How fast do these guys grow?
<Not that quick... a few inches a year... given "just" feeding for
maintenance (as opposed to growth, satiation>
I have heard that they can be pretty aggressive and I have heard that of
the larger morays they are one of the best to keep. Any info on them
would help.
Thanks for your help,
Wade
<Please see the various references to the Moray Eels posted on the
materials archived re the group on WetWebMedia.com
Bob Fenner>
Eels
Thank you for your response Cody. That is well needed information
concerning the decision of the what type of eel to purchase. I
researched a lot about the Zebra and Snowflake as well and I think I
would rather go for a Zebra because of the personality and aggression
levels it has but was wondering two things.<This is a great choice, I
have one myself that will eat out of my hand! They become very tame
after a while, mine even lets me "pet" it.> One web site I found said
they were difficult to keep compared to other eels and I want to know if
this is true and if so what makes them difficult compared to
others?<They are a very hardy choice, although they can sometimes have
problems with blindness.>
Next question would be could I keep a large sea cucumber with this eel?
<Yes> I pride myself on researching and making informed decisions
especially when it comes to the life of a living creature.
Also, if you don't mind will a Zebra work well in a 125g tank or should
I just get a snowflake? <He should be fine, just keep the tank under
crowded with a protein skimmer to clean up after their messy
meals. Cody>
Please advise,
Thanks,
JB
Moray Query
Hello,<Howdy, you got Cody today.>
I am very interested in purchasing a moray eel for my tank and have
found a place that has several to choose from. I like the snowflake and
the zebra and have read a lot on your site about them, but the one that
I am really interested in buying the honeycomb eel. What I would like to
know is would this eel work well in a 125 gallon tank? <Not for long.>
What is the max length of this eel? <I have seen four footers, but have
read they can reach six.> What does this eel eat, fish or inverts?<Fish>
Is this eel aggressive or calm? <They are usually very
aggressive. Cody> Anything you could tell me
about this specific eel would be great.
Thanks, JB
Overdosing???
Hi,
<Hi Ronnie, PF here this AM>
I am having chemical problems with my tank. It is a long story so I will
just ask my questions.
Let me first say, I almost have it under control.
tank is 75gal.
only inhabitant is Gymnothorax funebris
<Are you aware that these eels can reach 6' in length? Such animals are
best kept in public aquariums where they have the space for such an
animal.>
Ok, my first question is in regard to overdosing on certain chemicals to
try and help stabilize the water.
Can I overdose the tank on
1. StressZyme
2. Ammo-lock 2
3. Proquatics water conditioner
4. ProClear by Kent
<Not that I know of>
I have been adding one dose per day of each after a 25% water change
(tank is 75gal.).
<That looks like overkill to me.>
once the tank is stable I am going to do another 25% water change.
Water is still a little cloudy.
ph 8.0
nitrite 10ppm
nitrate 200ppm
ammonia 8ppm (should not be toxic)
temp. 77
salinity 1.024
I lost my biological filter due to medicating.
<I see. IMO, you should remove the eel to a QT tank and keep it there
till your tank has re-established the biological filter. Time is what is
going to cure this, not chemicals. Do consider finding a new home for
your eel, one more appropriate (IMO a 500g tank at home is too small.
There are many other members of the family Muraenidae that would make
much better pets. Do look here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/morays.htm, and consider getting Scott
Michaels Reef Fishes Vol. 1 - it has an extensive section on moral eels.
> I know I shouldn't have medicated the main tank. I am still a rookie.
<We all make mistakes, the key is learning from them. Then you can make
all new mistakes. ;) >
Ok, second question how long does each dose (StressZyme, ammo-lock2,
etc...) last? <I would assume until the chemical agents are all bound.
Sorry, I'm not a biochemist, that's the best answer I can give.>
Last question, if I run the protein skimmer will it pull all these
(StressZyme, ammo-lock2, etc...) out of the water?
<I would think so, but after they have been bound to the polluting
agents. At this point, you need to treat your tank as though it was a
brand new setup, and let it cure as you would live rock. For the sake of
the animal, please remove it.>
Thanks,
Ronnie
<Your welcome Ronnie, I hope I've helped. Remember to thoroughly
research any future purchases you make, and good luck. PF>
New Jersey
Overdosing on eels
Thanks for the quick response.
<We aim to please. :) >
I know how big this moray can get, I do plan on getting a bigger tank. I
was told that some green morays only get 4'. I read a lot about the
Gymnothorax and I still can't find accurate descriptions of the
different green morays. <Then you don't know how big it's going to get.
I've seen just how big those 6' eels are. I hope you get a really big
tank.>
Maybe I have the one that only grows to 4'.
<Maybe, do check out the book I recommended, lots of good info on morays
in there.>
As for removing the eel to a QT, how can I make a QT tank if I don't
have good established water? <Move him over to the QT, and do water
changes every day. A pain in the posterior, but worth the eels life.> I
wish I had a better place to put him until the tank stabilizes, I would
do it in a sec. He doesn't seem to be stressed, his color is good and he
is breathing normal. <The problem is that fish can be like birds -
looking ill is an invitation to be eaten.>
Should I be running the protein skimmer?
<Yes indeed, you should probably also be running activated carbon too.>
Thanks again
<You're welcome, hopefully I've helped.>
Golden moray
Hello again! I currently own a large peppered moray with a Volitans
lionfish (and various other assorted tanks with mostly south American
cichlids). I've recently become interested in setting up a small,
separate tank and keeping a golden moray (not a golden tail!). I read a
short article on keeping nano reefs (have some experience with this) in
a magazine that said golden morays would do well in a 10 to 20g tank. It
also said they don't get over 7 inches.
<Mmm, don't know (nor does fishbase.org) this species. Do you have a
scientific name?>
First of all, is this true?
<Mmm, not as far as I'm aware. The smallest morays grow to about a foot
and a half in length... most of the more than 200 species to more than
twice this length>
Second, I can't find much in the way of pricing, although I have found
numerous sites that said the yellow variety is hard to find and much
sought after. This is the species I'd like to keep. Is the care of a
small moray much different in the way of feeding/tank cleaning?
<No... just able to wiggle out of smaller spaces...>
Any info or sites you have on this species would be much appreciated. I
can't even find a listing of them on your site - thanks!
Bryce
<As stated, have never come across this species. Bob Fenner>
Eel question...
Mr. Fenner:
I am considering a jump into the world of eel care. I have taken your
recommendations to heart and am considering the Echidna nebulosa,
Gymnothorax favagineus or the Gymnothorax miliaris.
<All worthy species of morays>
I currently have a 40 gallon (3 feet across) that is unoccupied, the eel
would be its only resident.
<I would strike the favagineus off your list for this size tank>
Should the 40 not be suitable I have no problems waiting until life
affords me a larger aquarium, but what size would say is ideal for any
one of these fish.
<A hundred gallons for a small individual (up to eighteen inches let's
say), twice or more for a larger one>
I have experience with reefkeeping and aquarium keeping in general. I
would use a plenum, protein skimmer, two canisters (this offers better
filtration) as well as a two powerheads to help keep the water
oxygenated. But It's the size of the tank I am concerned about.
<Mmm, I wouldn't use canister filters on tanks with large fishes,
eaters, defecators like the Morays... something sump-like is better by
far.>
Any comments would be greatly appreciated.
Thank-you for your time, Vito Pilieci
<Looking forward to reports of your progress, planning. Bob Fenner>
Tesselata Eel
I was thinking about adding a tesselata eel (12-18 inches) along
with my goldentail moray (12 inches) but I was wondering if the
tesselata if try to eat the goldentail once it was about 2.5 feet in
length?
<Too likely so for me. Bob Fenner>
Eel question
Hi. I currently have a 75 gallon tank with plans to upgrade to a 125
this summer. I currently have a niger trigger and a Huma Huma trigger in
the tank. Both are about 4-5 inches and doing fine. I want to add an eel
and there are two that I just am having a very hard time deciding on and
so I am wondering if I could put both eels into the tank right now with
the two triggers and house them compatibly together until I get the 125
then switch everybody over to it. The two eels I am interested in are
the Fimbriated moray and the banded moray. Both are about 8-10 inches.
Do you think that this can be done compatibly?
<Mmm, there is some chance that your triggers may chew up these eels at
this small size...>
I have very good filtration on the tank and an Aqua C protein skimmer as
well. I have lots of hiding places also. Any help would be much
appreciated. I really would love to have both eels and the triggers but
do not want to order them and THEN find out that I cannot have them.
Thanks Tiffany
<The eels themselves should be fine together now and for quite a while
in your size system... It's just the worry about the unpredictable
nature of Triggerfishes that concerns me. Bob Fenner>
Eel addition to 75 gallon tank...
Hello,
I have contacted you previously and you suggested that I wait a month or
so until I think about adding an Eel. Well, here I am, a month away..
let me recap my livestock... a Scopas tang, panther grouper, porcupine
puffer, niger trigger, Tasmanian damsel and domino damselfish.
I want to add an eel, but will/can this realistically be put into my 75
gallon FOWLR system?
<In a 75? Not for too long... this eel will have to be a species, size
to compete (and not get eaten!) by the other fishes (all but the Tas.
may hassle it...)>
I have 50lbs live rock and 80 lbs live aragonite sand. I haven't seen a
trace of ammonia, nitrite or nitrate in over two months. I've recently
added a 400gph powerhead for increased circulation, it really seems to
make the tank a more active community. I have a Prizm skimmer that,
since I last contacted you, I went to my LFS and they offered to take it
back if they couldn't make me happy setting up/instructing me in store
on how to properly set it.. now it works great, no air bubbles and skims
a bucketful of scum out of the tank that I have to empty almost every
3-4 days.
<Sounds good>
Now.. as far as eels go, I really do have my heart set on a Tesselata
moray eel.. How large do these get?
<Up to about four feet in captivity:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/morays.htm >
and would they work in my system?
<Crowded... but is going to be too crowded even without adding the
eel... do you have plans for a much larger system? Even just the eel
can't live indefinitely in a 75 gallon system>
If not, can you suggest an eel that would?
I'm trying to stay away from zebra/snowflake now that I've done a bit of
research.. Tesselata is the only one that I've read is compatible in
fish only systems. Thanks again friend, Bill Hammond
<Please do look over the "Moray" parts of our site (WWM), and the
references posted there... and let's chat further. Bob Fenner>
Re: Eel addition to 75 gallon tank...
Hi again!
I do plan to eventually get a larger system (perhaps an eel-only one)
leaving my current fishes to their 75 gallon setup.
<This system will still have too much fish life w/o the Eel>
This, however, would be at least one if not two years down the road. I
read every bit I could on WetWebMedia about morays. It said eels grow
slowly in captivity...
<Most species, most circumstances, yes... but large species fed often
can grow a foot or so a year>
So I asked my LFS what size I could get and the buyer there is going to
look for a 1.5 ft specimen of tesselata and contact me if/when he finds
one. Would this be the right size given that most of my fish are very
young still.. the largest is the Scopas (about 6 inches long) and next
largest is the panther (3.5-4" long)
<The Tesselata is a piscivore. It may well eat all these fishes in time.
An eighteen inch one could eat most all that you have now.>
If I went with an eel of this species/size, how long could I get away
without adding a new system? (I would like a 150gallon, saw a great
looking set-up at LFS) Would 150 be enough for a full grown tesselata?
<Barely>
Thanks again, you have truly been so much help.. I've gotten frustrated
with
my LFS a few times, or not been able to get a straight answer.. but you
always seem to shoot back an email quickly and are always informative..
you sure make keeping a captive ocean enjoyable!!! Thanks so much for
all the advice you've given me!
<Very glad to be of assistance. Have you ever considered dive/adventure
traveling, going to visit these animals in the wild? Bob Fenner>
Take care, Bill Hammond
Re: Tesselata moray
Doh forgot one last thing..
I saw a picture of a leopard moray.. looks very similar to tesselata..
but was very recommended on your site.. would this eel be a better
choice for my FOWLR tank (very aggressive one) ?
<About the same situation all the way around. There are some smaller
species of Muraenids... but they might well have troubles with some of
the fishes you have in turn. You need more and larger systems. Bob
Fenner>
Thanks again, Bill
100g reef (livestocking a reef)
Hello,
I am setting up a 100 gallon reef with 125 lbs rock and a 2" sand bed. I
already have a 4" Fu Manchu Lionfish, and a 6" marine Betta which I will
move from my old 55g tank. I have three other species I'm thinking of
adding. First is Opistognathus rosenblatti (or another species of 5 to
8" Jawfish) , the second is Gymnothorax melatremus, and the third is the
leaf fish.
Do you think the Jawfish would do ok with these small but predatory
fish?
<Not the Moray>
My main question is about the dwarf golden eel. I checked Fishbase and
they say it gets 10" long and has small conical teeth. I would
appreciate any knowledge you might have on this species. Id like to keep
a small moray in this tank but am fairly worried about it.
<You should be. Fishbase is generally spot on... but doesn't offer
husbandry information. Please read through our coverage of these eels:
http://wetwebmedia.com/morays.htm>
Finally would this fish mix do ok in a reef tank. I will not be keeping
any shrimps or small fish but would like to keep hermit crabs and
snails.
<Should be fine... with a small eel. Bob Fenner>
Thanks, Everett
Which Eel?
Hi Bob, I have in my 90g tank a 4" fu man chu lion, a 5" black
Volitans, a 3" Picasso trigger, a large say 6 or 7" majestic angel and a
6" panther grouper along with 1 little Fijian and 1 blue Chromis damsels
and a pajama cardinal.
<Yikes... some crowd now! And soon to be much more crowded... hope you
have a much larger system in the planning.>
125 lb of live rock and 25 lb of live sand. since I don't like food to
be left over in the bottom (sand) which moray eel, if any, is more
suitable for the tank. or any other suggestion?
<A bigger tank! No morays here w/o shipping out two or more of the
larger fishes... Otherwise, my take on the Muraenids and beyond is
posted: http://wetwebmedia.com/morays.htm>
I have a Sealife minireef system that comes with the protein skimmer
integrated that is doing quiet well. Thanks for your help!!
<Do consider trading in some of these fishes... before you run into
troubles from the bioload in your ninety. Bob Fenner>
Another ? - this time @ eels
Thanks for your help on the algae ?'s!
What, is THE eel least likely to eat crustaceans and grab fish -
Snowflake, Zebra or Leopard?
<The first two for not grabbing fish, the last one for not grabbing
crustaceans>
I've read through the info on your website and would really like to add
one, but am torn as to which one. I like that Leopards swim out in the
day, and I think snowflakes are pretty....
I have Mithrax crabs in my tank, but think they are getting toooo big
and grabby anyway. If I added one of these eels, how do you think my
urchin, sand star, cuke, cleaner shrimps will fare?
<Likely fine for the echinoderms... the shrimps would be lunch if it
were one of the first two>
Here again is a list of occupants in my 75 gal tank w/ 60# rock & 2"
crushed coral sand: yellow tang, Sailfin tang, blue regal tang, Banggai
cardinal, maroon clown, small blue neon damsel, flame angel, bicolor
angel, Longnose Hawkfish, sand star, impatiens cuke, 3 Mithrax crabs, 2
cleaner shrimp, 3 cleanup hermits, tuxedo urchin, BUNCHES of small
feather dusters. Thank you Guru! Linda
<This system is too small, fish-crowded for any of these Eels for when
they grow... Bob Fenner>
Re: Another ? - this time @ eels
OK, good point! - I have one 4" fish, six 3" fish and one 1" fish =
23 "fish-inches" (I made that up) How much less fish (or fewer
fish-inches) would be optimal for one of these 3 eels in 75 gal ?
<Hmm, it's not the "present inches" that concern me, but the potential
"inches"... You could place (best) a Snowflake that is small now, and of
the three will "stay" smaller over time... but all will be crowded a
year or two down the line>
Thanks, Linda
< Be chatting, Bob Fenner>
Morays
Hi Bob,
I am looking at getting a 125 gal tank and was wondering if I could
house 2 of the following a Zebra/snowflake/dragon together?
<Yes, they can be kept together in such a system>
Or what would be allowable tankmates. (clowns with anemones?)>??
<If the anemones were placed high enough in the water column. Likely on
live rock>
I read the long article on the Zebra moray, is there any literature
online about dragon morays?
<Don't know... search by the genus name... some on fishbase.org>
Kurt
<Bob Fenner>
Cortez Dragon Eel
I was wondering do you think that I could add a 10” Cortez Dragon
Eel
to my 200 gal FOWLR tank with these following fish already in occupancy?
12” Snowflake Eel, 6” Vlamingi Tang, 5” Pink Tail Trigger, 5” Paddle Fin
Wrasse, 5” Twin Spot Coris Wrasse, and 6” Red Coris Wrasse. The Cortez
Dragon would be the last addition to the Tank. I know that the current
tank size seems like I will be overcrowding the fish but I'm waiting on
my 360 gal tank that is on order. I know that Eels hunt at night and was
wondering if you think that I would wake up one morning to find my
Paddle Fin missing? My Snowflake missing?
<Hmm, well, if these fishes were consumed by the Cortez, it would take a
couple of years for this to happen. I'm more concerned that the trigger
or Coris wrasse might harass this young Muraenid... but give you good
odds that this addition will/would work out>
I’m looking for an Eel that I could start off small and probably wont be
a total terror as it gets larger to my current set-up. I don’t want
anything like a Zebra moray, but something different that you don’t see
often in the pet stores. Any suggestions? Already tried looking on the
WetWebMedia site and various dealers. Any extra information would be
appreciated.
<Please look over the section "The Fishwatcher's Guide to... Tropical
Eastern Pacific" posted on the WWM site, and consider picking up a copy
of this book... need to get them out of the living room. Bob Fenner>
Stocking question w/eel
I am desperately trying to make up my mind on which route to take.
If you could help me in deciding which would be the best route to go, I
would be most grateful.
<Okay>
My tank is a 75 gallon Fish only with live rock. I currently only have
about 10 lbs but am adding about 35 more this weekend. I have the new
Ecosystem sump filtration method running on my tank. I have about 15lbs
of live rock and crushed coral each. I also have an Emperor 400 that I
am still running as a result of switching over to the Echo System sump.
I will eventually take if off unless I need to leave it on.
<Good attitude>
1st choice - I would like to put an eel in the 75 with one showpiece
fish able to be able to be with the eel, (not many choices here), and
yet not
bother the live rock.
<Or overwhelm the filtration... messy animals>
I was considering the Cortez Dragon Eel or the dwarf golden eel, (If I
could find it anywhere), and the Clown Trigger fish. I had also
considered the undulated trigger. I was told that as long as the clown
trigger, or undulated trigger were well fed they wouldn't bother the
live rock or the eel.
<Not necessarily... the Triggerfishes are unpredictable...>
2nd choice - Tang tank. I was looking at the blue hippo tang, (maybe 3),
Christmas Island Flame Angel, and possibly a mated pair of Gold striped
Maroon Clowns, along with my selection of inverts.
<This is better than the first choice>
3rd choice - Again, the Blue Hippo Tangs (maybe 3), and 2-3 painted
frogfish, or the wartskinned frogfish.
<Just get one... this is all you'll end up with anyway... they'll eat
each other...>
Can you help me with any of these decisions and tell me which would be
the best in your experience?
<Hmm, of the three, number two is the best for sure>
Also if there is a choice you would pick as the best but it needs a few
changes please let me know. I would rather know before hand that after
the fact.
One more question. Should I end up going with the eel choice, IF and
WHEN, the eel would outgrow the tank, the big question is if you don't
have a bigger tank yet and the LFS won't take it, and you can't sell it
to anyone, what do you do with it?
<Ads in the papers? Most public aquariums don't want overgrown
Muraenids...>
Please help! Just as an afterthought, I am going to be getting a 125
gallon middle of next year. Thanks again for all of your help. Robin
<Keep studying, considering your options till you're sure of where you
want to go. Bob Fenner>
Re: Stocking question w/eel
Thank you so much for you speedy reply. With your help I have
narrowed it down to 2 choices.
1st, Putting just a Dragon Moray in the 75 with the Live Rock. I know
that they are messy eaters, my son has a snowflake right now, but I
believe I can keep up with that. (I also considered instead of the
triggers putting in the clown tang but I don't know. Would it be better
with just the eel with this choice?)
<The Regal (Acanthurus lineatus) will/would be fine with either Eel...
the Dragon might eat the Snowflake if placed together>
2nd, the blue hippos (3), (this is possible to keep the 3 together
right?),
<Yes>
the pair of maroon clowns and the Christmas island flame angel with my
choice of inverts.
The reason I asked if I could even keep the 3 blue hippos together is I
hear so much about not putting the same species of tang in the same
tank.
<Many species aggregate/associate in the wild... Paracanthurus is one of
them>
My cousin used to have a 125 with a purple tang, yellow tang, blue hippo
tang, powder blue at one time, then had to get rid of it because it was
so mean, and 3 other tangs that I don't remember the name of. But he
said that they all did great, even with having 6-7 tangs in that tank.
I really wanted the powder blue but after reading your site I have
changed my mind. Thanks for all of your time and patience. I really
appreciate it.
<You're welcome my friend. My success and enjoyment are tied with yours.
Bob Fenner>
Re: Stocking question w/eel
Thanks again. You have been such a big help that it makes enjoying
this
hobby that much more fun. Thanks again. A sincere saltwater hobbyist.
Robin
<You're welcome my friend. As you know/will know, this sharing is very
important to me as well... an opportunity to make the distance and
concise distinction twixt our lives and "the planet" that much smaller,
less evident. Bob Fenner>
Trouble deciding on morays
Hi Again Bob,
Sorry to be pestering you every day for the last few days ...... this
will be the last Q for a while now :-) .... so hopefully you are not to
sick of me! Thanks for your recent correspondence RE my proposed FO set
up, I really appreciate your help.
<You're welcome my friend>
Due to a pic I saw today, I suddenly feel this re-occurring urge to add
a moray to my selection.
I have always been interested in the snowflake and zebra moray ......
but also really like the leopard (Gymnothorax tesselata). I have also
seen pics of Gymnothorax favagineus, which bears a striking resemblance
to the tesselata ...... is it by chance the same species ???
<It/they are indeed the same species... you can see this in Scott
Michaels fabulous first volume of "Reef Fishes" as well as on the net on
www.fishbase.org>
I prefer this species to the invert eaters ..... I like the "menacing"
looking head .... which seems more pronounced, and the big gaping mouth
..... which is less pronounced in the Zebra and snowflake.
I read an old article about marine oddballs, namely about morays, which
said that ....... "The leopard moray (G. tesselata) is most outstanding
and attains 75cm (30") in captivity" . I find this hard to believe ???
How big could I expect one to get in my 84"x18"x18" tank ??? .... a once
a week feeding routine is planned.
<At least this size... likely a few to several inches more over time>
Tank mates are most likely going to be:
Emperor angel
Long spined porcupine puffer (D. holacanthus) .... or maybe a Arothron
type ...not sure yet.
Volitans lion (or maybe a fuzzy dwarf lion instead)
Miniata grouper
Of the 3 (4?) morays listed above, which would you find:
1) The most suitable as a tankmate ?
2) The "best" aquarium choice
3) The most active (during lights on period)?
<The Snowflake for 1,2... the Tesselata for the third>
Could you also give me an idea what size to expect from each species,
including both length and girth ...... I have read so many differing
reports, that by now I am confused !!! Are there any other species that
you think might be worth considering, other than E. catenata, S. grisea,
<Catenata is a great species, very rare in the trade though... See the
Moray sections on our site: www.WetWebMedia.com for a bunch more... but
the ultimate (sort of good guess) for the Snowflake... a couple of feet
long, two or so inches in diameter, the Zebra, three feet long, three
inches in diameter... the Tesselata three and a half feet long, four
inches in diameter...>
Thanks a lot for reading, and for your help. It is really appreciated,
as is you fab site :-) Cheers, Matt
<Chat with you soon my friend. Bob Fenner, visiting on Hawai'i's Big
Island>
(Co. Cork, Ireland)
Morays in Reefs with Cartilaginous Fishes?
Hello,
This will be my final question. When I put my fish in to the
bigger tank that I am setting up, I would like to do something new in my
125. I was thinking 2 big eels the golden eel and the Brazilian dragon
eel or tesselata eel. Either one not sure but are they reef safe
because I want to make it just coral and eels. is there any certain
corals they like to eat if any that I would not want to buy?
<None of these Morays will eat corals... but do arrange your sedentary
invertebrates "high and tight" to discount these going-to-get large eels
nightly forays...>
Is there any other fish that I can keep with the eels and coral?
<For the eels, fast and smart ones... for the corals... ones that don't
eat, bother them...>
With the big eels I know they eat a lot would that affect the corals or
would it be better with just one eel?
<It's going to be a big job with even one as it grows...>
How big would these 2 eels get in this tank because I don not plan on
upgrading the size of the tank for the eels.
<A few feet>
Do all of these eels usually live a long time I heard the morays are
pretty strong fish to not as good water quality?
<Hmm, yes, they're very tough as marine fishes go>
Would a shark or stingray work with the eels I would maybe get a little
stingray or leopard shark?
<No my friend... Please read over the shark, ray, moray sections on the
www.WetWebMedia.com site.
Bob Fenner>
Eels
Bob, I am interested in purchasing a Moray eel. I was wondering
which eel would be more compatible with Tomato Clown and Damsel sized
fish: Zebra or Snowflake? Thanks for your help, Kelly
<Only a few choices here... as most Moray (family Muraenidae species)
are fish-eaters that get more than large enough to eat your livestock.
Either genus, species you list will do... Please read more thoroughly
about them on posted materials on the site: www.WetWebMedia.com Bob
Fenner>
Dragon Eel
I was thinking of buying a Dragon Eel for my 180 FOWLR. What do you
think about this eel? Does he get fairly big? Long? Will this type of
eel go after everything? I really can't find that much information about
this specimen.
<Enchelycore pardalis? About three feet maximum length... a fish eater.
Will eat what it can/does catch>
If I did buy this type of eel will I be able to put my hand in the tank
to clean it.
<Yes, carefully... watching where the Moray is... keeping your hands out
of its way>
Your opinion will be greatly appreciated. Could you also give some
examples of some other fish that I should be able to place in the tank.
I'm
assuming that all other fish in the tank should be 7inches or bigger
correct. When buying fishes of this I'm sure my selection is limited due
to
the fact that most fish do poorly when you purchase them at that size.
<Hmm, depends on the starting size of the Moray... do read over the
selection pieces and Moray cover article posted on the
www.wetwebmedia.com site. Bob Fenner>
Re: Dragon Eel
Does this go the same for the Cortez Dragon Eel? Does this eel look
similar in color (markings)? Would this be a better choice? Will this
eel come out and show itself during the day?
<Yes, yes, about the same in choice, and eventually. Bob Fenner>
Eel selection
I have a 180 gal. FOWLR tank, 8ft long. I would like to add an eel
to the tank but I'm having mixed feelings about this because of what
people are telling me about them. I would like to have a Dragon eel but
the guy told me that he would have to be in a tank by himself (would be
kind of boring to have just 1 eel in a 180 gal by himself). Then I saw a
picture of a Tesselata and someone told me that these guys are too
aggressive and would eat what I have in the Tank. My tank includes:
Lrg. Naso Tang
Med. Red Coris Wrasse
Lrg. Dusky Wrasse
Med. Dragon Wrasse
Lrg. Chevron Tang
After looking at your recommendations on wet web media I saw that the
only ones that you suggested for home use was the Snowflake, Chain,
Girdled, and Zebra eels. Do you know of any web sites where I could find
a good picture of the Chain and Girdled eels? I would like to check one
of these out to see what they look like. Which one of these two would
you prefer?
<Actually, these are my fave choices but a Tesselata could go in your
180... and with the other fish livestock... for a few years if you're
careful not to feed it too much/too frequently... but enough. And no to
a website, but Scott Michael's v.1 Reef Fishes book has some fab
coverage.>
I'm looking for something that has some color to it (Different). The
Snowflake and the Zebra eels are nice but I would rather have something
else. After looking at my current stock would an eel even work? Are
there any other eels that would work?
<Yes, even the larger piscivorous ones would do given the usual
provisos... careful feeding, a secure tank cover... starting with an
appropriate sized individual (shades of the Three Bears!)...>
The only thing else that I might add to my tank is a Juv. Passer Angel
or Grey Angel (if I can find one). What do you think about this
selection? Are there any other fish besides these that you think would
be a real showpiece?
<Should work, and many... MANY! Keep dreaming, scheming and gathering
information. When you have enough, you will know. Bob Fenner>
Eel question
Hello I have a 55 gallon tank with 25lbs of crushed coral and 15lbs of
sand, and I am going to buy 25lbs of live rock today at the LFS. I
am thinking of putting a blue ribbon eel in the tank first. My
question is how hardy are these guys and how are they at taking
food. Is there a eel which you would prefer? What kind of live
fish should I feed them, I would really want them to eat frozen
food. Later I am think of putting in a loin fish and maybe a stone
fish. And will these fish eat peppermint shrimp and snails?
Thanks
<< The Ribbon Moray Eel's"? Genus Rhinomuraena? Terrible choices... most
die, jump out (99.9%) within a month of capture... And yes, they do eat
crustaceans... if they do eat in captivity.
There are some fave Muraenids (morays)... The Snowflake and relatives of
the genus Echidna, and the Zebra's (Gymnomuraena)... but they REALLY eat
shrimps... You can read my take on true eels stored at
www.wetwebmedia.com in full if you'd like. Bob Fenner>>
Questions about Eels
Hey JasonC,
<<Howdy>>
My LFS keeps their eels in one tank. They got snowflake and zebra eels
sharing their homes in PVC pipes.
<<you realize this is because they don't expect to be keeping them for
very long... >>
Is it okay to get one of each in a 55 gal. tank?
<<I personally wouldn't do it. Better to have just one and enjoy it.
You're going to be kept very busy by one Houdini let alone two - these
guys are amazing escape artists.>>
I am also planning on stocking the tank with a marine Betta and a dragon
wrasse. How does this mix (2 eels, 1 Betta, 1 wrasse) sound? Do they
have enough room to live together peacefully for many years?
<<How about one eel, one marine Betta, and the wrasse for a couple of
years? Perhaps some other small-ish fish - a pygmy angel >>
Does the wrasse prefer sugar-fine sand or something coarser?
<<I would think the sugar-sand would work best>>
Thanks.
<<You are quite welcome. Cheers, J -- >>
Eels getting along?
What are you guys opinions on a Hawaiian Dragon Moray and a
Gymnothorax melatremus coexisting in a 120. The dwarf pretty much hides
all day with his head poking out. Do you think he would end up a snack
or would they be alright?
<<Hmm, hard to predict. I'd say at best the odds are 50/50 that the
smaller eel would become a meal.>>
Thanks, Ken
<<Cheers, J -- >>
|
|