Figure 8 puffer question, fdg. mostly 9/20/08
Hi.
<Hello.>
We have had a figure 8 puffer for about 3 months now. We have
a 55 gal, brackish tank set up, crushed coral substrate, salinity is ~1.004-5
right now, pH ~8.0-8.2, nitrates and ammonia both 0, and we do ~25-30% water
changes weekly. We have been varying the puffer's diet, giving him lots of
seafood like clams, shell-on shrimp, frozen krill, frozen crab legs. I also
always dose his food with Zoe Marine vitamins. He has quickly become my favorite
fish in the tank! The other fish in the tank (which I know both are not brackish
fish, but I have inherited taking care of this tank and doing the 'fish
research' from my fiancé who had these fish in low-end brackish conditions for
the past 5-6 years and never knew they weren't brackish) are one 4" clown loach
(had this guy for about a year and is thriving and growing fast), one ~7" banded
Leporinus and one ~8" red tail tinfoil barb.
<Clown Loaches (according to
Bob Fenner at least) are found in brackish water, and apparently will tolerate
such conditions well; as for the other two species, I suspect in the long term
they will need to be rehoused. To be fair, there are numerous barbs in slightly
brackish water and you may be fine with the Tinfoil Barb, at least for a while,
and if it keeps eating and swimming about normally I'd not worry overly much.
But the Leporinus won't like the salinity at all. I'd strongly suggest lowering
the SG to 1.003; that would be ample for the Pufferfish but not so high the
other species would be stressed, at least not in the short- to medium-term.>
My fiancé (three days ago) purchased a Columbian shark, which he did without
doing research :( just knowing that he was a cute fish and brackish.
<They
are indeed lovely fish. But GREGARIOUS! And how! Singletons are never happy for
long.>
So, when he got home and I did the research, we realized how big this
fish will get, so he is due to return this fish (under my demands!) to the LFS
tomorrow. My question is: when we first got the puffer, he ate voraciously,
every time I put food in the tank. It seems over the past week or so, he's 'gone
off' his food... Because of the bigger fish, I usually hand feed him with
forceps, or put his food into a large net and he swims right in and feeds by
himself in the net. Could it be that the addition of the shark is causing him to
go off his food.
<Possible. But I'd not worry unduly. Once the Shark Catfish
has gone, he should settle down. Shark Catfish do produce low frequency clicking
sounds that sound to many other fish like threats. Have observed this when
keeping them with Triggerfish, and trust me, mayhem ensued!>
He's accepted
none of the shrimp/ crab/ clam that I've offered him the past three nights, and
has only pecked and eaten a little bit of some freeze dried krill I put in there
as a last resort... his belly is still bright, bright white, and he has been
acting normally, other than always keeping an eye on where the Columbian shark
is. The only thing I've noticed is that he always did some flashing off the
heater (he seems to love to rub his little body on it) but have seen no signs of
any external parasites or ich... so he's still doing that flashing type
behavior, but I always thought that that was normal in small doses for puffers.
(Also, his beak looks great and doesn't look overgrown)
<I'd not worry too
much until the Catfish has gone; but I would be alert to Whitespot (Ick) or
Velvet, both diseases that commonly appear after adding new fish. Neither is
normally a problem in brackish water tanks, but I'd keep my eyes open anyway.>
Any help? He used to zip right to the front of the tank whenever I went to feed
the other fish, and I haven't seen this behavior in quite some time. I think
hopefully that once we get the Columbian shark back to the LFS, he'll go back to
feeding as normal. Is feeding him still once a day too much (he is ~2" long)...
I have seen other people feed their puffers every other day?
<The jury is out
about the best way to feed predatory fish including puffers. I'm very much in
the "small meals, but often" camp, though there's no question that in the wild
infrequent big meals is much more typical. With puffers in community situations,
I'd recommend keeping the puffer reasonably well fed so that it doesn't decide
to nip the fins of its tankmates. Perhaps not the best way to keep them in terms
of dietary behaviour in the wild, but a practical approach nonetheless. Cheers,
Neale.>
Fw: Figure 8 puffer question
Sorry, meant to include a
'thanks' in there!
Sandy
<No problems. Cheers, Neale.>
Re: Figure 8 puffer question 9/23/08
Hi,
<Hello!>
I have monitored our puffer over the weekend, he still was not
eating (only took some pecks at some bloodworms as a last ditch effort last
night, he is rejecting all fleshy, meaty foods I've been offering him)... and
I've now noticed a spot (white) that was always present on one of his pectoral
fins appears larger maybe, he is doing a LOT more flashing, and is starting to
clamp his fins...one fin, then the other.
<The white spot could easily be
Finrot, or the begins of, at least. Finrot is specifically blockages of blood
vessels, and these cause tissue to bleed and die, and that's when you start
seeing the red stuff. So I'd be treating for Finrot, using something suitable
for pufferfish, such as Maracyn.>
Starting to really think this may be gill
flukes?!?
<Never, ever encountered this. Certainly possible with wild-caught
fish I suppose. Gill flukes are external parasites (despite seemingly inside the
fish) and can usually be flushed out by changes of salinity. Given you have a
euryhaline puffer species, I'd be doing daily saltwater dips (35 grammes salt
per litre of water of equal temperature to the aquarium; cooking sea salt, tonic
salt, marine mix all fine). Dip for at least 2 minutes and really anything up to
20 minutes. You're fine with the dip until the fish rolls over: then get the
fish out! In theory this is shock to both the fish and gill parasite, but the
fish being bigger (and euryhaline in this case) can tolerate the shock better
than the tiny, stenohaline parasite. Do also see here:
http://www.wetwebmedia.com/fwsubwebindex/fwfshparasites.htm
>
I have done
a little online research, and with the current fish we have in the tank, I don't
want to drastically increase the salt... would something like Coppersafe be okay
for all of my other fish?
<Clown Loaches have a reputation for reacting badly
to copper/formalin medications, so would tend to treat the pufferfish in a QT
tank or via dips in another container of water.>
(none of the other fish are
exhibiting any symptoms). Thanks.
Sandy
<Fundamentally you may be hitting
the wall here re: salinity; these Pufferfish just don't do well in freshwater
conditions, and raising the salinity to what he needs will stress (likely kill)
the Barbs and Loaches. This is often the problem with brackish water fish; it's
not that they can't live in freshwater, they can, but they just become so much
more sensitive to disease that it becomes a constant battle. In any case, would
treat this fish with saltwater dips in the first instance, and secondly be
reviewing conditions in the tank re: the preferences of this species. Cheers,
Neale.>
Re: Figure 8 puffer question 9/25/08
Hi,
<Hello,>
Thanks so much for your prior advice. I, too, think it's Finrot.
Just a minor case though, I think. He has a little bit of signs of 'fraying' of
his fins... plus I 'think' I noticed a little bit of reddening of under his tail
area... but hard to tell. In any case, I really think it was induced not by poor
water quality, but by stress of being in the 55 gallon tank with so many other
fish.
<Social stress is unlikely to cause Finrot, though aggressive
behaviour between fish certainly can. Do keep an open mind about water quality.
Even in big tanks with proper filters, you can have occasional problems with pH
instability or high nitrate levels.>
SO, our 20 gallon (which was a fairly
newly cycled tank, only up for 3 weeks), which housed 4 platys only at the time,
we have decided to use as a hospital tank/ permanent home for our puffer (if he
makes it :!!) We got our pH up to 8.0, and I added ~ a cup of marine salt, just
to slowly bring up the salinity. The platys are now transferred, and we drip
acclimated our puffer, and have now put him into the 20 gallon. He is still
obviously a little freaked out by the transfer, but doesn't look stressed.
<Platies can, will adapt to moderate salinity, but I wouldn't take them above SG
1.005.>
Question is, I bought some Maracyn plus tonight... should I dose the
tank? I am worried that since the tank is so 'newly' cycled, that we may crash
the tank and kill off all the good bacteria.
<Maracyn -- used correctly --
has little to no effect on filter bacteria. Do review instructions on the
packaging carefully, and don't forget to make a (say, 10%) deduction to the
volume of the tank taken up with gravel and rocks.>
But, I don't want to
leave him untreated... I have all the original tank ornaments in there, same
cycled filter media, and also added BioSpira (on the advice of my guy at the pet
store)... plus, he is in a tank w/ aragonite.... should I worry about dosing
with Maracyn plus, or go ahead with it.. thanks SO much. we love this guy!!
<Go for it! Cheers, Neale.>
Re: Figure 8 puffer question 9/25/08
Hi,
Just as
an update to my earlier question, he is in the 20 gallon tank, ph ~8.0, sal
1.002, nitrate/ ammonia both 0.... When I woke up a little while ago and checked
on him, he seems okay, still not responsive to food, and I noticed some stingy
white poo coming from him (never seen that before).... any ideas???
<Could be Hexamita; do see WWM re: Metronidazole/Flagyl for treatment. Hexamita
parasites irritate the gut wall, causing excess production of mucous, and the
faeces end up looking white and stringy. It's primarily observed (in freshwater
tanks) among cichlids, but other fish can exhibit this or related diseases.>
His white spot on his fin is no worse, no better.. but I still haven't added any
medication to his tank yet?? I don't see any more flashing, just the white poo
and also the small spot on his pectoral fin....and the 'weathered' fins (just
his tail fin and pectoral fins look a bit 'weathered' like fin rot???
<A
photo would help here, as these symptoms are a bit vague. Do treat promptly for
Finrot in any event.>
Thanks!
<Cheers, Neale.>